← Library · Wisdom about Beginnings
Liberal Education Foreword
Wisdom about Beginnings · Beginnings Misc
From his file: TRIVIUM TALK.doc.
Read from in 1 class
LIBERAL EDUCATION FOREWORD
Liberal education can be defined in two ways, by the evil from which it frees us or by the good to which it leads us. Both ways are connected with the origin of the word liberal. The word liberal, like the word liberty, comes from the Latin word liber meaning free. Both ways in which we could define liberal education depend upon a likeness to the distinction between the free man and the slave. The free man is not enslaved and he exists for his own good while the slave exists for the good of another, the good of his master, and hence is a slave. An education is called liberal by likeness to the free man as opposed to the slave. A liberal education is one that frees us from many forms of slavery and is desirable for its own sake.
A liberal education is an education that frees, or helps to free, us from slavery, not slavery in the original sense (which may require a civil war), but other forms of slavery. There are four forms of slavery from which a liberal education frees us or, at least, helps to free us. Men are often enslaved to disordered emotions, to fashion, to custom and to many errors. A liberal education helps to free us from all these forms of slavery. This is to define liberal education by the evil from which it frees us.
But it can also be defined by the good to which it leads us. The slave does not exist for his own sake, but for the sake of another, his master. But the master or free man exists for his own sake. By likeness to this, a liberal education is one that is desirable for its own sake. What does this mean? It means that in liberal education the end is the knowing itself, the end is to know wonderful and beautiful things.
Let us examine liberal education first by the evil from which it frees us and then from the good to which it brings us. FIRST PART
The first form of slavery is to disordered or excessive passions and desires. Hamlet chose Horatio as his friend because he was free from this slavery:
Give me that man that is not passion's slave And I will wear him in my heart, ay in my heart of heart, as I do thee.
The second form of slavery is to fashion. A man is a slave of fashion when he pursues the fashionable because it is fashionable. One should not read an author because he is our contemporary anymore than not read him because he is our contemporary He is even more a slave of fashion when he pursues the lesser good because it is fashionable rather than the greater good which is not fashionable. Speaking of the influence of fashion upon men in Troilus and Cressida, Shakespeare says they Give to dust that is a little gilt more laud than gilt o'er dusted
One is most of all a slave of fashion when on pursues the bad because it is fashionable. In some high schools, it has become fashionable to pretend your are bi-sexual. How many in our time do what is bad because it is fashionable or cease doing what is good because it is no longer fashionable.
The third form of slavery is to custom. One is a slave to custom when it narrows one's interest and abilities to lesser goods and cuts one off from the better things in life. Men who are accustomed to only one way of thinking become slaves to this one way of thinking. And what cannot be known in this same way becomes a closed door to them. Custom can make a statement in need of proof seem obvious. It can even make a falsehood seem true. It is no wonder that Shakespeare sometimes calls custom a tyrant.
The fourth form of slavery is to error or mistake which comes from the aforesaid and from pride and false imagination and false reasoning. A slave is not ruled for his own good, but for the good of his master. When reason is ruled by an error, it is not for its good. This is misrule.
Now in what does a liberal education consist that it can free or help to free us from these four forms of slavery?
Liberal education involves catharsis and listening to the music or reading the words of those who have followed nature. We need to speak of both of these.
Catharsis (to use the Greek Word) or purgation (to use the Latin word) is originally a medical term for removing a harmful substance from the body. If one swallows poison, one needs a medical catharsis or purgation. Liberal education involves three other kinds of catharsis or purgation.
The first catharsis is one of the emotions. This is first achieved in liberal education by listening to and playing music that represents the emotions in a reasonable and noble disposition and so moves our emotions. This is the music of Mozart and Handel and Bach and Palestrina and Gregorian chant and other great music of the classical and Baroque and earlier periods.
When King George the II attended the first London performance at Covent Garden of the Messiah of Handel, at the Hallelujah Chorus", he was so overcome by its grandeur that he rose to his feet and remained standing until its conclusion. That was the beginning of his liberal education. Indeed, Handel himself said that when he wrote this chorus, "I did think I did see all Heaven before me, and the Great God Himself."
By listening to the music of Mozart, for another example, we begin to be freed from slavery to our passions and are no longer slaves of fashion, listening to inferior or bad music because it is fashionable in our time. Tortured souls of latter times can reach out of their time and go back to Mozart. Pyotr Ilich Tchaikovsky went back from his century to Mozart (Mozartiana and weeping at G minor quintet) In a letter to Nadejda von Meck:
You say that my worship for Mozart is quite contrary to my musical nature. but perhaps it is just because - being a child of my day - I feel broken and spiritually out of joint, that I find consolation and rest in Mozart’s music, wherein he gives expression to that joy of life which was part of his sane and wholesome temperament.
The second way that liberal education achieves a catharsis of our emotions is by reading the best fiction.
Aristotle defined tragedy by the catharsis of our emotions that it produces. Good comedy produces another catharsis of the emotions. Pope John Paul I said with wonderfully clear understatement that, after seeing Oedipus the King performed, one is anything, but enthusiastic about incest.
Shakespeare tells us in Hamlet that a good play should be as wholesome as sweet, it should be as morally healthy as it is pleasing to the senses and imagination. Pope Paul VI says in his Conversations with Guitton that to read Shakespeare is a moral education.
Rock and roll music and pornographic films and fiction enslave men to their passions while education in good music and fiction helps man get control of his passions.
The second catharsis in liberal education is that of the imagination. If the imagination is not filled with good images by great fiction, it will be occupied by harmful and sinful images. Here again it is important to read good authors. Take, for example, our first and perhaps greatest writer, Washington Irving.
Charles Dudley Warner, Washington Irving, A Biographical and Critical Study:
I should be untrue to my own conception of one of the most potent forces in Irving's literature, if I did not speak of his moral quality....you cannot account for Irving's influence in the world without it...Irving's literature, walk around it and measure it by whatever critical instruments you will, is a beneficent literature. The author loved good women and little children and a pure life; he had faith in his fellow men, a kindly sympathy with the lowest, without any subservience to the highest; he retained a belief in the possibility of chivalrous actions, and did not care to envelop them in a cynical suspicion; he was an author still capable of an enthusiasm. His books are wholesome, full of sweetness and charm, of humor without any sting, of amusement without any stain; and their more solid qualities are marred by neither pedantry nor pretension.
Listen to this description by Emily (Foster) Fuller of the visits of Irving later in life to their house in London: (Life and Letters of Washington Irving, Volume III, Chapter XXI, p. 291)
Every spare evening he had he spent at our house. He was still the same! time changed him very little. His conversation was as interesting as ever; his dark-grey eyes still full of varying feeling; his smile half playful, half melancholy, but ever kind.
All that was mean, or envious, or harsh, he seemed to turn away from so completely that when with him, it seemed such things were not.
All gentle and tender affections, Nature in her sweetest or grandest moods, pervaded his whole imagination, and left no place for low or evil thoughts;
and when in good spirits, his humor, his droll descriptions, and his fun would make the gravest or the saddest laugh.
Thomas gives as one of the many reasons why Sacred Scripture uses metaphors to bring the imagination into the service of God.
The third kind of catharsis in liberal education is the catharsis of reason. Liberal education introduces us to the examination conversation which was developed by Socrates to purge one's reason of errors through one's own admissions. In this conversation, the man who is in error contradicts himself by his other admissions and in this way comes to recognize his mistake and become free of it. Logic is an essential part of liberal education and there we learn to recognize with Aristotle the ways in which reason is deceived. This helps both to prevent errors and to recognize them when they have been made. Euclid's elements are fundamental in liberal education. Geometry disciplines the imagination, the great cause of error. And in geometry, we first learn to understand proportions. This is one of the main keys to knowledge and to avoiding error. Most discoveries in science and philosophy and theology are made by seeing a proportion. But many errors comes from bad proportions or from good ones misunderstood. In general, liberal education consists in reading carefully and understanding the words of the wisest men. But it belongs to the wise to refute the most fundamental and dangerous errors. It is the wise, especially, who free us from errors or prevent us from erring.
We have said that liberal education frees us from many forms of slavery by catharsis and also by listening to the music or reading the words of those who follow nature. Having seen the three kinds of catharsis that liberal education provides (the catharsis of the emotions, of the imagination and of the reason), we can now consider how it frees us from slavery to fashion and custom by listening to the music or reading the words of those who follow nature.
Let us take an example of a musician, a poet and a philosopher who followed nature and whose music or words must be listened to or read carefully, frequently and with reverence as a part of liberal education.
For an example of a musician whose works should be listened to as a part of a liberal education, let us take Mozart. Mozart was a musician who followed nature. Mozart understood well that he had to follow nature. In a letter (June 12, 1778) to his father, also a musician and composer, the twenty-two year old Mozart writes
The human voice trembles naturally - but in its own way - and only to such a degree that the effect is beautiful. Such is the nature of the voice, and people imitate it not only on wind instruments, but on string instruments too, and even on the clavier. But the moment the proper limit is overstepped, it is no longer beautiful - because it is contrary to nature.
Albert Einstein, the most famous scientist of the twentieth century, has an interesting comment on Mozart's music in comparison to Beethoven's that gives testimony to the natural character of Mozart's music:
Mozart is the greatest composer of all. Beethoven ëcreatedí his music, but the music of Mozart is of such purity and beauty that one feels he merely found it - that it has always existed as a part of the inner beauty of the universe waiting to be revealed.
Such music avoids the limitations of fashion and custom.
Let us turn now to the example of a poet whose works are an important part of liberal education because he followed nature. Shakespeare's similes strike one like Mozart's music strikes Einstein. They are so beautiful and apt that they seem to be natural and found by Shakespeare rather than invented by him. Let me give one example of this. What simile would express beautifully the tragic feeling we would have if our only child, a beautiful young daughter, on the very morning of her wedding, that happy day, was found dead in her bed. In Romeo and Juliet, Shakespeare says it thus: "Death lies on her like an untimely frost upon the sweetest flower of all the field." It is natural to compare a young beautiful virgin to a flower and, hence, her untimely departure to the most beautiful flower of the field destroyed by an untimely frost. Indeed the hand of death is cold.
In the Introduction to the New Hudson Edition of As You Like It, there is an interesting description of Shakespeare as a poet that brings out well why he should be a part of liberal education, of an education that frees us from slavery to fashion and custom and error
Shakespeare generally preferred to make up his plots and stories out of materials as were most familiar to his audience. Of this we have many examples, but the fact is too well known to need dwelling upon. Though surpassingly rich in fertility and force of invention, he was not withstanding singularly economical and sparing in the use of it; which aptly shows how free he was from everything like a sensational spirit or habit of mind. Nature was everything to him, novelty nothing or next to nothing. The true, not the new, was always the soul of his purpose. Than this nothing could better approve the moral healthiness of his genius; hence, in great part his noble superiority to the intellectual and literary fashions of his time. He understood these perfectly, but he deliberately rejected them, or rather struck quite above or beyond them. We rarely meet with anything that savors of modishness in his workmanship. Probably the best judgment ever pronounced upon him is Ben Jonson's, "He was not of an age, but for all time." For even so it is with the permanences of our intellectual and imaginative being that he deals, and not with any transiencies of popular or fashionable excitement or pursuit. And as he cared little for the new, so he was all the stronger in that which does not grow old and which lives on from age to age in the perennial, unwithering freshness of truth and nature. To be carried hither and thither by the shifting mental epidemics of the day is but a tacit confession of weakness or disease; it only proves that one has not strength of mind to "feel the soul of nature," or to live at peace with the solidities of reason. And because the attractions of mere novelty had no force with Shakespeare, because his mind dwelt far above the currents of intellectual fashion and convention, his dramas stand "exempt from the wrongs of time"; and the study of them is a wholesome discipline in those forms and sources of interest which underlie and outlast all the flitting specialties of mode and custom -
"Truths that wake, To perish never; Which neither listlessness, nor mad endeavour Nor Man nor Boy, Nor all that is at enmity with joy, Can utterly abolish or destroy!"
After the poets or makers of fiction who followed nature, we could go to the philosophers who followed nature. All such philosophers are in the tradition of Heraclitus who said:
Wisdom is to speak the truth and to act according to nature, giving ear thereto.
Such philosophers rise above custom. It was Plato in his last work the Laws who has the Athenian stranger propose a law against homosexuality because it is against nature. Here we see Plato rising above the influence of the pagan customs of his time and rejecting an error by basing himself on nature.
We have illustrated a little that definition of liberal education as one that frees us from slavery to disordered passion, fashion, custom and error.
SECOND PART
But let us turn to the second definition of liberal education which is not in terms of the evil or slavery from which it frees us, but it terms of the good it bestows upon us. Liberal education aims at the good of reason rather than the good of the body or the good of our exterior possessions. Liberal education gives us a knowledge of wonderful and beautiful things. rather than a knowledge which is useful for improving our body or house or bank account.
An objection is sometimes made against this aspect of liberal education: it is not practical. Man needs to do and make all kinds of things. We need to make a living. But liberal education does not prepare one to do or make something. Rather it ends with knowing wonderful and beautiful things, with a knowledge that is useless for making and doing things.
To this objection. three things should be said.
First, liberal education is not the only thing which is pursued, or needs to be pursued, by the man who pursues it. Our headmaster has some knowledge of carpentry. I have known liberally educated men who can repair an automobile, believe it or not. Granted, it was not by their liberal education. But it is stupid to reject any human activity because it does not satisfy every human need. It is stupid because nothing that we do satisfies everything we need. If one rejected everything that does not satisfy everything we need, you would have to reject anything that we do. This is clearly stupid. And can it be said that we have no time for liberal education when the average American is enslaved to his TV for 25 to 30 hours a week. Someone recently described the TV as "an instrument for idiocy and evil unparalleled in human history."
Second, it is not altogether true that a liberal education is impractical. A student of mine who has made a special study of St. Thomas More, Dr Gerard Wegemer of the University of Dallas, has written that:
Thomas More attributed his success in law, politics and international diplomacy to his study of the liberal arts. Erasmus agreed that the liberal arts were responsible for More's success in combining "so much real wisdom with such charm of character {that} it would be hard to find anyone who was more truly a man for all seasons."...
As More put it, the liberal arts can "prepare the soul for virtue." They can quicken the reason; they can form and perfect good judgment; they can clarify the highest principles which "both instruct and inspire the mind in the pursuit of virtue"; they can develop prudence in human affairs.
Prudence, or foresight, is the virtue of reason that perfects reason in regard to doing, just as art perfects reason as regards making. Hence, it is not true that liberal education is useless as far as the practical is concerned. For the practical is divided into doing and making and a liberal education seems to prepare one the best for doing. Even business many times prefers liberal arts majors for positions of responsibility in doing.
And third, there are very good reasons for pursuing a liberal education to the extent one can; indeed, three reasons.
First, liberal education is in accord with nature. Men are perverse when they do not follow nature. Nothing is more opposed to nature in general, or to the nature of a woman in particular, than abortion. Likewise, Plato rightly rejects homosexuality as against nature. But if we rightly reject these perversions because they are against nature it is because we respect nature which is something of the divine art in things by which they are moved to suitable ends through determined means.
But man has a natural desire to know apart from doing or making. This is shown by his wonder and his love of the beautiful.
Why does everyone look at a beautiful sunset? Can they make or do something with this knowledge? No. Further, they sometimes look at something beautiful to the detriment of what they are doing, as the man who looks at the mountains or the ocean when he is driving.
Why do children and men wonder how a story will turn out? because they are going to do or make something with how the story turns out?
And if you and I watched the Super Bowl last Sunday, is it because it will help us to decide what to do or make on the job Monday?
A natural desire cannot be in vain, or its object impossible of achieving. This can be seen in other natural desires such as hunger and thirst. It is naturally good, then, and possible for man to pursue a liberal education.
The second reason why we should pursue such knowledge is because this is the only way to be true to ourselves. Man is the only animal that wonders and loves the beautiful. The beast takes no delight in the beautiful. The beast has no painting, no music, no fiction, no admiration of the sunset. The beast does not wonder about things. The beast seeks knowledge only for practical reasons. Tabitha, my daughter's cat, sleeps through a performance of Mozart, but is at my feet when I bring out the sandwich meat from the refrigerator.
Albert Einstein, The World As I See It, 1931:
The most beautiful experience we can have is of the mysterious. It...stands at the cradle of true art and true science. Whoever does not know it and can no longer wonder, no longer marvel, is as good as dead, and his eyes are dimmed.
It is not hunger or thirst or the desire to get warm these days that separates us from the beast, but wonder and the love of the beautiful. Satisfying the former desires is necessary, but it cannot satisfy us as a human being.
The third reason is that only wonder and the love of the beautiful leads us to God on the side of reason. Socrates hints beautifully at this when he notes that wonder is the beginning of philosophy
Plato, Theaetetus, 155C-D:
Theaetetus:
By the gods, Socrates, how greatly I wonder what these things are and sometimes when looking at them, I am really dizzy.
Socrates:
Theodorus seems to guess not badly about your nature, my friend. For this wonder is very much the undergoing of a philosopher. There is no other beginning of philosophy than this. And the one saying that Iris is the offspring of Thaumas did not make a bad genealogy. But do you begin to understand why these things are so?
A fourth reason, the other side of the coin, is that the rejection of knowledge for its own sake, of knowledge that is not a knowledge of how to make, leads to a man centered world. Since man is the beginning and the end of what he makes, to limit the pursuit of knowledge to such knowledge is to make man the beginning and end of all that he thinks about. This was, as Engels informs, the germ of the Marxist world outlook. It leads to the error that man is the measure of all things, contrary to what Plato teaches us in the Laws, that God is the measure of all things.
A fifth reason is the harmony of this with the supernatural end of man. Consider Christ's words in THE GOSPEL ACCORDING TO ST. LUKE, CHAPTER TEN, VERSES 38-42:
Now it came to pass as they were on their journey, that he entered a certain village; and a woman named Martha welcomed him to her house. And she had a sister called Mary, who also seated herself at the Lordís feet and listened to his word. But Martha was busy about much serving. And she came up and said. "Lord, is it no concern of thine that my sister has left me to serve alone? Tell her therefore to help me." But the Lord answered and said to her, "Martha, Martha, thou art anxious and troubled about many things; and yet only one thing is necessary. Mary has chosen the best part, and it will not be taken away from her."
THE GOSPEL ACCORDING TO ST. JOHN, CHAPTER SEVENTEEN, VERSES 1-3:
These things Jesus spoke; and raising his eyes to heaven, he said, "Father, the hour has come! Glorify thy Son, that thy Son may glorify thee, even as thou hast given him power over all flesh, in order that to all thou hast given him he may give everlasting life. Now this is everlasting life that they may know thee, the only true God, and him whom thou hast sent, Jesus Christ."
The second Vatican Council is known as a pastoral council because it has much to say about the practical. But in the first document of Vatican II, the CONSTITUTION ON THE SACRED LITURGY ( N. 2, IN THE TEACHINGS OF THE SECOND VATICAN COUNCIL, THE NEWMAN PRESS, 1966, p.. 14) we have this statement on the nature of the Church:
It is of the essence of the Church that she be both human and divine, visible and yet invisibly equipped, eager to act and yet intent on contemplation, present in this world and yet not at home in it; and she is all these things in such wise that in her the human is directed and subordinated to the divine, the visible likewise to the invisible, action to contemplation, and this present world to that city yet to come which we seek.
Granted that it is better to be joined to God by love than by knowledge in this life, yet knowing God is a help to loving Him and the one who loves God wants to know Him better. The danger in liberal education is that one's knowledge may be an occasion of pride or haughtiness.