Questions of Principle

← Library · Natural Philosophy

Questions of Principle

Natural Philosophy · Physics Book 1

Not Berquist’s writing; a text he kept. By Werner Heisenberg. From his file: QUESTIONS OF PRINCIPLE.doc.

Word doc

QUESTIONS OF PRINCIPLE

Werner Heisenberg, The Physicist's Conception of Nature, Scientific Book Guild, London, p. 53:

...what always distinguished Greek thought from that of all other peoples was its ability to change the questions it asked into questions of principle and thus to arrive at new points of view, bringing order into the colourful kaleidoscope of experience and making it accessible to human thought...

Whoever delves into the philosophy of the Greeks will encounter at every step this ability to pose questions of principle, and thus by reading the Greeks he can become practised in the use of the strongest mental tool produced by Western thought.

Werner Heisenberg, The Physicist's Conception of Nature, Scientific Book Guild, London, p. 63:

Those, however, who...wish to get to the root of things in their chosen vocation...are bound sooner or later to encounter the sources of antiquity, and their own work can only benefit if they have learned from the Greeks how to discipline their thoughts and how to pose questions of principle.

I believe that in the work of Max Planck, for instance, we can clearly see that his thought was influenced and made fruitful by his classic schooling.

Werner Heisenberg, “The History of Quantum Theory” in Physics and Philosophy, Harper, N.Y., p. 35:

Bohr’s theory had opened up a new line of research. The great amount of experimental material collected by spectroscopy through several decades was now available for information about the strange quantum laws governing the motions of the electrons in the atom. The many experiments of chemistry could be used for the same purpose.

It was from this time on that the physicists learned to ask the right questions; and asking the right question is frequently more than halfway to the solution of the problem.

What were these questions? Practically all of them had to do with the strange apparent contradiction between the results of different experiments...Again and again one found that the attempt to describe atomic events in the traditional terms of physics led to contradictions.