Texts on Distinction

← Library · Wisdom about Beginnings

Texts on Distinction

Wisdom about Beginnings · 1st Axiom about Things

From his file: TEXTS ON DISTINCTION.doc.

Word doc

Scriptum super Lib. I Sententiarum, Dist XXXIV, Q. I, Art. I, Ad 2:

de eodem, secundum quod idem est, impossible est aliquid idem affirmare et negare; sed si in aliquo distinguantur, affirmationes et negationes pertinentes ad illam distinctionem de ipso verificari poterunt:

quia omnis distinctio, sive rei sive rationis, fundatur in affirmatione et negatione.

Summa Contra Gentiles, Liber IV, Caput 14:

Ubicumque enim est aliqua distinctio, oportet inveniri negationis et affirmationis oppositionem.

Quae enim secundum nullam affirmationem et negationem differunt, penitus indistincta sunt: oportet enim quod quantum ad omnia unum esset quod et alterum, et sic essent penitus idem, et nullo modo distincta.

In IV Metaphysicorum, Lectio IX, n. 660:

Item prohibet ne mente aliquid possimus definire vel determinare.

Prima enim ratio distinctionis consideratur in affirmatione et negatione.

Unde qui affirmationem et negationem unum esse dicit, omnem determinationem sive distinctionem excludit.

In IV Metaphysicorum, Lectio III, n. 566:

Sed unum quod cum ente convertitur importat privationem divisionis formalis quae fit per opposita,

cuius prima radix est oppositio affirmationis et negationis.

Nam illa dividuntur adinvicem, quae ita se habent, quod hoc non est illud. Summa Contra Gentiles, Liber I, Caput 71:

in ratione distinctionis est negatio: distincta enim sunt quorum unum non est aliud.

Unde et prima, quae seipis distinguuntur, mutuo sui negationem includunt: ratione cuius negativae propositiones in eis sunt immediatae, ut, Nulla quantitas est substantia.

Scriptum super Lib. I Sententiarum, Dist. V, Q. I, Art. I, Ad 1:

affirmatio et negatio dicuntur maxime opponi, quia in eis non importatur aliqua convenientia:

in privative enim oppositis importatur convenientia quantum ad subjectum, quia nata sunt fieri circa idem:

in contrariis autem et relativis etiam quantum ad genus, quia scilicet sunt in eodem genere. Unde in utraque oppositione utrumque extremorum significatur per modum entis et naturae cujusdam.

Illud autem in quo invenitur aliquid non permixtum contrario, est maximum et primum in genere illo, et causa omnium aliorum;

et ideo oppositio affirmationis et negationis, cui non admiscetur aliqua convenientia, est prima et maxima oppositio, et causa omnis oppositionis et distinctionis;

et ideo oportet quod in qualibet alia oppositione includatur affirmatio et negatio, sicut primum in posteriori.

Unde plura requiruntur ad alias oppositiones quam ad oppositionem contradictionis, quia se habent ex additione ad ipsam.

Unde non oportet quod, si contrarietas non inveniatur nisi in diversis realiter, quod affirmatio et negatio inveniatur in diversis realiter. [objection was: essentia non est generans, Pater est generans, ergo Pater non est essentia]

immo sufficit etiam distinctio rationis ad affirmationem et negationem: et talis distinctio, scilicet rationis, est inter essentiam et personam.

Sed opposita relative aliquando requirunt diversitatem vel distinctionem realem; et talia sunt quae divinas personas distinguunt: aliquando autem distinctionem rationis tantum; ut cum dicitur idem eidem idem.

Summa Contra Gentiles, Liber II, Caput 44:

Omnis distinctio est aut secundum divisionem quantitatis...aut secundum divisionem formalem. Quae sine graduum diversitate esse non potest, cum talis divisio reducitur ad privationem et formam.

Summa Contra Gentiles, Liber IV, Caput 24:

in rebus enim, remota materiali distinctione, quae in divinis personis locum habere non potest, non inveniuntur aliqua distingui nisi per aliquam oppositionem.

Quae enim nullam oppositionem habent ad invicem, simul esse possunt in eodem, unde per ea distinctio causari non potest: album enim et triangulare, licet diversa sunt, quia tamen non opponuntur, in eodem esse contingit.

Oportet autem supponere, secundum fidei catholicae documenta, quod Spiritus Sanctus a Filio distinguatur: aliter enim non esset trinitas, sed dualitas in personis. Oportet igitur huiusmodi distinctionem per aliquam oppositionem fieri.

Non autem oppositione affirmationis et negationis: quia sic distinguuntur entia a non entibus.

Nec etiam oppositione privationis et habitus: quia sic distinguuntur perfecta ab imperfectis.

Neque etiam oppositione contrarietatis. Quia sic distinguuntur quae sunt secundum formam diversa: nam contrarietas, ut philosophi docent, est differentia secundum formam...

Relinquitur igitur unam personam divinam ab alia non distingui nisi oppositione relationis.

Between the above text and the one before it, there would seem to be a contradiction. Is the opposition of contradiction or of affirmation and negation found in God? Perhaps it is denied insofar as it is a kind of opposition distinguished from the rest with a different basis for distinction from the other three for the reason given by Thomas above. But perhaps it is affirmed insofar as it is found in the other three kinds of opposition. See also Scriptum super Lib. I Sententiarum, Dist. V, Q. I, Art. I, Ad 1 below.

Summa Theologiae, Prima Pars, Q. 70, Art. 1, c:

Distinctio autem aliquorum maxime manifestatur per motum localem, quo ab invicem separantur.

THE ABOVE IS INTERESTING TO BEAR IN MIND WHEN CONSIDERING THE ID A QUO NOMEN IMPONITUR OF DIFFERENCE OR DIAPHORA.

Quaestiones Disputatae de Veritate, Q 5, Art. 2, 7 & Ad 7:

7. Praeterea principia quaedam sunt in rerum natura quae neque etiam Deus potest mutare, sicut hoc principium quod non est de eodem affirmare et negare. Ergo, ad minus, huiusmodi providentia gubernante et providente non indigent.

Ad septimum dicendum, quod necessitas principiorum dictorum consequitur providentiam divinam et dispositionem: ex hoc enim quod res productae sunt in tali natura, in qua habent esse terminatum, sunt distinctae a suis negationibus: ex qua distinctione sequitur quod affirmatio et negatio non sunt simul vera; et ex hoc principio est necessitas in omnibus aliis principiis, ut dicitur in IV Metaphysicorum.

CONTRADICTION IN JUDGING AND FINDING

The word grow can be and should be carried over from the body to the soul and the mind or reason. For we know and name what cannot be sensed by likeness to what can be sensed. Shakespeare touches upon this carrying over in beautiful words:

Hamlet, Act I, Sc. 3:

For nature crescent does not grow alone In thews and bulk, but as this temple waxes, The inward service of the mind and soul Grows wide withal

Heraclitus, DK 115:

The soul has a reason which makes itself grow.

Empedocles, DK 17:

...But come listen to my words. for learning will surely cause your mind to grow.

How mental growth does take place - Importance of the beginning:

Antiphon, DK 60:

The first thing, I believe, for mankind is education. For whenever someone has made a beginning correctly in anything, it is likely that the end will also come about correctly. And as is the seed one has sown in the ground, so also are the things one ought to expect will come forth. And when one sows a noble education in a young body, this lives and blooms through the whole of life, and neither rain nor drought destroys it. Reason grows from seeds.

The statement about contradiction is a seed of all judgment and of the most important dicoveries.

The logic of the third act of reason was divided by the ancients into the knowledge of judging and the knowledge of finding. Contradiction and the statement about contradiction are the beginning of all judging and the beginnning of the greatest discoveries, the finding of the greatest things. In what follows, we intend to bring out the truth of these statements. But we must first say what is contradiction and what is the statement about contradiction.

Contradiction is the opposition of being and non-being.

The statement about contradiction can be stated thus: it is impossible both to be and not be (at the same time in the same way).

CONTRADICTION IN JUDGING

The role and place of the statement about contradiction in judging can be seen more distinctly after we have considered a distinction which Aristotle and Huyghens saw about judging.

All true statements rest upon the statement about contradiction. The statement about contradiction is the beginning and the end of all other statements and the judging of them. And contradiction is the beginning of the most important discoveries.

The statement about contradiction is first in the genus of statements. And what is first in some genus is a cause and measure of all that comes after.

CONTRADICTION IN FINDING

Definition, division and distinction. The contradictions to which sophistical reasoning lead are useful for seeing the need for the (three) distinctions that are not divisions (in the strict sense) and making them.