The Discovery of the Five Predicables

← Library · Logic as a Whole

The Discovery of the Five Predicables

Logic as a Whole · Toward Beginning of Logic

From his file: DISCOVERY OF THE FIVE PREDICABL.doc.

Word doc

THE DISCOVERY OF THE FIVE PREDICABLES

The five predicables are to logic as matter, form and lack of form are to natural philosophy. (Coplestone, Greece and Rome p. 119 Antisthenes "Man is man"; p. 104 Socratic definition)

Although a treatise by Aristotle on the five predicables (such as is the Isagoge of Porphyry) has not come down to us, we find in the great tradition of Greek and Arab and Latin Commentators on the logical works of Aristotle and Porphyry that the five predicables are regarded as the cornerstone of the science of logic. Porphyry himself is careful to point out the immense importance of the five predicables for the entire science of logic. Porphyry restricts himself to pointing out the more obvious parts of logic that are dependent upon the doctrine of the five predicables: the Categories, the science of division, the science of definition, and that of demonstration. But the other parts of logic also seem to be dependent upon the teaching about the five predicables. Although the four predicates of the Topics (accident, genus, property, definition) should not be confused with the five predicables, they would seem nevertheless to presuppose them. Even the Prior Analytics depends upon the teaching of the five predicables as can be seen most easily when Aristotle shows how to make or discover syllogisms through definitions and properties. If then the whole of logic depends upon the five predicables (as should be shown more fully another time), they are to logic as matter, form and lack of form are to natural philosophy.

But although Aristotle has left us an intriguing account of how he discovered matter, form and lack of form or of how they were suggested. anticipated and led up to by the work and difficulties of his predecessors, he has left no similar account of how the five predicables were arrived at. In this paper, we shall attempt to reconstruct something of the way in which the five predicables were most likely discovered.

Our purpose is not primarily to fill a gap in our historical knowledge. Rather, we hope that our understanding of the five predicables can be increased by a knowledge of how they may reasonably be expected to have been discovered or approached by the man who seems to have built the entire science of logic upon them. Aristotle certainly thought that the way in which we approach and discover matter, form and lack of form is extremely important for understanding them. Would he have thought differently for the five predicables?

There is, however, a passage in the book On Sophistical Refutations which calls into serious doubt whether Aristotle would have tried to do, in regard to the five predicables, in a proportional way, what he did in regard to the matter, form and lack in Book One of the Physics. [quote passage]

The necessity of considering the positions and arguments of those who deny reasoning, error and definition is proportional to the necessity of considering Parmenides and Melissus in the first book of the Physics.