← Library · Natural Philosophy
Confused and Distinct Knowledge
Natural Philosophy · Physics Book 1
From his file: CONFUSED & DISTINCT.doc.
CONFUSED AND DISTINCT KNOWLEDGE
The Word Confused
The word confused can mean: (1) mixed-up and mistaken (2) indistinct. When we speak of confused knowledge, we are, of course, using the word confused in its second sense. A mistake is not knowledge, but the opposite.
Order of Confused and Distinct knowledge
Confused knowledge is before distinct knowledge in four ways:
Confused knowledge comes before distinct knowledge in time. Every student sees things in a confused way before (if ever) distinctly.
Confused knowledge is also before distinct knowledge in being. For confused knowledge can be without distinct knowledge, but the reverse is impossible. I can know, for example, that six is a number without knowing that six is a perfect number. But I cannot know that six is a perfect number without knowing that it is a number.
Confused knowledge is before distinct knowledge in the order of learning for distinct knowledge depends upon confused knowledge even though it cannot be deduced from confused knowledge.
Although it is better to have a distinct knowledge of something than a confused knowledge of it, in some respect, confused knowledge is also better than distinct knowledge. For confused knowledge is more sure or certain than distinct knowledge.
An Important Corollary from the Above
Although distinct knowledge is better than confused knowledge, it does not replace confused knowledge. For confused knowledge can be without distinct knowledge, but distinct knowledge cannot be without confused knowledge. And confused knowledge is more sure or certain. And one does not replace the more sure with the less sure, or the sure with unsure.
The Order of Two Main Movements from the Confused to the Distinct
In reasoned out knowledge, we often consider a thing that is both a composed whole and a universal whole. Should we move from the composed whole to its parts before or after we move from the universal whole to its parts? Should we move, for example, from triangle to the definition of triangle before or after we move from triangle to equilateral, isosceles and scalene triangles. Should we move from statement to noun and verb before or after we move from statement to affirmation and negation.?
Euclid defines triangle before dividing it into equilateral, isosceles and scalene. He defines quadrilateral before dividing it into square, oblong rhombus and so on. Aristotle moves from the name nature to the definition of nature before distinguishing nature into matter and form. If the genus can be defined, this definition will helps us to see better the species making differences. Likewise, the composing parts of a genus prepare us for understanding the species. If one did not know that a play has a plot and characters, one could not understand why tragedy and comedy are distinguished by their characters and plot.
An Important Corollary of the Above
Although a general knowledge is to a particular knowledge as the confused is to the distinct, this does not mean that one is not moving from the confused to the distinct when one stays in general knowledge. When one defines the general or divides it into its composing parts, one is moving from the confused to the distinct while staying on the level of the general and without descending to the level of the particular.
An Immediate Application of the Order of confused & Distinct Knowledge
Since the general is to the particular as the confused is to the distinct, general knowledge is before particular knowledge in all the above ways.
The same order is also found for the same reason between knowledge when one can name a thing and knowledge when one can define it.
An Intermediate Application of the Order of confused & Distinct Knowledge
Since knowledge based on common experience (the experience which all men have and cannot avoid having) is to knowledge based on private experience (the experience which only some men have) as general knowledge is to particular knowledge, knowledge based on common experience is before knowledge based on private experience in all the above ways.
Aristotle and Descartes on Certitude of Confused & Distinct
Aristotle's argument:
The more known to us is more certain for us. The confused is more known to us (than the distinct) Therefore, the confused is more certain for us (than the distinct)
Descartes' argument:
The mathematical sciences are more certain (than other sciences) The mathematical sciences are more distinct (than other sciences) Hence, the more distinct is more certain.
Aristotle's argument is a first figure syllogism while Descartes' argument is a third figure enthymeme.
The mathematical sciences are more certain than other sciences because their subject is simpler (involves fewer beginnings) than that of natural science or the sciences of human action and because their subject is separated from matter and change. Hence, the things considered in mathematics are more determined and it is easier to make them distinct by defining and dividing them. Because the matter is simpler and more determined, the private road of mathematics involves more certitude than the road of natural science and even more so than the road of the social sciences.
Nevertheless, even in mathematics there is a passage from the confused to the distinct which is based on the very nature of our reason which goes from ability to act. Hence, we must define and divide even in mathematics. And we are more sure of the confused than of the distinct. We are more sure that 28 is a number than that it is a perfect number. Aristotle is talking about a confused and a distinct knowledge of the same thing.
Why Some Thinkers seek a Distinct Knowledge of the Particular before they have Distinct Knowledge of the General
The causes on the side of desire:
Because they desire to make or do more than to understand. Making or doing is in the particular rather than the general.
Because they are curious about the particular. But this curiosity may be a disordered desire to know.
The causes on the side of reason:
Because they think that general statements are known by induction alone. But reason knows very general statements, not by induction alone, but also by knowing the what it is of the parts of the statements. Thus we know that no even number is odd by understanding what even and odd are, in addition to induction. And we know that every whole is larger than one of its parts by understanding what a whole is and what a part is, in addition to induction from examples of whole and part.
Because they proceed mathematically and by experiment and are accustomed to do so. One can measure and experiment only with the particular.
In natural philosophy, they think that change of place is the only kind of change. And hence, they begin with a particular kind of change.