Macbeth on Error
Intro & Logic · Order of Topics for Class 2016
From his file: MACBETHONERROR.pdf.
Macbeth on Error Duane H. Berquist
ų
acbeth opens with the words of the three witches, those instruments of hell. The whole of Act I, Sc. 1 is devoted to their conversation in twelve lines ending with the couplet which expresses with the brevity and beauty of Shakespeare, the two errors we can make about the good and the bad and touches upon the two sources of those errors. This is the couplet: Fair is foul, and foul is fair Hover through the fog and filthy air. But before we unfold all this reason, we should concentrate our mind upon the words by looking at the poetic devices of Shakespeare here — for there is rhyme as well as reason in these words. The lines, of course, rhyme (fair and air) and there is much alliteration beginning with the letter f (fair and foul, foul and fair, fog and filthy). Trochaic meter (catalectic) is used here by Shakespeare as he often does for unfamiliar creatures like witches or fairies rather than the iambic meter, closer to daily human speech. The first line touches upon the two possible mistakes about the good and the bad. One can think that the good is bad, the fair is foul; or that the bad is good, the foul is fair. If one can make the first mistake, one can also make the second. And vice-versa. The second line touches upon the two sources or causes of the above errors. For the cause of error is either on the side of the mind, and this is signified by the word fog, or on the side of the heart, and this is signified by the word filthy. Shakespeare emphasizes these words fair and foul and the possible confusion of the fair and the foul when he has Macbeth, just before he and Banquo meet the three witches, say: So foul and fair a day I have not seen.1 And after the witches have hailed Macbeth with present and future titles, Banquo says: Good sir, why do you start and seem to fear Things that sound so fair?2 We have said that by the word fog, Shakespeare signifies metaphorically the cause of error on the side of the mind. This is made explicit in the hilarious scene from Twelfth Night where the simile of fog is used. Malvolio has been locked up and treated as a madman as a result of the prank played upon him in the subplot of the play. Malvolio is locked-up in a darkroom and has the following conversation with the Clown impersonating Sir Topas through the door: 1Act I, Sc. 3. 2Ibid.
macbeth on error Malvolio: I am not mad, Sir Topas; I say to you this house is dark.
Clown: (imp. Topas) Mad man, thou errest. I say there is no darkness but ignorance, in which thou art more puzzl’d than the Egyptians in their fog.3 Similar images are used by Shakespeare in the following passage from the Tempest where he speaks of darkness and ignorant fumes in the charm that Prospero had cast upon Alonso, Sebastian, and Antonio. Prospero is speaking: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The charm dissolves apace, And as the morning steals upon the night, Melting the darkness, so their rising senses Begin to chase the ignorant fumes that mantle Their clearer reason.⁴ Shakespeare’s words “the ignorant fumes that mantle their clearer reason” clearly confirm that fog or something like it signifies the cause of error on the side of reason or the mind. We have said that the other alliterating word used in the couplet from Macbeth, the word filth, signifies the cause of error on the side of the heart or the ability to desire. When the heart becomes vicious or we acquire a moral vice, our reason is blinded by this filth of our heart. And that I am not making a wild guess about the meaning of the word filth in this couplet from Macbeth can be seen from a magnificent passage in Antony & Cleopatra where Shakespeare again uses the word filth in describing how reason is blinded and led into error. Antony is the speaker. But when we in our viciousness grow hard — O misery on’t — the wise gods seel our eyes, In our filth drop our clear judgments; make us Adore our errors; laugh at’s while we strut To our confusion.⁵ The first line (“when we in our viciousness grow hard”) speaks of us when, by repeated bad acts, we have acquired the habit of moral vice. For habit, being a disposition that is difficult to change, is suitably described by the word hard. The next words (“O misery on’t”) suitably precede the description of the process by which we come to “Adore our errors” (as is said in the fourth line) since (as Thomas Aquinas observes in the Summa Contra Gentiles) error is a great part of misery. The line “the wise gods seel our eyes” is suitable because he who does not live in accordance with reason is suitably punished by being deprived of the act of reason. The next part, “in our own filth drop our clear judgments; make us Adore our errors”, should be contrasted with the phrase above from the Tempest, “the ignorant fumes that mantle their clearer reason.” “Ignorant fumes” is on the side of reason or the knowing powers while “our own filth” refers to the viciousness in our heart or desiring powers. When our clear judgments have been dropped in our own filth, we proceed to the absurd conclusion of adoring our own errors and making ourselves laughable as we proceed to our own confusion. Confusion here is the opposite of glory. The above passage from Antony & Cleopatra seems to speak of the filth of our heart as the cause of the error whereby we think the foul is fair or the bad is good. There is another passage in Shakespeare where 3Act IV, Sc. 2. ⁴Act V, Sc. 1. ⁵Act II, Sc. 11.
duane h. berquist
the filth of the heart is spoken of as the cause of the reverse error where the good seems bad or the fair to be foul. This is in King Lear after Albany has upbraided his evil and unnatural wife Goneril: Goneril: No more; the text is foolish. Albany: Wisdom and goodness to the vile seem vile. Filths savor but themselves.⁶ If you want a contemporary illustration of what Shakespeare is saying in the witches’ couplet, you could not find a better example than that of the errors about abortion. Those who support abortion are trying to say that what is foul is fair. And when they attack those who oppose abortion, they are saying that what is fair is foul. But notice the fog that surrounds their position. “Pro-abortion” is called “pro-choice”; the painful murder of the unborn is called “termination of pregnancy”; and those who are opposed to abortion are said to be interfering with the “rights of women”. Anything to avoid calling a spade a spade. The fog is so thick that it would take the knife of reason to cut it. Such a smoke-screen is thrown up before the eyes of the public so that, in the words of the Tempest, “ignorant fumes … mantle their clearer reason.” Likewise, on the side of the heart or desiring powers, there is the filth of two of the capital vices in which to “drop our clear judgments.” The most fundamental vices, the vices that draw other vices and sins into the service of their ends, are divided according to the goods of man. Pride is concerned with the good of the soul, lust and gluttony with the good of the body, and avarice with exterior goods. The force behind abortion, like that behind the hard pornography run by the Mafia and the more insidious pornography pushed by Hollywood, involves the union of two capital vices, avarice and lust. There is avarice on the part of those who perform the abortions and lust behind those who have them (and sometimes avarice in those who kill their offspring to avoid having to stretch the paycheck to provide for another mouth). In the union of two capital vices then, there is more than enough filth in which to “drop our clear judgments.” If we add the inane glory of the politicians who seek abortion lobby money, we have a union of three capital vices, covering the whole spectrum of human goods.
⁶Act IV, Sc. 2.