Looking Before & After and the Beginning

← Library · Wisdom about Beginnings

Looking Before & After and the Beginning

Wisdom about Beginnings · Beginnings Misc

From his file: S & H ON LOOKING BEFORE & AFTER.doc.

Word doc

LOOKING BEFORE & AFTER AND THE BEGINNING

Foreword

In the first issue of Περιπατητικός we had gathered chief texts from Plato, Aristotle, Thomas Aquinas, and Albert the Great on the necessity and importance of beginning well. (If those texts are not enough to convince someone in the tradition that nothing is more necessary in philosophy than to begin well, let them begin badly.) And we promised to say something about looking before and after in Shakespeare and Homer and the connection of looking before and after with beginning well.

Looking Before and After in Shakespeare and Homer

Nowhere does the importance of looking before and after appear with more universality and force in Shakespeare than in Hamlet's Exhortation to Use Reason. On seven lines of blank verse (unrhymed iambic pentameter), but amounting to six lines of blank verse (since the exhortation begins on the seventh syllable of the first line and ends on the sixth syllable of the seventh line), Shakespeare has given us what may well be the best short exhortation to use reason ever written. These seven lines are found in Hamlet, Act IV, Sc. 4:

........................................What is a man, If his chief good and market of his time Be but to sleep and feed: a beast, no more. Sure he that made us with such large discourse, Looking before and after, gave us not That capability and god-like reason To fust in us un’used.

We have explained this exhortation at length elsewhere (especially at the summer, 1994 meeting of the Society for Aristotelian Studies at St. Anselm's College in New Hampshire) and extended there (and do so again now) an invitation for anyone to find a better short exhortation to use reason than the above. Shakespeare uses less than fifty words (49 to be exact) and it would be very difficult, if not impossible, to find a better exhortation in less than fifty words (or, even in less than one hundred). But members of the Society are encouraged to submit to the Περιπατητικός a better short exhortation if they know of one. Since the philosopher is a lover of wisdom and wisdom is the highest perfection of reason, it belongs most of all to the philosopher to find the best exhortation(s) to use reason.

Theobald, one of the best of the early editors of Shakespeare's plays, had spoken of the phrase "Looking before and after" as being "an expression purely Homeric." And indeed, if we look at the Iliad and the Odyssey, we do find a similar phrase. In the Iliad, when Agamemnon has offended Achilles to the point of causing the latter's withdrawal from fighting (and the subsequent turning of the battle against the Achaeans) Achilles says of Agamemnon in Book One, lines 342-344 (Lattimore trans. used for the quotes from Homer):

...| γὰρ ὅγ’ ὀλοιῇσι φρεσὶ θύει οὐδέ τι οἶδε νοῆσαι ἅμα πρόσσω καὶ ὀπίσσω ὅπτως οἱ παρὰ νηυσὶ σόοι μαχέοιντο Ἀχαιοί

...For surely in ruinous heart he makes sacrifice and has not wit enough to look behind and before him that the Achaians fighting beside their ships shall not perish.

And later, when Achilles is about to re-enter the battle after the death of Patroklos, the Trojans make the fatal mistake of listening to Hector who wants to remain encamped on the plains rather than to get back into the city behinds its walls as advised by Poulydamas. Homer uses almost the same phrase (Iliad, Book XVIII, lines 249-250):

τοῖσι δὲ Πουλυδάμας πεπνυμένος |ρχ’ ἀγορεύειν Πανθοίδης· ὁ γὰρ οἶος ὅρα πρόσσω καὶ ὀπίσσω.

First to speak among them was the careful Poulydamas, Panthoos' son, who alone of them looked before and behind him.

Poulydamas advises them with good reason to get back into the city before Achilles re-enters the battle, but he is over-ruled by Hector. Homer comments (Book XVIII, lines 310-313):

"`Wß "´Ektwr ἀγόρευ’, ἐπὶ δὲ Τρῶες κελάδησαν νήπιοι· ἐκ γάρ σφεων φρένας εἵλετο Παλλὰς Ἀθήνη. "´Ektori mèn gàr ëpjnhsan κακὰ μητιόωντι, Πουλυδάμαντι δ’ ἄρ’ οὔτις, +ß ἐσθλὴν φράζετο Βουλήν.

So spoke Hektor, and the Trojans thundered to hear him; fools, since Pallas Athene had taken away the wits from them. They gave their applause to Hektor in his counsel of evil, but none to Poulydamas, who had spoken good sense before them.

The next day, of course, Achilles mows them down.

Since foresight or prudence requires experience and this comes with age, Homer rightly speaks of the older as more looking forwards and backwards, before and behind, than the young. In the Iliad, Book III. 105-110, we find the distinction between the young and the old:

ἄξετε δὲ Πριάμοιο βίην, ὄφρ’ ὅρκια τάμνῃ αὐτὸς, ἐπεί οἱ παῖδες ὑπερφίαλοι καὶ ἄπιστοι, μή τις ὑπερβασίῃ Διὸς ὅρκια δηλήσηται. αἰεὶ δ’ ὁ γέρων μετέῃσιν, ἅμα πρόσσω καὶ ὀπίσσω λεύσσει, ὅπως ὄχ’ ἄριστα μετ’ ἀμφοτέροισι γένηται.

Bring, that he may seal the pledges, the strength of Priam: Priam himself, for his sons are outrageous, not to be trusted; lest some man overstep Zeus' oaths, and make them nothing. Always it is, that the hearts in the younger men are frivolous, but when an elder man is among them, he looks behind him and in front, so that all comes out far better for both sides.

We find this same ability attributed again to the old in the Odyssey, Book 24, vv. 451-452:

τοῖσι δὲ καὶ μετέειπε γέρων ἥρως "Αλιθέρσης Μαστορίδης· ὁ γὰρ οἶος ὅρα πρόσσω καὶ ὀπίσσω.

Then among them spoke the old lord Halitherses, son of Mastor, for he alone saw before and after.[Loeb trans.]

Now Halitherses, Mastor's son, an aged warrior, spoke to them. He alone saw what was before and behind him.[Lattimore]

Socrates refers to these words of Homer as to the importance of looking before and after in the Cratylus, 428D:

τὸ γὰρ ἐξαπατᾶσθαι αὐτὸν ὑφ’ αὑτοῦ πάντων χαλεπώτατον· ὅταν γὰρ μηδὲ σμικρὸν ἀποστατῇ, ἀλλ’ ἀεὶ παρῇ ὁ ἐξαπατήσων, πῶς οὐ δεινόν; δεῖ δή, ὡς ἔοικε, θαμὰ μεταστρέφεσθαι ἐπὶ τὰ προειρημένα, καὶ πειρᾶσθαι, τὸ ἐκείνου τοῦ ποιητοῦ, βλέπειν ἅμα πρόσσω καὶ ὀπίσσω.

To be deceived by one self is the most dangerous of all. For when the deceiver is never distant, but always present, how could it not be terrible? It is necessary, as it seems, to turn back often to what has been said and to try, as the poet says, to look at the same time forwards and backwards.

Homer's phrase uses words that are not as easily carried over as the words before and after in Hamlet's Exhortation. It is only after we have understood (in Chapter 12 of the Categories) the order in which the word before is carried over that we can begin to see how looking before and after is a beginning of the whole of philosophy. But these are matters for the consideration of Hamlet's Exhortation and the definition of reason contained therein.

Another way in which before and after are connected with Homer can be seen from the words of Aristotle in his book About the Poetic Art (usually called the Poetics) Aristotle taught that (1) the plot is the beginning and the soul of tragedy (Poetics, Chapter VI, 1450a 37-38):

ἀρχὴ μὲν οὖν καὶ οἷον ψυχὴ ὁ μῦθος τῆς τραγῳδίας, δεύτερον δὲ τὰ \qh:

The plot then is the beginning and as the soul of tragedy while character is second.

Likewise, he taught that (2) the plot must be a whole, having a beginning, middle and an end (Poetics, Chapter VII, 1450b 24-32):

κεῖται δὴ ἡμῖν τὴν τραγῳδίαν τελείας καὶ ὅλης πράξεως εἶναι μίμησιν ἐχούσης τι μέγεθος· ἔστιν γὰρ ὅλον καὶ μηδὲν ἔχον μέγεθος. ὅλον δὲ ἐστιν τὸ ἔχον ἀρχὴν καὶ μέσον καὶ τελευτήν. ἀρχὴ δέ ἐστιν + αὐτὸ μὲν μὴ ἐξ ἀνάγκης μετ’ ἄλλο ἐστίν, μετ’ ἐκεῖνο δ’ ἕτερον πέφυκεν εἶναι ἢ γίγνεσθαι· τελευτὴ δὲ τοὐναντίον + αὐτὸ μετ’ ἄλλο πέφυκεν εἶναι ἢ ἐξ ἀνάγχης ἢ ὡς ἐπὶ τὸ πολύ , μετὰ δὲ τοῦτο ἄλλο οὐδέν· μέσον δὲ + καὶ αὐτὸ μετ’ ἄλλο καὶ μετ’ ἐκεῖνο ἕτερον.

It has been laid down by us that tragedy is an imitation of an action that is complete and a whole, having a certain magnitude - for there is a whole that has no magnitude. A whole is that which has a beginning, a middle and an end. A beginning is that which itself is not by necessity after another, but after it another is naturally apt to be or become. The end, contrariwise, is that which itself is naturally apt to be after another, either by necessity or for the most part, but after this no other thing. A middle is what itself is after another and after it another.

And he also taught that Homer, whether by art or by nature, saw that the unity of plot must consist in its being, not about the actions of one man, but about an action which has a beginning, middle and an end (Poetics, Chapter VIII, 1451a 15-16, 22-25, 28-32):

Μῦθος δ’ ἐστὶν εἷς οὐχ ὥσπερ τινὲς οἴονται ἐὰν περὶ *na ≈...

= d' "Ὅμηρος ὥσπερ καὶ τὰ ἄλλα διαφέρει καὶ τοῦτ’ ἔοικεν καλῶς ἰδεῖν \toi διὰ τέχνην ἢ διὰ φύσιν· Ὀδύσσειαν γὰρ ποιῶν οὐκ ἐποίησεν ἅπαντα ὅσα αὐτῷ...

περὶ μίαν πρᾶξιν οἵαν λέγομεν τὴν Ὀδύσσειαν συνέστησεν, ὁμοίως δὲ καὶ τὴν Ἰλιάδα. χρὴ οὖν καθάπερ καὶ ἐν ταῖς ἄλλαις μιμητικαῖς ἡ μία μίμησις ἑνός ἐστιν οὕτω καὶ τὸν μῦθον, ἐπεὶ πράξεως μίμησίς ἐστι, μιας τε εἶναι καὶ ταῦτης ὅλης....

A plot is one, not as some think, if it is about one...

But Homer, just as he differs in other things, so also he sees this well, whether by art or by nature. For in making the Odyssey, he did not make all things whatever that happened to him [Odysseus]

...but he made the Odyssey, and likewise the Iliad, to center around one action that in our sense of the word is one. As in the other imitative arts therefore, the imitation is one when the object imitated is one and that a whole, so the plot, being an imitation of an action, must imitate one action and that a whole.

Since beginning, middle and end are defined by before and after (for the beginning is before something, but not after something; the end is the reverse, after something, but not before something; and the middle is both after something and before something.), it is clear that the very beginning and soul of tragedy (and likewise epic) is tied to looking before and after. That Homer saw this, whether by art or by nature, in what is the soul of his work is a sign of the intimate connection between his work and looking before and after.

The Connection between Beginning Well and Looking Before and After.

We can see the connection between beginning well and looking before and after in general by considering the connection between beginning and before and after.

Aristotle distinguishes in order the central senses of the word before in Chapter Twelve of the Categories. (The central senses of after would, of course, correspond to these.) He distinguishes in order the central senses of beginning in Chapter One of the Fifth Book (D) of the Metaphysics. Anyone who wants to begin well and look before and after should understand these two fundamental texts. We shall not attempt to lay out either of these texts here. But at the end of the Chapter on beginning, Aristotle gives a common account or ratio of beginning (Metaphysics D, 1013a 17-19):

πασῶν μὲν οὖν κοινὸν τῶν ἀρχῶν τὸ πρῶτον εἶναι ὅθεν ἢ ἔστιν ἢ γίγνεται ἢ γιγνώσκεται:

It is common to all beginnings to be that whence something first is or comes to be or is known.

Since first (πρῶτον) is defined by before and after, it is clear that before and after are found in our understanding of beginning. Likewise, we have seen above in the definition of beginning as a part of a plot, the use of before and after in understanding what a beginning is.

But Aristotle has another chapter on the meanings of before in the fifth book of the Metaphysics. Here (Chapter Eleven), he divides the meanings of before and after by the common account of beginning at the end of Chapter One. Thomas explains in his commentary thereon.

Thomas Aquinas, In V Metaphysicorum, Lectio XIII, n. 937:

Distinguit modos diversos, quibus dicitur aliquid prius et posterius. Et quia prius et posterius dicuntur in ordinem ad principium aliquod, principium autem est, ut supra dictum est, quod est primum in esse, aut in fieri, aut in cognitione: ideo pars ista dividitur in partes tres.

In prima dicitur quomodo dicitur aliquid esse prius secundum motum et quantitatem; nam ordo in motu, sequitur ordinem in quantitate. Per prius enim et posterius in magnitudine, est prius et posterius in motu, ut dicitur in quarto Physicorum. Secundo ostendit, quomodo aliquid dicitur prius altero in cognitione...Tertio quomodo dicitur aliquid altero prius in essendo, idest secundum naturam.

He distinguishes the diverse ways in which something is said to be before and after. And because before and after are said in order to some beginning; a beginning, however, as has been said above, is what is first in being or in becoming or in knowledge; therefore this part is divided into three parts.

In the first is said in what way something is said to be before according to motion and quantity. for the before and after in motion is because of the before and after in magnitude, as is said in the fourth book of the Physics. Second, he shows in what way something is said to be before another in knowledge...Third, [he shows] in what way something is before another in being; that is, by nature.

Indeed, if we know what is the beginning or origin of things, we can see what is before and what is after. For what is closer to the beginning is before and what is further away from the beginning is after.

From the above diligently considered, it is clear that beginning and before & after are intimately connected. (It is only in the Trinity that there is a beginning without a before and after. But this is above the philosopher's consideration.) Knowing a beginning helps us to see a before and after "because before and after are said in order to some beginning." And seeing a before and after helps us to find the beginning since the beginning is first or before all the rest. And from this, it can be seen that there is a close connection between the exhortation of Plato and Aristotle to begin well and the exhortation of Homer and Shakespeare to look before and after.

In the next issue of the Περιπατητικός, we shall (Deo volente) distinguish the genera or kinds of beginnings of philosophy. One cannot begin well if one does not know all the beginnings (or the chief ones, at least). For the good is ex integra causa and the bad from any defect. It pays to be a dumb ox when the beginning is in question.

Duane H. Berquist