← Library · Natural Philosophy
Matter, Non-being & Evil in the Platonists, Manicheans & St. Augustine
Natural Philosophy · Physics Book 1
From his file: PHILOSOPHERS, ABILITY OF MATTER.doc.
MATTER, NON-BEING & EVIL IN THE PLATONISTS, MANICHEANS & ST. AUGUSTINE
Plato: Timaeus, Lysis, Republic 476A, Laws 896E & 898C
Plotinus, Enneads, I, Book. 8, Chapter 3:
By this non-being, of course, we are not to understand something that simply does not exist, but only something of an utterly different order from authentic being...the non-being we are thinking of is rather an image of being or perhaps something still further from an image.
Plotinus, Enneads, III, Book 6, Chapter 7:
Investigation will show us that matter has not reality and is not capable of being affected. Matter must be bodiless - for body is a later production, a compound made by matter in conjunction with some other entity. Matter is no limit or bound, for it is mere indetermination; it is not a power, for what does it produce? It lives on the farther side of all these categories and so has no title to the name of being. It will be more plausibly called a non-being and this in the sense not of movement (away from being) or of station (in not being) but of veritable non-being.
St. Augustine, De div. quaest. LXXXIII, q. 54:
However, what is not a body is either soul or something better than soul. For there is nothing lower than all bodies because, even if someone will suggest the matter from which a body is made, since it lacks all form, is rightly called nothing.
St. Augustine, Confessions, Book 12, Chapter 6:
For the mutability of mutable things is simply their capacity for all the forms into which mutable things can be changed. But what is this?..If it were allowable to say that it is a nothing which is in some way something, or that it is and yet is not, that is what I should say.
St. Augustine, Confessions, Book 12, Chapter 15:
Yet this almost-nothing, since it was not absolutely nothing, must have been from Him from whom all is that in any way is.
St. Augustine, De Natura Boni Contra Manichaeos, C. 18, P.L. 556-557)
Nor on this account ought this hyle which cannot be perceived through any sensible species but which can, with difficulty, be conceived through the privation of all form, be called evil. For it has a capacity for form, since if it were not able to receive form imposed by the maker, it would certainly not be called matter. But if form is something good, whence things are called well-formed which excel in it, just as things which excel in beauty are called beautiful, then, without doubt, even the capacity for form is something good.
Hegel: “..the portentous power of the negative”
Lenin, Philosophical Notebooks:
In its proper meaning, dialectics is the study of the contradiction within the very essence of things.
Lenin, Materialism and Empirio-Criticism:
Development is the ‘struggle’ of oppposites.
Speaking of the views of Heraclitus who held that “the world, all in one, was not created by God or any man, but was, is and ever will be a living flame, systematically flaring up and systematically dying down.”. Lenin comments (Philosophical Notebooks):
A very good exposition of the rudiments of dialectical materialism.
Sarte identifies the indetermination of the human will before it chooses with that will or with its freedom. And since he identifies man with his freedom, he makes man consist in nothingness or non-being.