Natural Desire and the Use of Reason

← Library · Wisdom about Beginnings

Natural Desire and the Use of Reason

Wisdom about Beginnings · Beginning of Philosophy in the Will

From his file: NATURAL DESIRE & REASON.doc.

Word doc

NATURAL DESIRE AND THE USE OF REASON

De Unitate Intellectus Contra Averroistas, Proemium, n. 173:

Sicut omnes homines naturaliter scire desiderant veritatem, ita naturale desiderium inest hominibus fugiendi errores.

But because truth is usually a good difficult to get, hope is necessary in addition to the natural desire to know truth. This hope may not be natural, but acquired. After experience of the difficulty in knowing truth, a man may despair or hope of ovecoming these difficulties.

And because error or a mistake is not only bad, but also difficult to avoid, one needs, in addition to the natural desire to avoid or escape error, fear of making or remaining in a mistake. This fear also seems to be acquired rather than natural.

Although nature assures more the desire to know truth and avoid error than the hope of overcoming the difficulties in the way of knowing truth and the fear of making a mistake or of being mistaken, yet even that natural desire needs to be moderated by a virtue.

Does the same virtue (called studiositas in Latin) regulate the love of, the desire for and the joy in the knowledge of truth?

When speaking of charity, Thomas says (Summa Theologiae, Secunda Secundae, Q. 51, Art. 2, c):

ex eodem dependet bonitas amoris, desiderii et gaudii; et ideo omnia ista pertinent ad eandem virtutem caritatis.

If the goodness of the love of truth, the desire for truth and the joy in knowing truth are from the same, then they would pertain to the same virtue. Since wisdom is the knowledge of truth by antonomasia, the love of wisdom might also belong to this same virtue to regulate.

What is not clear is that the hope and fear spoken of above would belong to this same virtue. Comparing again with charity, theological hope is a virtue distinct from charity.

(Consider Summa Theologiae, Secunda Secundae: Q. 51, Art., 2 C & Ad 3; Art. 3, C; Art. 4, Ad 2 and check parallel readiings for Q. 51. Also Q. 48 or 98?)

But notice the connection of love and fear in the following passage: Hamlet, Act III, Sc. 2, Player Queen:

For woman's fear and love holds quantity, In neither aught, or in extremity. Now, what my love is, proof hath made you know; And as my love is siz'd, my fear is so: Where love is great, the littlest doubts are fear; Where little fears grow great, great love grows there.

(Would the word siz'd be a good translation for modus? The mode of fear corresponds to the mode of love; as the one is sized so is the other.)