The Before and After in Our Consideration of Change

← Library · Natural Philosophy

The Before and After in Our Consideration of Change

Natural Philosophy · Physics Book 1

From his file: BEFORE & AFTER CONSID. CHANGE.doc.

Word doc

THE BEFORE AND AFTER IN OUR CONSIDERATION OF CHANGE

The consideration of change would seem to come before every other consideration of our mind. Since sensing comes before understanding in our knowledge, things sensed come before all other things in our knowledge. And since, as Shakespeare says, "things in motion sooner catch the eye than what not stirs", it would seem that change and changing things are considered by our mind before anything else.

But within our consideration of change, there is a before and after. We can begin to look at this before and after from the following statement: Change of place is before every other kind of change in our knowledge.

One sign of this is the science of mechanics. Mechanics which considers change of place, was the first part (in time) of modern science to be perfected, and it can be without the other parts, but they cannot be without it.

Another sign is this: many who studied change of place denied there was any other kind of change or tried to reduce all other apparently different kinds of change to change of place. This is true not only of the modern mechanists, but also of ancient thinkers such as Empedocles, Anaxagoras and Democritus. But we do not find the reverse; that is, men asserting other kinds of change, but denying the existence of change of place.

A third sign is that names from change of place are carried over and placed upon other kinds of change; for example, going from cold to hot, coming into existence and going out of existence, quantum jumps and so on. And we name things in the order that we know them.

If change of place is the only kind of change, the whole of natural science would be about change of place. There would be no part before or after the study of change of place. But if change of place is not the only kind of change, one should consider change in general before change of place and other kinds of change after change of place.

Actually men are sure there are other kinds of change besides change of place (for example, death), but they deny this in words because of the great difficulty in understanding how any other kind of change is possible. No other kind of change is possible without the ability which Aristotle was the first to bring out clearly (so far as the nature of ability admits of being known) and which was not seen in modern science until perhaps quantum theory.