← Library · Wisdom about Beginnings
A Misunderstood Distinction
Wisdom about Beginnings · Nature, Reason, Will
From his file: PMR - PROPOSAL.doc.
A MISUNDERSTOOD DISTINCTION
When distinguishing movers or makers, it is customary to distinguish between nature and reason and between nature and will. Such distinctions are necessary for understanding these causes and their order and, further, for understanding the distinction and order of things whose causes are nature or reason or will. Since all or most things we consider have nature or reason or will as causes, it is not difficult to see the universal importance of these distinctions. If we misunderstand the distinction between nature and reason or that between nature and will, almost all our understanding of things must be adversely affected.
One kind of distinction is found in distinguishing both nature and reason and nature and will. Failure to understand this kind of distinction is fatal. Thomas Aquinas has perhaps best understood the kind of distinction involved here (and consequently the order). An examination of several texts where Thomas explains this distinction is useful, not only to understand the distinction, but also to see the reasons for the kind of distinction involved.
It should not remain hidden from us that many philosophers have either not distinguished nature from reason and will or have misunderstood the distinction. Either defect is serious. But before one enters into a dispute about the distinction, it is useful to see how Thomas sees two possible ways of understanding the distinction and why he rejects one as inadequate or mistaken.
Dr. Duane H. Berquist Assoc. Prof. of Philosophy Assumption College 500 Salibury St. Worcester, Mass. 01609