← Library · Intro to Philosophy
Summary of the Four Causes
Intro to Philosophy · 4 Causes
From his file: summary4causes.tex.
Read from in 5 classes
- Natural Hearing — 42. Aristotle's Three Corollaries on Causes and Nature as Form
- De Anima — 14. De Anima II.2: Definition and Demonstration, Wonder, and Reasoning from the Soul's Activities
- Wisdom (2005) — 8. The Four Causes and the First Philosophers: Thales and Anaximander
- Prima Pars — 90. Aquinas on Predestination (ST I, Q.23, Arts. 5–6): Is It Caused by Foreseen Merits, and Is It Certain?
- Prima Secundae — 29. Violence, Fear and the Involuntary (Prima Secundae Q.6, aa.5–6)
1. Matter is that from which something comes to be, existing within it.
2. Form is the definition of what was to be, e.g., the model or exemplar, an extrinsic form copied or imitated.
3. Mover or Maker is whence first there is a beginning of motion.
4. End is that for the sake of which (something is or is done).
We should not expect to find all kinds of causes in everything. Not everything can be said to have all 4 kinds of cause (e.g., geometry vs. nature).
Corollaries
There can be many causes as such of the very same thing. Analyzing the definition of marriage, for example, we can find all 4 causes: “a stable union of a man and a woman by mutual choice for the sake of children.” Not so with geometry, in which perhaps we only consider the formal cause. With God, we recognize that he is the Mover or Maker and the End for the sake of which all things are (“I am the Alpha and the Omega, the First and the Last, the Beginning and the End”). He is not the matter in any way at all. God is the extrinsic form whose image is impressed upon us and the exemplar whom we imitate (“Be perfect as your heavenly Father is perfect”) but he is not the intrinsic form of anything.
Two things can be causes of each other, but by different kinds of causes. For example, health is a cause of exercise as an end or that for the sake of which I exercise; but exercise makes me healthy. Another example: “Hail Mary, full of grace, the Lord is with thee.” Is Mary full of grace because the Lord is with her, or is the Lord with her because she is full of grace? Both are true but by a different kind of cause.
The same thing is sometimes responsible for contraries, by its presence or absence. For example: the captain is responsible for the safety or the destruction of the ship either by his attention or inattention ... the same can be said of a student being responsible for his knowledge or ignorance by his attention or inattention.