Role of Contradiction in Discovery

← Library · Natural Philosophy

Role of Contradiction in Discovery

Natural Philosophy · Physics Book 1

From his file: ROLE OF CONTRADICT IN DISCOVERY.doc.

Word doc

Read from in 4 classes

ROLE OF CONTRADICTION IN DISCOVERY

PHILOSOPHY

Heraclitus:

DK 53 War is the father of all things, the king of all things...

DK 80 We must know that war is common to all and strife is justice, and that all things come into being and pass away by strife.

DK 54 The hidden harmony is better than the apparent harmony.

DK 123 Nature loves to hide.

DK 18 If you do not expect the unexpected, you will not find it; for it is hard to be found and difficult.

DK 122 Dispute.

Aristotle, Metaphysics, Book III, Chapter 1 (995a 27-995b 4):

To raise difficulties well is useful for those who wish to resolve them. For the later solution is a loosening of the previous difficulties, [To doubt well before is necessary for those wishing to discover. For the discovery afterwards is an untying of the difficulties before] and it is impossible for those ignorant of a knot to loosen it. But the doubt of the mind shows this about the thing. Insofar as it doubts, it undergoes something about the same as those tied. In both cases, it is impossible to go forward.

Hence one ought to have looked at all the difficulties before, on account of these reasons, and because those investigating without having first considered the difficulties are like those who do not know where they ought to go and, in addition, do not know if the thing sought has been found or not. for the goal is not clear to this one, but it is to the one who has brought up the difficulties before.

Moreover, the one who has heard all the reasons of those disagreeing, like that of two parties in a lawsuit, is necessarily better prepared to judge.

SCIENCE

Max Planck, “New Paths of Physical Knowledge” in A Survey of Physical Theory, Dover, N.Y., p. 46:

The first impulse towards a revision and reconstruction of a physical theory is nearly always given by the discovery of one or more facts which cannot be fitted into the existing theory. Facts always form a central point about which the most important theories hinge. Nothing is more interesting to the true theorist than a fact which directly contradicts a theory generally accepted up to that time, for this is his particular work.

Gamow, Thirty Years That Shook Physics, Doubleday, N.Y., pp. 36-37:

Staggering contradictions... between theoretical expectations on the one side and observational facts or even common sense on the other are the main factors in the development of science.

From Niels Bohr (His Life and Work as seen by his friends and colleagues), edited by S. Rozental, Interscience Publishers, John Wiley & Sons, New York:

Bohr’s hypotheses were only of a provisional character inasmuch as they presented a ‘mixture of Planck’s ideas with the old mechanics’....Nobody was aware of this situation more than Bohr himself....Thus, in a lecture on the new theory which he gave to the Danish Physical Society in December 1913 - and which he himself rightly considered one of his best and clearest lectures - he emphasized this aspect of the problem in the following fine conclusion: ‘Before closing I only wish to say that I hope I have expressed myself sufficiently clearly so that you have appreciated the extent to which these considerations conflict with the admirably coherent group of conceptions which have been rightly termed the classical theory of electrodynamics. On the other hand, I have tried to convey to you the impression that just by emphasizing this conflict, it may be also possible in the course of time to discover a certain coherence in the new ideas." (pp. 60-61)

His [Bohr’s] turn of mind was essentially dialectical rather than reflective. Although he did of course spend long hours in solitary thought, often during sleepless nights, he needed the stimulus of some form of dialogue to start off his thinking. If the proposer of the doubt was at hand, the dialogue could be lively enough, for as soon as Bohr saw his way to the elucidation of the matter, he would make his point with unbounded eagerness and tenacity - not at all to get the better of his opponent, but rather to get him to share his own exhilaration at solving the difficulty...So intensely did he want everyone around him to share them with him. Even after many years he would remember every detail of the argument’s progress, and he would repeatedly tell the story with the same freshness and animation. It was characteristic for these unforgettable conversations, so clearly revealing the essentially dialectical form of this thinking, that he would never try to outline any finished picture, but would patiently go through all phases of the development of a problem, starting from some apparent paradox and gradually leading to its elucidation. (p. 117)

...logical analysis was not for him [Bohr] a mere verification of consistency....but a powerful constructive tool, orienting the groping mind in the right direction. That he saw the heuristic power of logic in its dialectical character is illustrated by the striking comment he made on more than one occasion on his own early experience of scientific discovery: ‘The decisive point about Rutherford’s atom model was that it made quite clear that atomic stability could in no way be accounted for by the classical physical laws, and thereby pointed to the quantum postulate as the only possible escape from the acute dilemma. Just the sharpness of the contradiction made me absolutely confident of the truth of the quantum postulate’. He was still remembering this lesson when, in one of his last conversations, he observed that the reason why no progress was being made in the theory of the transformations of matter occurring at very high energy is that we have not so far found among these processes any one exhibiting a sufficiently violent contradiction with what could be expected from current ideas to give us a clear and unambiguous indication of how we have to modify these ideas. (pp. 117-118)

Difficulties were for him [Bohr] merely the external appearance of new knowledge, and in an apparently hopeless contradiction he conceived the germ of wider and more comprehensive order and harmony. (p. 234)

Werner Heisenberg, “The History of Quantum Theory” in Physics and Philosophy, Harper, N.Y., p. 35:

Bohr’s theory had opened up a new line of research. The great amount of experimental material collected by spectroscopy through several decades was now available for information about the strange quantum laws governing the motions of the electrons in the atom. The many experiments of chemistry could be used for the same purpose.

It was from this time on that the physicists learned to ask the right questions; and asking the right question is frequently more than halfway to the solution of the problem.

What were these questions? Practically all of them had to do with the strange apparent contradiction between the results of different experiments...Again and again one found that the attempt to describe atomic events in the traditional terms of physics led to contradictions.

Albert Einstein, The Evolution of Physics, Simon and Shuster, N.Y.:

The relativity theory arose from necessity, from serious and deep contradictions in the old theory from which there seemed no escape. The strength of the new theory lies in the consistency and simplicity with which it solves all these difficulties, using only a few very convincing assumptions. (p. 192)

One of the most fundamental questions raised by recent advances in science is how to reconcile the two contradictory views of matter and wave. It is one of those fundamental difficulties which, once formulated, must lead, in the long run, to scientific progress. Physics has tried to solve this problem. The future must decide whether the solution suggested by modern physics is enduring or temporary. (p. 280)

Science forces us to create new ideas, new theories. Their aim is to break down the wall of contradictions which frequently blocks the way of scientific progress. All the essential ideas in science were born in a dramatic conflict between reality and our attempts at understanding. (p. 264)

THEOLOGY

The Gospel according to St. Matthew, Chapter 22, vv. 41-46:

While the Pharisees were gathered round, Jesus put to them this question, "What is your opinion about the Christ? Whose son is he?"

“David’s" they told him.

‘Then how is it’"he said "that David, moved by the Spirit, calls him Lord, where he says:

The Lord said to my Lord: Sit at my right hand and I will put your enemies under your feet

"If David can call him Lord, then how can he be his son?"

No one could think of anything to say in reply, and from that day no one dared to ask him any further questions.

St. Augustine, The City of God, Book XVI, Chapter 2:

But even the heretics yield an advantage to those who make proficiency, according to the apostle’s saying, ‘There must also be heresies, that they which are approved may be made manifest among you." (I Cor., Ch. 11, v. 19) Whence, too, it is elsewhere said, ‘The son who receives instruction will be wise, and he uses the foolish as his servant." (Prov., Ch. 10, v. 5 in Septuagint). For while the hot restlessness of heretics stirs up questions about many articles of the Catholic faith, the necessity of defending them forces us both to investigate them more accurately, to understand them more clearly, and to proclaim them more earnestly; and the question mooted by an adversary becomes the occasion of instruction.

The Second Vatican Council, Decree on Priestly Training, n. 16, Newman Press ed.. pp. 226-227:

Dogmatic theology should be so arranged that these biblical themes are proposed first of all.

Next there should be opened up to the students what the Fathers of the Eastern and Western church have contributed to the faithful transmission and development of the individual truths of revelation.

The further history of dogma should also be presented, account being taken of its relation to the general history of the Church.

Next, in order that they may illumine the mysteries of salvation as completely as possible, the students should learn to penetrate them more deeply with the help of speculation, under the guidance of Thomas, and to perceive their interconnections.