Dispositions of Desire Necessary for the Philosopher

← Library · Wisdom about Beginnings

Dispositions of Desire Necessary for the Philosopher

Wisdom about Beginnings · Beginning of Philosophy in the Will

From his file: DISPOSITIONS OF DESIRE FOR PHIL.doc.

Word doc

DISPOSITIONS OF DESIRE NECESSARY FOR THE PHILOSOPHER

There are many dispositions of desire[1] necessary for the philosopher. But among them, we can distinguish three central ones in order, around which the others may be considered.

The first of these is wonder. Wonder is nothing other than the natural desire to know for its own sake the cause. Or it is the natural desire to know for its own sake what and why. These two definitions are equivalent for the questions what and why are answered by a knowledge of the cause. Although this wonder is natural to man, it is especially strong in the philosopher. Thus, Democritus said that he would rather discover one cause than be master of the kingdom of the Persians. Socrates or Plato in the Theaetetus and Aristotle in the Metaphysics both note that philosophy began in wonder.

The second central disposition of desire necessary in the philosopher is the love of wisdom. He is indeed named from this love of wisdom. Wonder is not the same as the love of wisdom although it surely prepares for it. Wonder is natural, but the love of wisdom is a chosen love. Hence, Aristotle in the fourth book of the Metaphysics states that the philosopher differs from the sophist by his choice of life. When Hamlet speaks of why he chose Horatio for his friend, he first says "Since my dear soul was mistress of her choice, and could of men distinguish, her election hath sealed thee for herself." Likewise the soul cannot choose to love wisdom before it can distinguish one knowledge from another and see which knowledge is better. We see Aristotle doing this in the beginning of the first book About the Soul where he shows how one knowledge is better than another. And in the Parts of Animals, he discriminates even further. And in the proemium to the Metaphysics, he shows what wisdom is about and why it is better than any other knowledge. The love of wisdom grows as one's knowledge increases and one becomes closer to being wise. But the wonder which is the beginning of wisdom declines as one comes to know the cause or to know what and why.

The third central desire necessary for the philosopher is teachableness. By teachableness here is meant the firm will to hear or read carefully, frequently and with reverence the words of the wise. A philosopher must learn from others. But just as the love of wisdom requires much distinction of one knowledge from another, so teachableness requires much distinction between those whom one should hear or read and those who should be ignored or attended to much less. The classic consideration of this discrimination is in Plato's great dialogue the Protagoras.

----------------------- [1]We are using the word desire here, not to name the act, but the ability for such acts - the will and, to a lesser extent, the ability for emotions.