Logic to Sebastian

← Library · Logic as a Whole

Logic to Sebastian

Logic as a Whole · Subject of Logic

From his file: LOGIC TO SEBASTIAN.doc.

Word doc

Read from in 1 class

There are places where Thomas will say that logic is about beings of reason or relations of reason of one kind. And many have picked up on these words. And there are places where Avicenna and Albert say that logic is about things insofar as they are in reason. Hence, Albert says that the first thing to be considered in logic is the universal for to be universal (common to many and said of many) is what happens to things insofar as they are in reason. Hence, Boethius says well that a thing is singular when sensed and universal when understood. Now all of these statements are true.

But when we turn to the books of the father of logic, we find that he is talking up front about words in a certain way. Logic is about three acts of reason as a remote matter, but more proximately about the tools that perfect these three acts: definition, statement and syllogism. And the logos which is the genus in the definition of each of them is speech (vocal sound signifying by agreement having parts that signify by themselves). This is especially clear in the Peri Hermeneias. Logic is also about the names that compose these speeches as about noun and verb that compose a statement and about genus and difference that compose a definition. And the book called the Categories is in general about names signifying things through thoughts, but this must be made more particular. And the Isagoge of Porphyry can be considered to be a distinction of name said univocally, or with the exact same meaning in mind, of many things. And instead of saying that the universal is the first thing to be considered in logic, one could say in a more sensible way that name said of many things is the first thing to be considered in logic for both the name of the defined and the names in the definition are names said of many things.

Man is not reason, but an animal that has reason. Hence, he needs a sensible tool to order his thoughts. But this does not contradict what Thomas and Albert say elsewhere that logic is about. For even the sensible way of saying what logic is about does not say that it is about words period. The Categories is about words signifying things through thoughts so that what happens to things insofar as they are in reason (to be universal, to be the subject or predicate of a statement, to be a middle term or minor term or major term) enters into logic essentially. And likewise one could say that, if logic is about words signifying things through thoughts, it is about the relations of reason which things have in our reason or through being thought about.

In the sensible way of speaking about logic, we can say that it is one of the arts about using words.

Grammar is about using words to make sentences in some language. Hence, it is also about the distinction of the parts of speech used in making sentences.

Logic is about using words to order our thoughts about things. Words can be used in this way because they signify things through thoughts.

Rhetoric is about using words to persuade the crowd or the jury or the assembly

The poetic art or the art of fiction is about using words to imitate the doings of men in a pleasing way