← Library · Wisdom about Beginnings
Conversation About Beg Of. Phil
Wisdom about Beginnings
From his file: CONVERSATION ABOUT BEG OF. PHIL.doc.
STUDENT: Why is it important to consider the beginnings of philosophy?
TEACHER: Because everything else depends upon the beginnings. If one begins well, one will be helped by this through the whole of philosophy. But even a small mistake in the beginning will be a great one in the end.
STUDENT: Distinguish the beginnings of philosophy
TEACHER: The beginnings of philosophy are either in our ability to know (Which includes the senses and reason) or in our ability to desire which includes the will and the ability to feel emotions.
STUDENT: Distinguish the beginnings in our ability to know.
TEACHER: The beginnings in our ability to know are either about what we know (the thing or things we know) or about how we know them, the way and order in which we know them.
STUDENT: Distinguish the beginnings about things
TEACHER: The beginnings about things are either common to all things or private to the things considered in one reasoned out knowlege
STUDENT: Could you exemplify these two?
TEACHER: Statements such as the same thing cannot both be and not be at the same time and in the same way and nothing is a beginning of itself and a whole is greater than one of its parts and the knowledge of such statements are beginnings commmon to all things.
Statements such as all right angles are equal or every number is odd or even and the knowledge of them are beginnings private to one form of reasoned out knowledge. In this example, the reasoned out knowledge is geometry or arithmetic.
STUDENT: Are the beginnings about things always statements and the knowledge of such statements?
TEACHER: The parts of these statements and the knowledge of them are also beginnings about things
STUDENT:
TEACHER:
DIVISION OF THE BEGINNING IN PHILOSOPHY (AND HUMAN KNOWLEDGE
I. Beginning in the heart or the abilities to desire
A. Remote
1. Love of, desire for, and delight in the beautiful found in the products of the imitative arts.
2. Wonder of the philomuthos
B. Proximate
1. Acts or dispositions necessary whether by oneself or with others.
a. love of wisdom or truth (in will)
b. wonder of philosopher (in will)
c. tranquillity of feelings or emotions (in the ability to feel)
d. joy over truth (in the will)
2. Acts or dispositions necessary in particular towards investigating with, or learning from, others.
a. friendship (in will)
b. pia affectio (in will)
c. docility or teachableness (in will)
d. tranquillity of anger in particular (in ability to feel)