← Library · Natural Philosophy
Questions Asked on the Books of the Hearing About Nature
Natural Philosophy
From his file: QUESTIONS ON THE PHUSIS.doc.
QUESTIONS ASKED ON THE BOOKS OF THE HEARING ABOUT NATURE
Is there a difference between common and private experience? If so, what is the difference? Exemplify
Is there a difference between common knowledge and common opinion? If so, what is the difference? Exemplify.
(Common knowledge is a necessary result of common experience. Common opinion is a result of imagination “whatever is must be somewhere” or custom or human belief.)
Does common knowledge come before any other kind of knowledge in man? Why?
Can common knowledge be clarified or made distinct? Why?
What advantage does the man who has clarified common knowledge have over other men who also possess common knowledge?
How are the philosophy of nature and the experimental sciences of nature related to our common knowledge of the natural world? Consequently, how are they related to each other?
Why do we talk about the basic road in human knowledge at the beginning of natural science?
Give the most difficult statement of the basic road. In what ways can we be led by the hand to understand this most difficult statement?
Manifest the most difficult statement of the basic road by less universal statements. Give the three kinds of example used by Aristotle to manifest that our knowledge goes from the confused to the distinct. Give an example of each.
manifest the most difficult statement of the basic road by analogy to the first principles in other kinds of education.
The consideration of what is found in every change comes before the consideration of particular kinds of change because of what aspect of the basic road in human knowledge?
Show from the basic road in human knowledge that the most basic part of our mind’s knowledge is that based on common experience of the natural world.
whether the general is before the particular in our knowledge
Whether it is necessary to know the general before the particular
Whether the confused is more sure than the distinct.
Show how the above principles are often violated in or custom of beginning the study of natural things with the experimental science and the study of human actio with the social sciences. what is the position of Einstein, bohr, Heisenberg and Strauss on this matter?
Where does our mind go when all thinkers disagree?
Why is change the first thing to arouse our wonder?
what is found in every change?
Why does change leads to an understanding of matter?
Why does our mind go forward by seeing proportions and untying contradictions.?
The consideration of what is found in every change comes before the consideration of change of place, chemical change, and growth because of what aspect of the basic road in human knowledge? What three kinds of example does Aristotle use to manifest this aspect of the basic road? Give an example of each.
What statement is the ruler of all statements? State it.
For what three things is this ruling statement useful or necessary?
What three alternatives does a thinker have when his predecessors disagree? Which alternative is most reasonable? What is the connection of these three alternatives with the three parts of wonder? What alternative did Aristotle take in regard to the diversity of opinion in his predecessors about he cause of naturel things?
What are the three alternatives or options open to a mind when it finds that its predecessors disagree? Which alternative is most reasonable? What are the two ways of carrying out this alternative? Which of these ways should be used first? Why?
What are the two ways in which the most reasonable alternative (proceeding with the help of one’s predecessors even though they disagree) can be carried out? show their connection with the basic road Which of these ways should be used first? Why? Show the connection of your answer with the basic road.
What are some of the differences between common knowledge and common opinion?
Show form the basic road in human knowledge the need for finding a common basis in human thought. what connection does the search for a common basis among divergent thinkers or among all men have with the basic road in human knowledge? How does a knowledge of the common basis and a knowledge of the basic road help each other? (Exemplify in Book one of Hearing About Nature)
What are the two comparison used by Heraclitus to bring out the importance of the common basis in human knowledge?
WHY IS IT NECESSARY TO CLARIFY THE COMMON BASIS IN HUMAN THOUGHT AFTER IT HAS BEEN FOUND OR RECOGNIZED?
Show from the basic road in human knowledge that it is absurd to try to prove the obvious. Show from the basic road inhuman knowledge why it can sometimes be useful to consider the reasons of a man who denies the obvious.
What connection does the search for a common basis among diverse=gent thinkers or among all men have with the basic road in human knowledge? How does a knowledge of a common basis and a knowledge of the basic road help each other? Exemplify in book oNe of the physics.
Show how the basic road is often neglected or gone against in natural science and in the sciences of human action as regards the order of knowledge based on common experience and knowledge based on special experience. What is the position of Einstein, Bohr and Heisenberg in this matter?
We find Aristotle pursuing a basis which is more and more common as we follow him through Chapters Four, Five, Six and Seven. State the basis he finds at each step and those who share it.
Why is the first common basis among natural scientists about change?
What is the first common thought about change shared by natural scientists (whether ancient or modern, western or eastern)? What reason can be given for it?
How does Aristotle clarify the common basis in Chapter five?
What reasons are given in Ch. 6 for saying the principles are not unlimited?
Contradiction plays a fundamental role in the development of philosophy, exp. science and theology. In what ways does contradiction contribute to the development of our knowledge? How important is contradiction in the development of our knowledge? Why is the importance of contradiction often overlooked by the student?
What role does contradiction play in the clarification of the common basis in ch. 6? What contradiction forces the mind to recognize a third principle besides the contraries in every change?
Why consider the way all men speak about change? What can be brought out by this means about change? show that al men in some wAy recognize that three things are found in every change. What are these three things? Show that only two of these three are causes as such or through themselves of what comes to be.
What two important clarifications of the common basis are made in Chapter 7.?
Show in three ways that change is between contraries or opposites.
Is it a matter of common knowledge that change is between opposites? What signs are there of this?
Show how the philosopher’s knowledge that change is between opposites goes beyond every man’s knowledge of the same?
Explain the role of contradiction in showing the need for a third principle besides the contraries in every change.
Contradiction plays a fundamental role in the development of philosophy, science,and theology. what contradiction forces the mind to recognize a third principle between the contraries in every change?
In what ways does contradiction contribute to the development of our knowledge? How important is contradiction in the development of our knowledge? Why is the importance of contradiction often overlook by the student and the professor?
Show that all men in some way recognize that three things are found in every change. What are these three things?
Show that only two of these are causes as such of what comes to be.
Can something necessarily come before an effect and not be a cause of that effect? EXPLAIN
Does every man know that nature and art differ? What, if anything, does the philosopher definition of nature ad to every man’s knowledge?
Why is it necessary to consider whether natural science and mathematics differ? Show that they differ and how?
Anaxagoras could not separate the way things are in matter before they are made from the way things are in a box or container. How can we understand the way things are in the first matter or first matter itself?
What part of modern physics has introduced a “quantitative version of potency”, and what developing part of modern physics is apt to be faced even more with this difficult concept of potency which Aristotle was the first to clarify? Why should these two parts involve potency.
Scientists studying the elementary particles often adopt anaxagoras’ way of speaking. explain the common root of their difficulty.
What principle underlying the whole of modern physics is used by Aristotle in his critique of Anaxagoras’ position in ch. four?
What principle(s) does Aristotle’s critique of Anaxagoras’ position on matter share with physics from Galileo to Einstein and Heisenberg?
What truth,involving the difference between mathematics and natural science, does Aristotle’s critique of Anaxagoras’ position on matter have in common with the physics of the twentieth century (relativity and quantum theory)?
What difference between the quantity of natural things and pure mathematics is brought out by Aristotle in his critique of anaxagoras? How is this same difference fundamental in chemical theories of the atom and the molecule
What is the one common source of difficulty in the position of anaxagoras on matter,in the common opinion of the early Greek natural philosophers that substantial change does not exist, in the scientists studying elementary particles who commonly adopted Anaxagoras’ way of speaking and in quantum theory according to Heisenberg? Why does this source cause us difficulty?
Perhaps the next great development in the physico-chemical sciences will be a theory of the elementary particles. this will be our most profound understanding of matter. How does the position and difficulty of anaxagoras enter into the study of elementary particles?
Can something necessarily come before an effect and not be a cause as such of that effect? Explain.
The most difficult thing to understand in natural things is potency where does potency enter into the discussions in Book One of Aristotle’s Physics?
SHOW HOW AN UNDERSTANDING OF POTENCY IS THE SOLUTION TO THE APPARENT CONTRADICTION INVOLVED IN CHANGE BETWEEN CONTRARIES OR OPPOSITES, Show how ignorance of potency is involved in the difficulties of Anaxagoras”
Show how an ignorance of potency is the root of Anaxagoras’ difficulties exposed in Ch. 4 Show how an understanding of potency is in the solution to the apparent contradiction involved in change between contraries or opposites
Can potency or ability be known by itself?
How does an understanding of potency enter into the solution of the wave-particle duality in quantum theory? How great A change was this in our understanding of the natural world in the physical sciences?
What is the difference between Plato and Aristotle on matter and lack of form? How does Aristotle resolve e this difference/
What common basis does Aristotle use between himself and Plato to justify that part of the clarification of Ch. 7 which Plato seems to deny? How does he do this?
Since the hard can never be soft, the hard can never come to be soft. Hence, the hard remains hard forever. Likewise, in the case of any opposites. Hence, there is no change. SOLVE THIS ARGUMENT. WHAT KIND OF FALLACY OR MISTAKE DOES IT INVOLVE?
What difference between the quantity of natural things and quantity in mathematics does Aristotle use in his critique of Anaxagoras’ position on matter? Show that this difference is basic to modern chemistry and physics.
How can we distinguish between the ability of matter and its lack of form. Do so.
What is the first matter out of which all things are made?
Why does our mind seek unity, simplicity and conservation in the first cause?
What is nature?
Give in the order of the basic road the meanings of the word nature. Which meaning of nature distinguishes natural science from the other sciences?
Why is there a problem about the difference between natural science and mathematics. how are they distinguished?
Why is a consideration of the kinds of cause made in natural science rather than in mathematics or in the sciences of human action?
What are the four kinds of cause talked about by the Greeks? What can be aid about the order of these causes in our knowledge and in things?
Define the four kinds of cause and state the three corollaries that follow upon them.
Explain and exemplify the order of many causes in reality within the same kind of cause. How does the order of these causes in things and in our knowledge compare? Do all men know that there are four kinds of causes?
Explain the order of the four kinds of cause and the order of many per se causes in the same kind of causes in the light of the basic road.
Give the second division of cause and the three corollaries that follow upon it.
What is the importance of the answer given to the question whether end or purpose is a cause of the natural for the whole of human life? Show how all the sciences of human action depend upon the answer to the questions about natural purposes.
Give five reasons showing that nature acts for the good or that end is a cause of nature’s operations.
Show from human arts acting for an end, that nature’s operations are also directed towards an end.
State three common arguments against nature acting for an end. If these arguments can be untied, do so.
Action for an end requires a mind. Nature doesn’t have a mind. Therefore the operations of nature are not directed to an end. SOLVE THIS ARGUMENT.