Common and Private Experience

← Library · Natural Philosophy

Common and Private Experience

Natural Philosophy · Physics Book 1

From his file: COMMON & PRIVATE EXPERIENCE.doc.

Word doc

Read from in 2 classes

COMMON AND PRIVATE EXPERIENCE

Common experience is the experience which all men have and cannot avoid having. All men, for example, have experienced change, wholes and their parts, and pleasure and pain. And they cannot avoid experiencing these.

Private experience is the experienced which only some men have, such as the experience acquired by experiments or by prolonged observation. Private experience is often to be acquired only by special effort and tools although some comes by chance.

Some parts of philosophy do not require any private experience. Our common experience is the only experience required for them. This is especially true of those parts developed by the early Greek natural philosophers and Plato and brought to an ordered whole in Aristotle’s general books on nature and the soul, the eight books of Hearing About Nature (often called the Physics from the Greek word for nature in its title) and his three books On the Soul. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Niels Bohr, Atomic Theory and The Description of Nature, Introductory Survey, Cambridge University Press, p. 1:

The task of science is both to extend the range of our experience and to reduce it to order.

Werner Heisenberg, Gifford Lectures, Physics and Philosophy, Harper, 1958, pp. 149 and 75:

Since the time of Galileo,the fundamental method of natural science had been the experiment. This method made it possible to pass from general experience to specific experience, to single out characteristic events in nature from which its “laws” could be studied more directly than from general experience.

...some statements of ancient philosophy are rather near to those of modern science. This simply shows how far one can get by combining the ordinary experience that we have without doing experiments with the untiring effort to get some logical order into this experience to understand it from general principles.

Pope Paul VI, Encyclical Letter On the Holy Eucharist (Mysterium Fidei):

For by these formulae as by the rest which the Church uses to express the dogmas of faith, concepts are expressed which are not tied to one specific form of human civilization, nor definite period of scientific progress, nor one school of theological thought, but they present what the human mind by universal and necessary experience grasps of realities. For this reason, these formulae are adapted to men of all times

First Book of Natural Hearing, Reading One

Since understanding and knowing why in all sciences of which there are beginnings or causes or elements, come to be from knowing these (for then we think we know each thing when we know its first causes and first beginnings and as far as its elements), it is clear that in the science of nature one should first try to determine about the beginnings.

But the road from the more known and more certain to us to the more certain and more known by nature is inborn. For the known to us and the known simply are not the same. Wherefore it is necessary to go forward in this way from the more uncertain by nature but more certain to us to what is more certain and more known by nature.

But what is first clear and certain for us is the more confused. Afterwards, by dividing it, the elements and the beginnings come to be known from it.

Hence, one should go forward from the general to the particular.

For the whole is more known by sense. And the general is a kind of whole since the general takes in many things as parts.

Names compared to definitions also undergo the same in some way. for they signify some kind of whole and indistinctly; as circle. But the definition of it divides into particulars.

And children first call all men father, and all women mother, but afterwards separate each of these.