The End or Purpose of Logic

← Library · Logic as a Whole

The End or Purpose of Logic

Logic as a Whole

From his file: Log 1st Definitions& Distinctions.doc.

Word doc

THE END OR PURPOSE OF LOGIC

Logic is for the perfection and good of three acts of our looking reason: understanding what a thing is, understanding the true or the false, and reasoning.

There is an order among these three acts for the first can be without the second, but the reverse is not possible. And the second can be without the third, but the reverse is not possible.

THE CHIEF SUBJECTS OF LOGIC

Logic is about the tools for perfecting the above three acts.

Definition is the chief tool for the perfection of understanding what a thing is because definition is speech signifying what a thing is, or speech making known what a thing is.

Statement is the chief tool for understanding the true or the false because the true or the false is found only in a statement which is nothing other than speech signifying the true or the false.

Syllogism is the chief tool for reasoning because it is speech, in which some statements laid down, another follows necessarily because of those laid down.

Logic is thus chiefly about definition, statement and syllogism. Logic is the reasoned out knowledge of definition, statement and syllogism.

THE FIRST DEFINITIONS IN LOGIC

Since logic is the reasoned out knowledge of definition, statement and syllogism, and each of these is a speech composed of names, we must first define speech and name as these are found in logic

Following the father of logic in his Peri Hermeneias, we can define them thus. Speech is vocal sound signifying by human agreement having parts that signify by themselves. Name is defined in the same way except for the last difference. A name is a vocal sound signifying by human agreement, no part of which signifies by itself.

NAME BEFORE SPEECH

Since we must name things before we can speak of them and speech is composed of names, the logician must consider name before speech.

WHY THE LOGICIAN CONSIDERS NAME SAID OF MANY THINGS

The logician is mainly interested in name said of many things. (By many is meant more than one.) For the name of the defined is said of many things because we define the universal and not the singular. We define, for example, square and not this or that square. And the names in the definition are even more universal. Likewise, the syllogism is based on something being said of all or none of another. And most statements that say something more than a thing is itself will say something universal of it.

Moreover, looking reason tries to understand the universal while practical reason aims at making or doing something, which is singular. But logic is directed chiefly to the good of looking reason. Hence, Albert the Great says that the first thing to be considered in logic is the universal. But we can be more sensible and say that it is name said of many things.

THE FIRST DISTINCTION OF NAMES SAID OF MANY THINGS

The first distinction in logic of names said of many things is between name said univocally of many things and name said equivocally of many things. A name is said of many things either with the same meaning in mind when said of each or with other meanings in mind. In the former, it is said univocally and in the latter, equivocally. Animal has the same meaning when said of dog and cat. But bat has other meanings when said of the flying rodent and the wooden tool used in baseball. One should know whether he has one meaning in mind or many when he uses a word or name.

THE DISTINCTION OF NAMES SAID UNIVOCALLY OF MANY THINGS

A distinction of names said univocally of many things that is useful and necessary for understanding the Categories of Aristotle, definition, division, and demonstration was made by Porphyry in his Isagoge. This distinction is extremely important in logic. Without it, one can hardly understand anything in logic. The Isagoge, or the teaching therein, is the first book of logic

THE DISTINCTION OF NAMES SAID EQUIVOCALLY OF MANY THINGS

Following the father of logic, we can see a distinction between a name said equivocally by chance of many things and a name said equivocally by reason of many things. The logician needs to consider at length the latter to see how or for what reason things are named equivocally by reason

WHY THE LOGICIAN MUST CONSIDER NAME EQUIVOCAL BY REASON

The father of logic said that the most common mistake in thinking is from mixing up different meanings of the same word. We are more apt to mix up the senses of a word equivocal by reason than one equivocal by chance. For in the latter, the meanings are altogether different, but in the former they are more alike or more connected.

But there are other reasons for considering name equivocal by reason besides avoiding the most common kind of mistake in reasoning. Aristotle discovered that the most common words used everywhere, in every art and science and in daily speech and especially in wisdom and the axioms (which underlie all reasoned out knowledge) are all equivocal by reason. Hence, if we do not understand how a word becomes equivocal by reason, our understanding of wisdom and the axioms and indeed everything (not only because the common names are used everywhere, but also because there are some names equivocal by reason private to one study or another) is deficient.

And since there are names equivocal by reason in the Categories (especially in the third part called the post-predicaments), a consideration of name equivocal by reason is also (like the Isagoge) useful and necessary for an understanding of the Categories.