Ability or Potency in Modern Physical Science

← Library · Natural Philosophy

Ability or Potency in Modern Physical Science

Natural Philosophy · Physics Book 1

From his file: POTENCY & CONTRADICTION.doc.

Word doc

Read from in 1 class

ABILITY OR POTENCY IN MODERN PHYSICAL SCIENCE

Selections from Heisenberg’s Gifford Lectures in Physics and Philosophy, Harper Torchbooks, Harper and Harper, New York:

A first and very interesting step towards a real understanding of quantum theory was taken by Bohr, Kramers and Slater in 1924. These authors tried to solve the apparent contradiction between the wave picture and the particle picture by the concept of the probability wave. The electromagnetic waves were interpreted not as ‘real’ waves but as probability waves, the intensity of which determines in every point the probability for the absorption (or induced emission) of a light quantum by an atom at this point. This idea led to the conclusion that the laws of the conservation of energy and momentum need not be true for the single event, that they are only statistical laws and are true only in the statistical average. This conclusion was not correct, however, and the connection between the wave aspect and the particle aspect of radiation were still more complicated.

But the papers of Bohr, Kramers and Slater revealed one essential feature of the correct interpretation of quantum theory. This concept of the probability wave was something entirely new in mathematical physics since Newton. Probability in mathematics, or in statistical mechanics, means a statement about our degree of knowledge of the actual situation. In throwing dice we do not know the fine details of the motion of our hands which determine the fall of the dice and therefore we say that the probability for throwing a special number is just one in six. The probability wave of Bohr, Kramers, slater, however, meant more than that; it meant a tendency for something. It was a qualitative version of the old concept of ‘potentia’ in Aristotelian philosophy. It introduced something standing in the middle between the idea of an event and the actual event, a strange kind of reality just in the middle between possibility and reality.” (pp. 40-41)

..an intensive study of all questions concerning the interpretation of quantum theory in Copenhagen finally led to a complete and, as many physicists believe, satisfactory clarification of the situation. But it was not a solution which one could easily accept. I remember discussions with Bohr which went through many hours till very late at night and ended almost in despair; and when at the end of the discussion I went alone for a walk in the neighboring park I repeated to myself again and again the question: Can nature possibly be as absurd as it seemed to us in these atomic experiments? (p. 42)

The experiments carried out by means of cosmic radiation or of the big accelerators have revealed new interesting features of matter. Besides the three fundamental building stones of matter - electron, proton, and neutron - new elementary particles have been found which can be created in these processes of highest energies and disappear again after a short time. The new particles have similar properties as the old ones except for their instability. Even the most sable ones have lifetimes roughly only a millionth part of a second, and the lifetimes of others are even a thousand times smaller. At the present time about twenty-five different new elementary particles are known; the most recent one is the negative proton. These reslts seem at first sight to lead away from the idea of the unity of the matter since the number of fundamental units of matter seems again to have increased to values comparable to the umber of different chemical elements. But this would not be a proper interpretation. The experiments have at the same time shown that the particles can be created from other particles or simply from the kinetic energy of such particles, and they can again disintegrate into other particles. actually the experiments have shown the complete mutability of matter. all the elementary particles, at sufficiently high energies, can be transmuted into other particles, or they can simply be created from kinetic energy and can be annihilated into energy, for instance into radiation. Therefore, we have here actually the final proof for the unity of matter. All the elementary particles are made of the same substance, which we may call energy or universal matter; they are just different forms in which matter can appear. If we compare this situation with the Aristotelian concepts of matter and form,we can say that the mater of Aristotle which is merely ‘potentia’, should be compared to our concept of energy, which gets into ‘actuality’ by means of the form, when the elementary particle is created.(pp. 159-160)

...in quantum theory all the classical concepts are, when applied to the atom, just as well and just as little defined as the ‘temperature of the atom’; they are correlated with statistical expectations; only in rare cases may the expectation become the equivalent of certainty. Again, as in classical thermodynamics, it is difficult to call the expectation objective. One might perhaps call it an objective tendency or possibility, a ‘potentia’ in the sense of Aristotelian philosophy. In fact, I believe that the language actually used by physicists when they speak about atomic events produces in their minds similar notion as the concept ‘Potentia’. So the physicists have gradually become accustomed to considering the electronic orbits, etc., not as reality but rather as a kind of ‘potentia’.The language has already adjusted itself, at least to some extent, to this true situation. But it is not a precise language in which one could use the normal logical patterns; it is a language that produces pictures in our mind, but together with them the notion that the pictures have only a vague connection with reality, that they represent only a tendency toward reality.)pp. 180-181)

The vagueness of this language in use among physicists has therefore led to attempts to define a different precise language which follows definite logical patterns in complete conformity with the mathematical scheme of quantum theory. The result of these attempts by Birkhoff and Neumann and more recently by Weizsacker can be stated by saying that the mathematical scheme of quantum theory can be interpreted as an extension of modification of classical logic. It is especially one fundamental principle of classical logic which seems to require a modification. In classical logic it is assumed that, if a statement has any meaning at all, either the statement or the negation of the statement must be true. Of ‘here is a table’ or ‘here is not a table’, either the first or the second must be correct. ‘Tertium non datur’, a third possibility does not exist. It may be that we do not know whether the statement or its negation is correct; but in ‘reality’ one of the two is correct. In quantum theory, this law ‘tertium non datur’ is to be modified. (p. 181)

The ‘states’ corresponding to complementary statements are....called ‘coexistent states’ by Weizsacker. This term ‘coexistent’ describes the situation correctly; it would in fact be difficult to call them ‘different states’, since every state contains to some extent also the other ‘coexistent states’. This concept of ‘state’ would then form a first definition concerning the ontology of quantum theory. One sees at once that this use of the word ‘state’, especially the term ‘coexistent state’, is so different from the usual materialistic ontology that we may doubt whether one is using a convenient terminology. On the other hand, if one considers the word ‘state’ as describing some potentiality rather than a reality - one may even replace the term ‘state’ by the term ‘potentiality’ - then the concept of ‘coexistent potentialities’ is quite plausible, since one potentiality may involve or overlap other potentialities. All these difficult definitions and distinctions can be avoided if one confines the language to the description of facts; i.e., experimental results. However, if one wishes to speak about the atomic particles themselves, one must either use the mathematical scheme as the only supplement to natural language or one must combine it with a language that makes use of a modified logic or of no well-defined logic at all. In the experiments about atomic events we have to do with things and facts, with phenomena that are just as real as nay phenomena in daily life. But the atoms or the elementary particles themselves are not as real; they form a world of potentialities or possibilities rather than one of things or facts. (pp. 185-186)

Louis de Broglie, Matter and Light, Dover Publ., N.Y., p. 272:

And now, to conclude, we can reply to a question such as the following: ‘Do colours exist in the white Light before it passes through the prism which is destined to decompose it?’ We shall reply that they do exist, but only in the way in which a possibility exists before the event which will tell us whether it has in fact been realized. It is a reply of some subtlety, and would certainly have surprised the physicists of yesterday: but it is also characteristic of the degree of keenness and abstraction which has been reached by physical theory today.

From Sir James Jeans lectures also called Physics and Philosophy, p. 95:

The law of the excluded middle entails other disconcerting consequences....From it we learn that at every moment of his life a man must be either young or not-young, so that the transition form young to not-young must occur at a single moment of his life. Thus youth passes away in the twinkling of an eye, and it is the same with the beauty of a woman and the health of an invalid. We reach strange conclusions by following the straight path of formal logic.