Learning is by Recalling
Logic as a Whole
From his file: LearningIsByRecalling.pdf.
Read from in 1 class
Learning is by Recalling Duane H. Berquist All teaching and all learning by reason come to be from pre-existent knowledge. This is clear to those looking at all. For the mathematical forms of reasoned out knowledge come about in this way and each of the other arts. And likewise in the conversations by syllogisms and those by induction. For both teach through what was known before: these taking from what is understood, and those showing the universal through the singular that is clear. And in the same way speakers persuade. For they do so either through examples which is induction or through enthymemes which is syllogism.1 ⁂ It happens to the one learning geometry to foreknow, but he knows nothing before of that of which there is reasoned out knowledge and about which he is going to learn. So it is in others…. For all learning is through the foreknown, either all or some, both that by demonstration and that by definitions (for it is necessary to understand and know before that from which is the definition). Likewise, also that through induction.2 ⁂ Thomas Aquinas, In I Metaphysicorum, Lectio XVII, n. 268. Nullus enim praecognoscit illud quod addiscere debet; sicut geometra, etsi praecognoscat alia quae sunt necessaria ad demonstrandum, tamen ea quae debet addiscere non debet praecognoscere. Et similiter est in aliiis scientiis…. Unde si ponatur quod aliquis addiscat, oportet quod non praexistat cognoscens illa quae addiscit, sed quaedam alia cum quibus fiat disciplinatus, idest addiscens praecognita “omnia”, idest universalia “aut quae1Aristotle, Posterior Analytics, Book One, Lect. 1. 2Aristotle, Metaphysics, Book One, 992b 26–33.
No one foreknows that which he ought to learn: as the geometer, although he foreknows other things which are necessary for demonstrating, nevertheless he ought not to foreknow those things which he ought to learn. And it is likewise in the other forms of reasoned out knowledge…. Whence if it is laid down that someone learns, it is necessary that he be not knowing beforehand those things which he is going to learn, but other things
dam”, idest singularia. Universalia quidem, sicut in his quae addiscuntur per demonstrationem et definitionem; nam oportet sicut in demonstrationibus, ita in definitionbus esse praecognita ea, ex quibus definitiones fiunt, quae sunt universalia; singularia vero oportet esse praecognita in his quae discuntur per inductionem.
with which he becomes taught, namely “all”, that is universals, “or some”, that is singulars. Universals, as in those which are learned by demonstration and definition, for just as in demonstrations, so also in definitions it is necessary that those things from which definitions come to be, be known before, and these are universals. But in those things which are learned by induction, it is necessary that singulars be known before.