About the Subject of Logical Treatises

← Library · Logic as a Whole

About the Subject of Logical Treatises

Logic as a Whole · Subject of Logic

From his file: ABOUT SUBJ. OF LOGICAL TREATISE.doc.

Word doc

ABOUT THE SUBJECT OF LOGICAL TREATISES

Man cannot proceed orderly, easily and without error in his thinking if he does not order his thoughts, just as he cannot imagine or remember in an orderly way without putting order into his images.

Further, man cannot order his thoughts without using words. Words can be used to order our thoughts only insofar as they signify thoughts and things in some way. Hence, every treatise in logic is about words insofar as they signify something and can be used by reason to order its own thoughts about things.

Does it belong to logic to show why man cannot order his thoughts without using words? This why belongs more to the study of the soul or to wisdom. It is enough for the logician to know from experience that it is so. Indeed from experience we know that we do not even know clearly what we think before we express it clearly in words; and, hence, we cannot began to order our thoughts until they and things are signified by words.

Thus statement is defined as speech signifying the true or the false; and definition as speech signifying what a thing is. If arguments are composed of statements, they also will be a form of speech.

But the Categories is not about speech but about names and what they signify. Likewise, the Isagoge is about names and what they signify.

We learn in the Isagoge that when a name is said with one meaning of many things, it is either a genus or a species or a difference or a property or an accident. We learn in the Categories, that when many things are named with one thought in mind about what they are, that name signifies either substance or quantity or quality or towards what or where or when or position or outfitted or acting upon or undergoing.

The Isagoge and the Categories obviously presuppose a more general consideration of names and how they signify things through thoughts

Since names are found in every tool of speech in logic, it is clearly necessary to understand names well.