← Library · Natural Philosophy
Schrodinger - Indeterminism
Natural Philosophy · Physics Book 3
Not Berquist’s writing; a text he kept. By Erwin Schrodinger. From his file: SCHRODINGER - INDETERMINISM.doc.
Erwin Schrodinger, "Indeterminism in Physics", in the collection of his papers Science,Theory and Man, Dover Publications, N.Y., pp. 55-63:
The modern attempts to relinquish determinism are rendered particularly interesting by the fact that their claims with regard to the absence of determinism, far from being vague and inaccurate, are quantitatively quite definite and can be expressed in centimeters, grams and seconds. As a simple example, we may take a mass point in motion either in a state of isolation from others or as a member of a system of many mass points exerting force upon each other. The claim which is made is that its movement cannot be foretold with complete accuracy because, among other things, it would be necessary to know its position and velocity at the initial point of time; and it is claimed that it is impossible in principle to determine both of these exactly. Let us assume that we have succeeded in ascertaining that the point must at any rate be situated somewhere within a small area whose linear dimensions I will call L. Let us take any point within this area and from it draw an arrow to denote the velocity in the customary way. Let us next assume that we have succeeded in determining the direction and the magnitude of the velocity sufficiently to enable us to restrict the point of the arrow which symbolizes these latter to a small area, whose linear dimensions I propose to denote by G. Finally let M denote the mass of this material point. The sufficiently peculiar assertion then is that the product MGL cannot be reduced beneath a certain definite limit. It is claimed that the inaccuracy which is inherent in the position (L) and that which adheres to the velocity at the same time (G) cannot both be reduced to a greater degree, than to give the product MGL, the approximate magnitude of what is known as Planck' constant h:
27 2 1 MGL approximately equals h = 6:5 X 10 g. cm. sec.
Now although the value of this constant is extremely small, yet it can be expressed with perfect accuracy in centimeters, grams and seconds; it can be derived from the laws governing heat radiation and by many other extremely exact methods. What is claimed then is that, while it is possible to make one of these two regions (L) and (G) as small as may be desired, and their relative statements as exact as may be desired, this is achieved only at the cost of increasing the other. In other words, it is impossible to make both as small as may be desired (Heisenberg's relation of inexactitude)...
What is peculiar in this theoretical assertion is the fact that there is a rigid limit to the accuracy of observation, a limit which in its turn is determined by a constant of Nature. Hitherto in all our theoretical considerations we had quite unconsciously assumed, that at any rate in principle, observations could be carried out with any degree of accuracy; nobody had dreamed that a correlation of the kind mentioned between the accuracies of the different measurements (in the present instance position and velocity) did in fact exist.....
According to the new theory, identical conditions at the beginning do not invariably lead to identical results; all that they lead to is identical statistics (= relative frequency of the various possible events); indeed this is precisely what we mean by indeterminateness.
Now what I wish to claim is that from a purely naive point of view, classical mechanics itself is undeterminate. The opposite is generally asserted; but this is due merely to a technique to which we have grown so accustomed in course of time that we take it for granted. Let us take a mass point in motion. We find that at a certain moment it is at a given point; we are perfectly acquainted with the nature and condition of its entire environment: thus, for example, in the case of a stone which has been thrown and is situated in a gravitational field, we know all the forces acting upon it. In such circumstances, can we tell on the lines of classical mechanics how the body will be moving in the next instant of time? And if the experiment is repeated, will the identical circumstances at the beginning be followed invariably by an identical trajectory? We know that such is not the case. We know, on the contrary, that the mere notion of its position and of the forces acing on the body in one moment, leaves us in the completest ignorance of what is going to happen in the next moment. It is only when we know what it will be doing in the next moment that we can make precise predictions relating to the "next but one" (as it were) and to all the following: for, according to classical mechanics, it is accelerations and not velocities that the bodies determine in each other. A good deal of time had to elapse before this fact was grasped: the ancient Greeks and, as I believe, the Middle Ages up to and including Descartes were of a different opinion...it was Galileo and Newton who realized that, while their velocities remain undetermined, it is their acceleration which was determined. If the question is asked how a mass point will be moving in the next moment the only answer furnished by classical mechanics is: "I do not know; if you want to know, watch it!"
Now the special technique by which classical mechanics dodges the awkward fact of indeterminateness (the fact that equal initial conditions are followed by different consequences) consists in including the initial velocity within the initial conditions. It simply states that the initial velocity must be given because unless it is given we are not fully acquainted with the initial condition: the initial velocity is taken as forming part of the initial condition at any given moment. Now if we look at the matter carefully it will appear very dubious whether such a procedure is permissible. Velocity, after all, is defined as a differential quotient with respect to time:
X X dx = the limit of 2 - 1 for t - t = 0 t - t 2 1
This definition refers to two moments of time and not to the state at one moment. True, it is believed that these two moments can at will be taken so close to each other as to make them "coincide" in the limit. Possibly, however, this is incorrect; possibly the mathematical process of approach to the limit, which was especially invented by Newton for mechanical purposes, is inadmissible. It may be that the mathematical apparatus devised by Newton is inadequately adapted to nature; and the modern claim that the concept of velocity becomes meaningless for a precisely defined position in space points strongly in that direction...
In order to avoid misunderstanding I would like to state that the above is a consideration which I have added as an afterthought to the indeterminism which has arisen in modern theory. It is not the case that the modern view is a natural growth arising out of a hypercritical scrutiny of Newton's differential calculus; if it had been possible to deal adequately with actual observed phenomena by means of Newtonian mechanics, no physicist would have found any fault with them.