← Library · Plato: On the Soul
Paper on the Phaedo (Phaedo Talk)
Plato: On the Soul
From his file: 02-Paper_on_the_Phaedo.pdf.
Read from in 14 classes
- Introduction to Philosophy & Logic (1999) — 10. Thomas's Proemia: Logic as the Art of Arts and Its Division by the Three Acts of Reason
- Introduction to Philosophy & Logic (1999) — 34. Second Figure Syllogisms, the Power of the Figures, and Why Universal Negatives Convert
- Introduction to Philosophy & Logic (1999) — 38. Fallacies Outside Language: Accident, Secundum Quid and the Meno
- Introduction to Philosophy & Logic (1999) — 43. Seeing Likeness and Proportion, Then Q&A on Places and Comedy
- Natural Hearing — 17. Anaxagoras on the Mind: Unlimited, Self-Ruling, and Separate
- Natural Hearing — 26. Contradiction and the Progress of Knowledge: Heraclitus, Aristotle and the Untying of Knots
- De Anima — 65. Article Three: Are Animal Souls Subsistent? Sense vs. Intellect, Proportion, and Greek Humility
- De Anima — 69. Summa I q.75 a.6: Why the Human Soul Is Incorruptible (Per Se and Per Accidens, Form and Existence, No Contrariety in the Understanding)
- De Anima — 137. Summa Theologiae I, Q.84, Article 4: Against Avicenna, Understanding Requires the Senses
- Love & Friendship — 5. The Good as Cause of Love: Shakespeare and Aquinas ST I-II q.27 a.1, and Knowledge as Cause of Love in Shakespeare
- Wisdom (2005) — 49. The Meanings of 'Necessary' and Metaphysics IX, Reading 4: Rational Ability, Choice, and Mind versus Love as First Mover
- Wisdom (2006, Colorado) — 32. Dispositions of the Will for the Philosopher, and Hope and Fear in Pursuing Truth (Metaphysics II intro)
- Prima Secundae — 18. Aquinas on Beatitude II: The Vision of God's Essence, the Wonder to Know What Things Are, and Pleasure in Beatitude (q.3 a.8, q.4 a.1)
- Prima Secundae — 198. Replies on the seven capital vices, then the effects of sin (Question 85, article 1): does sin weaken the good of nature?
PHAEDO TALK
The Phaedo is one of the major dialogues of Plato. And before considering the Phaedo in particular, we should ask what is a platonic dialogue. It is an imitation or likeness of a conversation about a philosophical question (or questions) exercising our reason on that question (or questions) and disposing our will and emotions for philosophy. Our reason is exercised on the question by the defining and reasoning, which are represented in the dialogue. Since man is the most imitative of the animals and at first we learn by imitation, we learn from the dialogues how to go about answering a philosophical question. The dialogue also disposes our will and emotions for philosophy by showing how the dispositions of will and emotion in the characters of the dialogue either help or impede them in answering the question(s) of the dialogue. One advantage of the dialogues of Plato over a philosophical treatise is that the dispositions of will and emotion that help or impede one in philosophy can be clearly represented while in a treatise the dispositions of the will and emotions may be hidden.
The Phaedo is a likeness of a conversation on the last day of Socrates' life when he is in prison awaiting his death at the sentence of the Athenian court. Phaedo narrates the conversations of that day to Echecrates. The largest parts of the Phaedo are two conversations on two philosophical questions and a muthos or myth told by Socrates. The first long conversation is about the question whether the philosopher should be willing to die or whether the soul is better off while it is in the body or after it has left the body. This question however presupposes the answer to another philosophical question: does the soul continue to exist after the death of a man? If the soul does not continue to exist after death, there is no reason to ask whether it is better off then. The philosopher would not we willing to die unless (1) the soul continued to exist after death and (2) the soul is in a better state after death than before. The second and longer conversation of the Phaedo is about whether the human soul is immortal or deathless. The immediate relevance of these two questions for Socrates and his friends on this day when he is going to die is obvious. But their importance for all of us is inescapable. For we all expect to die some day. After these two long conversations, Socrates tells a long muthos, a myth or story, about the soul after death. We can ask later why he stops reasoning and tells a muthos.
Before these two long conversations and the telling of the muthos, Socrates sends his weeping wife Xanthippe home and remarks on the connection between pleasure and pain in the body as he rubs his legs after being released from his bands and touches upon philosophy as being the
highest music. And after the two long conversations and the telling of the muthos, there is the moving scene of Socrates' death.
Before looking at the two main conversations and why Socrates tells a muthos, we should look at what is most interesting in the first part of the dialogue. This is the statement of Socrates that philosophy is the highest music. Although the Greek word mousike can be understood for all the arts, I think Socrates' remark is more interesting if we think of music in particular. In music, as opposed to noise, there is harmony. The musician aims at the harmony of sounds, but the philosopher aims at a higher kind of harmony. Indeed at two kinds of harmony. When Socrates examined others he found a kind of noise in their heads. One thought did not agree with another. One thought contradicted, or led to a contradiction with, another. As Aristotle observed in the first book of the Nicomachean Ethics, with the truth all things harmonize. The philosopher then aims at the harmony of truth which involves the harmony of our thoughts with each other and with things. If our thoughts do not harmonize or fit together, they are not in harmony with things. And if they are in harmony with things, they will also be in harmony with each other.
But there is also another kind of harmony which is the end of the practical philosopher. This is the harmony of desire with reason and consequently the harmony of action with reason. This is first considered in ethics. But in political philosophy, we are also concerned with the harmony of citizens or of the classes within the city.
It is important to have seen that philosophy aims at a harmony within the soul (the harmony of our thoughts and the harmony of desire with reason) when we examine later Socrates' arguments against the soul being the harmony of the body.
Turning now to the first major conversation: Socrates intimates that a true philosopher should be willing to die and his friends wish that he would explain this since it seems strange that any man should be willing to die. Before one can know whether the true philosopher should be willing to die, we must know what death is and what true philosophy is. If by the word soul we mean the cause of life within living bodies (which is what the Greeks meant by their word psyche), then it seems clear that death is the separation of the soul from the body. And if true philosophy involves separating one's soul to some extent from the body, then true philosophy is a practice or exercise in dying. And if these are true, then Socrates can reason that the philosopher should be willing to die; just as the man practicing hitting the ball should be willing to play ball when the time comes.
That death is the separation of the soul from the body seems reasonable right away if by soul you mean the cause of life within living bodies, whatever that cause may be. But that the true philosopher is separating his soul from his body to some extent is in need of being shown. How does Socrates show this? The philosopher seeks knowledge and moral virtue and Socrates reasons from both that he is practicing death, that is, separating to some extent his soul from his body. Does one acquire the moral virtues by following the inclinations of the body or by resisting them? Faced with danger, the body inclines one to run away. But one becomes courageous by resisting this inclination of the body when it is reasonable to face the danger, as in the case of a soldier defending his country. But faced with something very pleasing to the senses such as food or wine or a beautiful woman, a man's body is inclined to go to excess in the pursuit of them. A man does not become moderate or temperate or chaste by following these inclinations of the body but by resisting them. Thus the soul becomes virtuous by resisting the body or by separating itself to some extent from the body rather than by following the body. And this separating of the soul from the body could be called a practice in dying since death is the complete separation of the soul from the body. Hence, Christians also talk about mortifying the body and dying to oneself and so on.
But the philosopher also separates his soul from his body to some extent in seeking knowledge. We all know that concentration is essential in acquiring knowledge. The body is first of all a great distraction to the soul, both through what is going on in the body and by what impinges on the senses from outside the body. We speak of the absent-minded professor. His mind seems to be withdrawn from his body and surroundings. Sometimes our mind is so engrossed in its thoughts that we do not realize our hunger until we stop thinking.
The body and the things that act upon our bodily senses are changing all the time, to a greater or lesser extent. But understanding, as the word itself indicates, is possible only of what stands still. Hence, to perfect our reason by understanding, we must turn away from these changing bodily things towards unchanging things such as the immaterial things of geometry and theology.
Thus the soul is perfected both in moral virtue and in understanding by resisting the body or turning away from it. And this partial separation of the soul from the body can be called a practice in dying or the practice of death.
If the philosopher then as a lover of the soul and in his pursuit of the goods of the soul is practicing dying in this life; that is, separating to some extent his soul from his body; then he should be willing to die; that is, undergo the complete separation of his soul from his body. For only in this way can his soul reach complete perfection in knowledge and the moral virtues.
Someone might think that all of this is an argument in support of suicide. Socrates does not try to reason that suicide as such is a bad thing. Rather he says that the soul is in the body perhaps as in a prison, but at any rate at the command of the gods. And that we should not leave the body until the gods approve of our departure by our natural death or death in battle or death at the command of the city.
Socrates seems to be thinking that the soul is the whole man and the body is not really part of us. The body is more a prison. The body impedes and leads astray the soul in so many ways that one could think that the union of the body and the soul is not natural, but that the soul is in the body to be punished or as a prison.
Aristotle, the pupil of Plato, saw that the union of the body and the soul was natural and that the body is part of us. Yet the puzzle remains. Why should the body impede the soul in so many ways? All of this makes one think that human nature has been vitiated by something like the original sin of which Christianity speaks.
If the soul then continues to exist after death and the soul is better off separated from the body than in the body, then the philosopher should be willing to die - for he is a lover of the soul and its good. But for those who have been lovers of the body, death is the worst of all evils because it separates the soul from all that it loves - the body and its pleasures. Socrates says that the stories we hear of the souls of the departed lingering around graveyards are about the souls which were lovers of the body in this life. They wish to get back into their bodies to continue enjoying the goods of the body.
But does the soul continue to exist after death? The friends of Socrates want to know. This leads to the second and longest conversation of the Phaedo. This conversation naturally falls into three parts. In the first part, Socrates develops a number of arguments which conclude that the soul is immortal - it does survive death. But Simmias and Cebes towards the end of this part raise some objections and suddenly the arguments of Socrates seem no longer good or, at least, not necessary. The hope that the soul is immortal and that we could know its immortality suddenly turns to despair. There is a distrust of arguments in its favor.
In the second part, Socrates gradually leads them out of this despair and distrust of arguments, and prepares them to investigate further the question of whether the soul is immortal. It is in this second part that we learn much about the dispositions of will (and emotion) which either help or impede or even
prevent the pursuit of philosophy. Likewise, in this part, Socrates says that we need an art about arguments. This, to my knowledge, is the first explicit reference to the need of logic for our reason.
And in the third part of the conversation, Socrates again takes up the investigation of whether the soul is immortal, answering the objections of Simmias and Cebes and strengthening and developing new arguments for the immortality of the human soul.
We should look at each of these parts in some detail.
In his first argument for the immortality of the soul, Socrates brings out two general statements, which he then applies to life and death and the soul.
The first general statement is that change is between contraries. Socrates shows this by induction. The dry becomes wet and the wet dries out. The hard becomes soft and the soft hardens or becomes hard. The cold becomes hot and the hot becomes cold. The sick become healthy and the healthy become sick.
The second general statement is that if both contraries continue to exist in the world, there must be change in both directions. Thus, for example, if there was only change from hot to cold and not the reverse change, everything would by now be cold and the hot would not exist. Underlying this is the common opinion that things are always changing and the universe has always been, so that if there is only change in one direction, there would only be by now one of the contraries, the one towards which there was change.
Socrates then applies these two statements to life and death and the soul. Living and dead are contraries. And there is change from living to dead or souls are separated from bodies. Now if the reverse or contrary change from the dead to the living does not take place, if souls are not joined to bodies again, then by now all things should be dead and nothing alive. But this is contrary to our experience. There continue to be living and dead things in the world. Hence, souls must be joined to bodies again and not merely separated. Therefore, souls must continue to exist after they have been separated from bodies or they could not be joined to bodies again or enter into bodies again.
Some people object to this argument, saying they see living bodies becoming dead, but they do not see dead bodies coming alive. This however is to miss the point of why Socrates is reasoning. If we saw dead bodies coming back to life or souls reentering bodies, we would not have to reason to this conclusion.
Socrates' argument can be explained by a likeness. If we saw people leaving houses all day long, but we never saw people entering houses; we would have to reason to the latter. Now if people are always leaving houses (as we know), but they never enter them, all houses would be by now empty. But since some houses have people in them now and some do not, we can conclude (although we do not see it) that people must be entering houses. The same could be said of cars and people.
The real weakness in this argument is not brought out in the Phaedo. If the separation of the soul from the body (which is death) is a change of place for the soul, then the argument is good; just as the arguments from the house and car. But this supposes that the soul is a substance distinct from the body. For only if the soul is a substance distinct from the body, is it possible for the soul to be where the body is not. But if, as Simmias will suggest later, the soul is only the harmony or order of the body, then the argument will not be good. For when the harmony or order of bodies is lost, the harmony or order cannot go elsewhere since it is essentially something of the body. When students disturb the order or arrangement of chairs in a classroom, that order does not leave and go elsewhere. It no longer exists. And if someone again arranges the chairs in the same order, it is not the same numerically. Not only the change from living to non-living, but also the change from non-living to living must exist as Socrates has shown. Otherwise, nothing would be alive anymore. But this change may be like that from arranged to disarranged chairs and back again. In this case, no one's soul remains after death. But this weakness in the argument is not seen by anyone in the dialogue. However, Socrates remedies this weakness later when he reasons against the soul being the harmony of the body which Simmias suggests in reply to another argument of Socrates. But Simmias does not present this position on what the soul might be as an objection to the first argument, nor does Socrates reply to it as to an objection to the first argument.
The second argument of Socrates is from recollection or recalling. And here it should be known that there is one argument from recalling in the dialogue called the Meno which is referred to in this dialogue and another argument which is developed here in the Phaedo. And the argument here is more difficult to answer than that in the Meno. We must see the difference between these two arguments. But first we must see what they have in common.
Both have the same chief syllogism which is an if-then syllogism, but they differ in how they back up the second premiss in this chief syllogism.
The chief syllogism is thus: If the soul has some knowledge which it did not acquire in this life or in this body, then the soul must have existed before this life or before it was in this body. But the soul does have some knowledge it did not acquire in this life or in this body. Therefore, the soul must have existed before it was in this body. This shows that the soul's existence does not depend upon this body and therefore that the soul will not cease to be because the body is destroyed.
The if-then statement in the chief syllogism is clearly true. This can be illustrated by a simple example. If the teacher meets his students for the first time in the classroom; and in conversation with them, it appears that the students have acquired some knowledge which they did not acquire in this teacher's class, then they must have existed before they were in his class. Since they did not acquire the knowledge in the class, they must have acquired it before the class. And hence they must have existed before the class.
The problem then is to show the truth of the second premiss of the chief syllogism. How can one show that the soul has some knowledge which it did not acquire in this body or in this life? Socrates develops one argument for this in the Meno and another one here in the Phaedo.
In the Meno, Socrates asks the slave-boy of Meno questions and out of the slave-boy's answers comes the way to double a square in geometry. Since Meno has testified to the fact that his slave-boy has never studied geometry, it appears that the slave-boy has some knowledge of geometry which he did not acquire in this life. For the way to double a square comes out of the slave-boy's answers and therefore out of the knowledge of the slave-boy.
Socrates has touched here upon a profound truth about how we come to know in geometry and, more generally, in philosophy. We come to know by recalling together two or more things that we know already. We can know, for example, two statements from which we can reason to a conclusion. But, if we cannot recall these two statements together, we cannot reason from them to a conclusion. The questions of Socrates not only help the slave-boy to recall things that he knows already, but to recall them together so that he can see their consequence. The slave-boy does not recall the way to double a square. Rather he recalls other things from which he can reason to this conclusion. The slave boy is able to know the way to double a square, but he actually comes to know this only after he has put together (with the help of Socrates) things he knows already. Thus Socrates has not shown that the slave-boy already knew how to double the square. In fact, when Socrates first asks him how to do so, the slave-boy is mistaken as to how to do this. He thinks you double the side and only later realizes this would give you a square four times as big.
But in the Phaedo, Socrates reasons, not from the soul recollecting what is a conclusion of geometry, but from its recalling what is a beginning in geometry. This argument is not so easily answered. The geometer knows what equality is. But the material things we know in our body and through our body are not really equal. They approach equality, but fall short of perfect or strict equality. How, Socrates asks, do we make this judgment that the things we know through the body approach, but fall short of equality. We must have a knowledge of equality not gotten through this body and to this equality we compare the material things around us, saying they approach but fall short of true equality.
The strength of Socrates' argument is brought out by a likeness. If you see the painting or statue of some man and you say that it resembles the real man, but is not exactly like him; must you not have a knowledge of the real man before and independent of the painting and the statue? If your only knowledge of the man was through the painting or statue of him, you could not say that it falls short of him.
Thus, if we judge the material things we come to know as not being perfectly equal, but as resembling equality and falling short of it, our soul must have a knowledge of perfect equality gotten before it was in the body.
One could reason in the same way about other things, such as flat surface and perfect happiness.
At this point, Cebes objects. Socrates has shown only half of what he should show. Socrates has reasoned that the soul has existed before the body, but not after. To this Socrates replies that the first argument did touch upon this. If the soul did not continue to exist after death, there would be no souls to come back into bodies. And then by now there would be no living bodies. And in general, one could say that if the soul existed before the body, then its existence does not depend upon the body. And hence it will not cease to be because the body has been destroyed.
Nevertheless, Socrates says that he understands their fears and concern, and he will reason directly to the soul's existence after death.
The direct argument of Socrates to the soul existing after death is an if-then syllogism. The if-then statement is based on the soul being more apt to survive death than the body. If the body survives death, then the soul survives death will be the first premiss. We will see in a moment how Socrates establishes that the soul is more apt to survive death than the body. But if he
can show this, he can then reason that if surviving death belongs to the one it is less apt to belong to, even more so will it belong to the one it is more apt to belong to. But we do know that the body, or part of it, the bones, does survive death. Hence, the soul must survive death.
How does Socrates show that the soul is more apt to survive death than the body? He shows that the soul with its reason is more apt to survive death than the body with its eye. For the bodily eye knows this dog, which is corruptible, but the reason knows what a dog is and this does not change. The soul then through reason is in contact with the incorruptible and necessary while the body through its senses is in contact only with the corruptible and contingent. Hence, the soul is more akin to the incorruptible and unchangeable than the body. Hence, it is more apt to survive death than the body.
Again, the soul rules the body, just as the gods or immortals rule men or the mortals. Thus the soul is more like the gods or immortals than is the body. Hence, again it is more apt to survive.
At this point, everyone is satisfied, except for Simmias and Cebes. Simmias has heard the famous opinion that the soul is the harmony of the body, a sign of which is that the soul delights in the harmony of music. There is something godlike in music. Hence, its name which is derived from the Muses. But if the soul is godlike in the way that harmony is godlike, then the soul would not be immortal even though it is in this way godlike. For the harmony of a body does not precede that body in existence, nor does it exist after that body. Hence, although the soul may be godlike, it may not be immortal at all.
Cebes objects that, although the soul is longer lasting than a body, it enters into one body after another, according to Socrates' earlier arguments, and it may eventually corrupt. The weakness of Socrates' argument is brought out by Cebes in a proportion. Just as a soul is apt to last longer than a body, so a man is apt to last longer than a pair of shoes or trousers etc. But a man goes through many pairs of shoes or trousers in his life. And the man gradually wears out himself and finally he puts on a pair of shoes or trousers that will out last him. Maybe my soul is gradually wearing out and, although it outlasts many bodies, eventually it also wears out. So, for all I know, my soul may be now in its last body. Socrates' reasoning is like that of a man who said that someone has not died since his shoes and trousers still exist and a man is longer lasting that a pair of shoes or trousers.
At this point, despair seizes the friends of Socrates. Arguments, which had seemed good, no longer seem to be any good. They begin to despair of knowing the truth about the soul. Such despair in the life of the mind is by no
means uncommon. What is remarkable here is how Socrates leads them out of this despair. He warns them of becoming misologists; that is, haters of argument. And he makes a beautiful comparison between how men become misanthropes and how they become misologists. He says that there are few men one can trust completely. There are some men that should not be trusted at all. Most men are in-between. They can be trusted up to a point. Men become misanthropes by trusting someone they should not trust or by trusting someone more than they should. They should have understood the three-fold distinction of men and understood whether a particular man is to be trusted completely, not at all, or up to some point. By not knowing this, they trusted someone they should not trust or someone more than they should have. When they were let down, they began to distrust all men and in this way they became misanthropes. It is the same with arguments. Some arguments can be trusted completely and some arguments cannot be trusted at all. And some can be trusted up to a point, some more, some less. We need, says Socrates, an art about arguments; an art that would help us distinguish between an argument that can be trusted completely, an argument that cannot be trusted at all, and an argument that can be trusted up to a point.
This is the first time, to my knowledge, that someone has seen the need for logic which is the art about arguments. When Aristotle, the father of logic, thought out and wrote out the basic parts of the art about arguments, his works fall into this three-fold division. The Prior and Posterior Analytics are about the kind of argument which can be trusted completely, demonstration. The Topics or About Places and the Rhetoric are about arguments that can be trusted up to a point. And the book On Sophistical Refutations is about arguments which should not be trusted at all.
Just as the misanthrope misses out on one of the greatest goods in human life which is friendship, so the misologist misses out on the other greatest good in human life which is wisdom. For wisdom can be achieved only by arguments.
Socrates urges them not to distrust all arguments, but to distrust their own knowledge of arguments.
Socrates also warns them against loving Socrates more than the truth. Since Socrates wants to think that the soul survives death, he and his friends must be on guard against wishful thinking.
Socrates then resumes the investigation and replies to the objections of Simmias and Cebes. Simmias had objected that the soul might be godlike in the way that harmony is godlike, but he had not proven that the soul is the
harmony of the body. Socrates quickly demolishes the opinion that the soul is the harmony of the body. Since the soul existed before the body, as was shown by the argument from recollection (and this argument has not been refuted in the conversation), and a harmony of the body cannot be before the body, clearly the soul is not the harmony of the body. Moreover, there is a harmony of the soul as when we say that philosophy is the highest kind of music. But there does not seem to be a harmony of harmony. And third, the soul sometimes resists the inclinations of the body, but the harmony of the body would not resist the body's inclinations.
This was so easy that Socrates has to warn them of the opposite of despair - overconfidence and boastfulness. The argument of Cebes will not be so easy to answer. We see here the role of a good teacher in learning. He must encourage the student when the student is discouraged and he must caution the student when he is overconfident.
Cebes is pushing Socrates to come up with a necessary argument. Socrates has been giving reasons for thinking that the soul is immortal, that the soul does not die when the body dies. But Cebes wants the best reason that can be given for the truth of a statement. The best reason that can be given for the truth of a statement is the reason why it must be so. Such a reason contains the cause of the truth of the statement. Hence, when Socrates is, so to speak, pushed to the wall by Cebes to come up with such a reason, he sees the need to recall his experience as a natural philosopher.
It was the natural philosophers before Socrates who most of all looked for the causes of things. The desire which motivated the natural philosophers is well expressed in a fragment of Democritus which has come down to us.
I would rather discover one cause than be master of the kingdom of the Persians. (Democritus, DK 118)
The natural philosophers discovered that there is more than one way in which something can be responsible for the existence, or the coming into existence, of another. Eventually, by the time of Aristotle, they saw clearly that something could depend for its existence or coming into existence upon as many as four things, but in different ways. Wood is responsible in one way for the existence and coming into existence of a wooden chair while the carpenter is responsible for the chair coming into existence in another way. And sitting is responsible for the existence of the chair and its coming into existence, in yet another way. Even the shape of the wood and the order of its parts are responsible in some way for the existence of the chair. For there would not be a chair without that shape and order.
Socrates discusses at some length his dissatisfaction with the use of these various kinds of cause by the natural philosophers to explain why things are so. And then he states the usefulness of the kind of cause that is most connected with definition, the form or the what it is of a thing. If we are asked, for example, why an odd number cannot be an even number, we can give a very satisfactory answer in the light of the definition of odd number and the definition of even number. There is an opposition in the definitions of these two whence we can see that one does not admit of the other. For an even number is divisible into two equal parts while the odd number is not.
With the light then cast upon causes by his experience and thinking as a natural philosopher, Socrates then returns to the objection or demand of Cebes that he show that the soul must be immortal.
Socrates first develops some general statements which he then applies to the particular case of the soul and death.
One opposite cannot be the other. The hot cannot be cold, the wet cannot be dry, the hard cannot be soft and so on. This is clearly impossible for then the same thing would be both hot and cold, hot and not hot at the same time; wet and dry, wet and not wet, at the same time; and so on.
The second point is that, if one of two opposites is in the definition of a third thing, in what it is, that third thing also could not admit of the other opposite. If hard were in the definition of butter or pertained to what it is, then butter could never be soft. For this would also involve the hard being soft. But as a matter of fact, hard is not in the definition of butter. So butter can lose its hardness and acquire the opposite softness.
But since odd is in the definition of three or to be an odd number belongs to what three is, not only is it impossible for an odd number to be even, but it is also impossible for three to be even.
We must clearly see this difference before we descend to the question of the soul and death. If one was to define butter, one would not put hard in its definition. If one was to define cloth, one would not put dry into its definition. Hence, the butter can becomes soft and the cloth could become wet. And the reverse is also true. One would not put wet in the definition of cloth even though a cloth may be wet. Likewise one would not put soft in the definition of butter even though butter may be soft. Hence, the cloth can become dry even though the wet cannot be dry. And likewise butter can become hard even though the soft cannot be hard. The butter loses its softness when it becomes
hard and it can do so because softness does not pertain to its definition. or to what it is.
Socrates then applies this to the soul and death. Life and death are opposites so life cannot admit of death, nor can death admit of life. But life is in the definition of soul for the soul is the cause of life in living bodies. But life is not in the definition of body. Hence, a body which is alive can die, just as soft butter can become hard. But since life is in the definition of the soul, as odd number is in the definition of three, it is impossible for the soul to admit of death, just as it is impossible for three to admit of being even.
At this point, even Cebes is satisfied. However, Socrates says later to Simmias that the consideration of the soul is difficult and further thinking would be appropriate on the subject.
After these intense discussions of the questions whether the soul is immortal and whether the soul is better off in the body or outside the body, Socrates tells a muthos about the soul after death.
We cannot enter into the details of this muthos now, but we can attempt to answer why Socrates should stop his intense reasoning at this point and tell a muthos instead.
One reason is that we all need to return to our senses even if we can follow the reasoning. It is natural for man to begin and end in his senses. The muthos is sensible in that it is imaginable. Just as Christians enjoy returning to their inward eye or imagination in Dante's Divine Comedy, so too the Greek would enjoy this muthos.
Second, telling a muthos about the soul after death is suitable insofar as the condition of the soul after death is not able to be investigated very much by reason. Socrates' telling a muthos may be a sign that he recognizes that the subject is one that is not very accessible to reason. Christ also told parables in part because he was speaking of things that exceed the grasp of our reason and a parable is an extended metaphor.
A third reason for telling a muthos is a dramatic one. Just as Shakespeare relieves the tension and intensity of tragedy, such as in Macbeth, with a slightly comic interlude, so Plato does not want to pass from the intensity and strain of the two great discussions to the different, but very intense (in an another way) scene of the death of Socrates, his revered master. We need a break so that we can concentrate upon a different intense scene.
Now the time has come for Socrates to die by drinking the hemlock according to the sentence of the Athenian Court. Socrates gives the example of a man who believes that his soul is indeed going to a better place. When Crito asks Socrates where they shall bury him, he replies that Crito will have to catch him first. Socrates is evidently thinking that he is a soul and the body is not Socrates and it is hard or impossible to catch the soul. Socrates' last request is that they sacrifice a cock to Aesculapius, the god of medicine. Socrates is indicating his belief that his soul, when it is separated, will be purged from the errors and vices it has occurred by being in the body.
Phaedo, who has been narrating this last day of Socrates, concludes his narration with a eulogy of Socrates as the best and wisest and most just man they have known.
Perhaps some general reflections are in order here. The study of the soul is the greatest of studies except for the study of those things which are above the soul in the excellence of their natures. Only the study of the angels and the study of God are above the study of the soul. For nothing is more noble than the soul except an angel or God. And the study of the soul is presupposed to a study of the angels or a study of God. We understand the higher immaterial substances by the likeness of our soul to them and by the negation of the natural defects of our soul
There were many opinions about the nature of the soul among the Greeks, some more probable than others. But two probable opinions are touched upon in this dialogue. A probable opinion is not necessarily the whole truth, but a truly probable opinion is apt to have some part of the truth in it. The opinion that the soul is the harmony of the body, although not much defended in this dialogue, has much probability. Likewise, the opinion of Socrates that the soul is an immaterial substance distinct from the body also has much probability. There is a part of the truth in both of these positions. It is not until the second book of Aristotle About the Soul that these two parts of the truth were united and the whole truth in general about what the soul is was seen.
Likewise, the truth about the existence of the human soul before or after the body is between the two main positions in the Phaedo. The human soul does not exist before and after the body as in the opinion of Socrates, nor does it neither exist before nor after the body, as in the opinion of those who think the soul is the harmony of the body. Rather the soul exists after the body, but not before it, as Aristotle first saw. The reason for this depends upon seeing fully what the soul is.
Aristotle also perfected the arguments of Socrates for the immortality of the soul, especially the last one.
But the Phaedo is not only important for its investigation of the soul. It is also extremely important for the light it casts upon what is necessary to undertake any investigation. On the part of the will, one needs not only the desire to know, but also the endurance in pursuing a difficult truth and the reasonable fear of making a mistake. As Socrates shows or exemplifies in his words to his friends, one needs a balance of hope or endurance in the pursuit of a difficult good and the fear of making a mistake in important matters. This is proportional to the Christian need to both hope in God and fear God. Without hope in the divine mercy, the Christian would despair. And without fear of the divine justice, the Christian would become careless and presumptuous. Likewise, without the hope of coming to know the truth, the philosopher would despair and give up the pursuit of wisdom. But without the fear of making a mistake, the philosopher would become careless and fall into many mistakes.
And on the side of reason, one needs logic or the art about arguments as Socrates calls it. It is, of course, Aristotle who is usually called the father of logic. For Aristotle was the first to think out the basic parts of logic.
We can also see, especially in Socrates' first and last arguments for the immortality of the soul, that the philosophy of nature is before the study of the soul.
Given the importance of the study of the soul, it is strange that hardly anyone studies it. It is important for the study of living bodies and it gives us a foundation for logic and ethics. And a knowledge of the soul is the only way to get a glimpse of the separated substances.
Duane H. Berquist