← Library · Natural Philosophy
Common
Natural Philosophy · Physics Book 1
From his file: COMMON.doc.
Read from in 2 classes
COMMON
Otto Robert Frisch, “The Interest is Focusing on the Atomic Nucleus” in the collection Niels Bohr, His Life and Work as seen by His Friends and Colleagues, ed. by S. Rozental, Wiley Interscience Publishers, N.Y., pp 140-143:
He never hesitated for a moment to admit that he had been in error; to him it merely meant that he now understood things better, and what could have made him happier..
the most personal contacts we had were on those frequent occasions when Bohr had invited a number of us out to Carlsberg where, sipping our coffee after dinner, we sat close to him - some of us literally at his feet, on the floor - so as not to miss a word. Here, I felt, was Socrates come to life again, tossing us challenges in his gentle way, lifting each argument onto a higher plane, drawing wisdom out of us which we didn’t know was in us (and which, of course, wasn’t). Our conversations ranged from religion to genetics, from politics to art; and when I cycled home through the streets of Copenhagen, fragrant with lilac or wet with rain, I felt intoxicated with the heady spirit of Platonic dialogue.
Leon Rosenfeld, “Niels Bohr in the Thirties” in the collection Niels Bohr, His Life and Work as seen by His Friends and Colleagues, ed. by S. Rozental, Wiley Interscience Publishers, N.Y., pp. 117-120:
His turn of mind was essentially dialectical, rather than reflective; although he did of course spend long hours in solitary thought, often during sleepless nights, he needed the stimulus of some form of dialogue to start off his thinking. If the proposer of the doubt was at hand, the dialogue could be lively enough, for as soon as Bohr saw his way to the elucidation of the matter, he would make his point with unbounded eagerness and tenacity - not at all to get the better of his opponent, but rather to get him to share his own exhiliration at solving the difficulty...So intensely did he feel the excitement of the quest and the joy of achievement that he wanted everyone around him to share them with him. Even after many years he would remember every detail of the argument’s progress, and he would repeatedly tell the story with the same freshness and animation. It was characteristic for these unforgettable conversations, so clearly revealing the essentially dialectical form of his thinking, that he would never try to outline a finished picture, but would patiently go through all the phases of the development of a problem, starting from some apparent paradox and gradually leading to its elucidation...
It was this urge of Bohr’s to look for the deeper logical aspects of the problems presented by the analysis of the physical phenomena. as much as his uncanny intuition for their essential features and his supreme ability to trace at one glance their widest implications, that gave him a unique position among physicists. He was quite conscious of his powers, but his deep humanity, his constant awareness that scientific knowledge is a common good and the search for it a common endeavour, saved him frothe failing so frequent among great men, to shut themselves up in their own vision of the world and become unwilling or incapable of understanding different approaches. On the contrary, Bohr was always most anxious to ‘learn’ (as he expressed it with unfeigned modesty) from others’ ideas: he carefully considered every suggestion and insistently elicited criticism of his own views...This was Bohr’s favourite method of work: to have someone with whom he would feel free to think aloud, on whom he could literally try out the formulation of his ideas, test its adequacy to fulfil the all-important function of communication. From time to time, he would dictate a few sentences, embodying the progress of the argument; these were meant to help the partner, for his own remarkable memory made such records superfluous for himself. In fact, he would hardly ever look at these notes, but woudld rather re-draft the sentences afresh, again and again, with inexhaustible patience, slowly approaching the carefully balanced form he would at long last deem fit for publication.
Thus would week after week pass in this arduous struggle to order our concepts in humble submission to the lessons we learned from Nature: for precisely this was Bohr’s ideal of science and no scientist ever lived up to it with more devotion.
From a discussion between two physicists published in Quanta and Reality Meridian Books, The World Publishing Company, p. 68:
David Bohm:
For I think that philosophy does enter into everything we do. Even if a physicist or any other scientist regards himself as guided purely by empirical considerations, he is none the less a philosopher, following an empiricist philosophy, whether he admits it or not. If you insist on looking merely at the facts, you cannot know whether it is better to be guided only by the facts, or whether it is better to be guided only by general opinions or ideas, or to combine these in some way or other.
Maurice Pryce:
Well, of course, I find my philosophy a little difficult, because my philosophy is to avoid philosophy. I know that even to make that statement is in itself a philosophical statement, so I’m rather in a trap here.
David Bohm:
Yes, that is why I said that no matter what happens you are bound to have some philosophy. it seems to me that the best thing to do is to recognize this as inevitable, to try to understand your own philosophy, to develop it and criticize it, to allow other people to criticize it, and to see if you can’t become free of those arbitrary features which are in it.