De Broglie - on Zeno's Problems

← Library · Natural Philosophy

De Broglie - on Zeno's Problems

Natural Philosophy · Physics Book 3

Not Berquist’s writing; a text he kept. By Louis de Broglie. From his file: DE BROGLIE - ON ZENO’S PROBLEMS.doc.

Word doc

Louis de Broglie, Matter and Light, Dover Publications, New York, pp. 254-255:

Heisenberg's Principle of Uncertainty asserts that owing to the finite value of the constant h, we cannot know simultaneously and exactly the pairs of conjugate variables, which means (in other words) that the complete description of a mechanical system in terms of Time and Space is incompatible in current science, with the exact specification of the dynamical state.

The impossibility of giving an exact description of the spatio-temporal localization and of the dynamical state, simultaneously, may perhaps be connected with one of the difficulties which troubled ancient philosophers. Let us take an arrow in flight, said Zeno. At any moment it is motionless in a certain position. How then can it follow a certain trajectory? How - that is to say - can motion be constructed out of a series of immobilities?

To the eyes of modern Science, imbued as it was, before the discovery of quanta, with the idea of continuity, the argument from Zeno's arrow used to look rather childish. Consideration of the positions infinitely close to each other occupied by a body in motion does enable us to define the velocity by the same argument as that which serves to establish the existence of the derivative of a continuous function, and velocity is ultimately just the derivative of position with respect to time.

In classical Mechanics, then, the co-ordinates of a moving body at a given instant t, or more generally of a mechanical system, define its spatio-temporal localization, while the derivatives of the co-ordinates with respect to time define its state of motion. Consideration of positions infinitely close to each other, and of the instantaneous uniform motion which permits the transition from one of these to the other, thus seems to open up the way to a complete refutation of Zeno's objection.

But this refutation itself rests on the assumption that physical phenomena are continuous, and is impaired by the introduction of an element of discontinuity into the physical universe like that implied in the existence of the quantum of action.

Without wishing, then, to make Zeno a precursor of Heisenberg, and without forgetting the part played in this problem at the present day by the finite value of Planck's constant, we may still say that the impossibility which recent theories reveal, of assigning simultaneously to a moving body an exact spatio-temporal localization and also a completely defined dynamic state, appears to have some kinship with a philosophical difficulty which has long been familiar.

Albert Einstein, Foreword to Physics and Microphysics by Louis de Broglie, Harper Torchbooks, p. 7:

I found the consideration of Bergson's and Zeno's philosophy from the point of view of the newly acquired concepts highly fascinating.