← Library · Natural Philosophy
Hegel & Jeans-motion-contradict
Natural Philosophy · Physics Book 3
Not Berquist’s writing; a text he kept. By Hegel and Jeans. From his file: HEGEL & JEANS-MOTION-CONTRADICT.doc.
Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel: Outlines of Hegel's Logic Part First, First Division, A. Being, Non-Being, Becoming (Hegel Selections, Charles Scribner's sons, p. 104):
Being is the simple empty immediateness which has its opposite in pure Non-being, and whose union therewith is the Becoming: as transition from Non-being to Being, it is Beginning; the converse is Ceasing.
The "sound common sense," as one-sided abstraction often calls itself, will not admit the union of Being and Non-being. "Either it is Being or it is not. There is no third." "What is, does not begin; what is not, is not. " It asserts, therefore, the impossibility of Beginning.
Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel: The Science of Logic, Book I, The Doctrine of Being, With what must science Begin? (The Philosophy of Hegel, Modern Library, p. 211):
The beginning is not pure nothing, but a nothing from which something is to proceed; so that being is already contained in the beginning. the beginning thus contains both, being and nothing; it is the unity of being and nothing, or is not-being which is being, and being which is also not-being.
Further, being and nothing are present in the beginning as distinct from one another: for the beginning points forward to something other; it is a not-being related to being as to an other: that which is-beginning, as yet is not: it is advancing towards being. The beginning therefore contains being as having this characteristic, that it flies from and transcends not-being, as its opposite.
And further, that which is-beginning, already is, and equally, as yet, is not. The opposites being and not-being are therefore in immediate union in it: in other words, it is the undifferentiated unity of the two. The analysis of the beginning thus yields the concept of the unity of being and not-being.
Sir James Jeans, Physics and Philosophy, p. 95:
The law of the excluded middle entails other disconcerting consequences...From it we learn that at every moment of his life a man must be either young or not-young, so that the transition from young to not-young must occur at a single moment of his life. Thus youth passes away in the twinkling of an eye, and it is the same with the beauty of a woman and the health of an invalid. We reach strange conclusions following the straight path of formal logic.