The Necessity Of The Eucharist
DHB
From his file: NecessityOfTheEucharist.doc.
Duane Berquist, Ph.D.
The Necessity Of The Eucharist
Duane Berquist, Ph.D., is a Professor of Philosophy at Assumption College in Worchester, Massachusetts. He is the brother of our founding tutor, Marc Berquist, and has lectured here several times over the years. The following is abridged from a lecture he gave at the College in celebration of St. Thomas Aquinas Day on March 5, 1999:
St. Thomas gives many reasons for many things about the Eucharist in many places. But the reasons he gives in his Commentary on the First Epistle to the Corinthians are noteworthy for their abundance and especially for their distinction and order. He gives reasons in five ordered steps, which I would like to address. 1. The Necessity Of The Eucharist. Thomas first explains why the Eucharist, together with Baptism and Confirmation, is necessary for the spiritual life. He says: It should be known that the sacraments are instituted on account of the necessity of the spiritual life. And because bodily things have certain likenesses to spiritual things, it is necessary for the sacrament to be proportioned to those things necessary for the life of the body in which there is first found generation, which Baptism is proportional, by which someone is regenerated into spiritual life. Second, for bodily life is required growth, by which someone is brought to a perfect size and power. To this is proportioned the sacrament of Confirmation in which the Holy Spirit is given for strength. Third, for bodily life is required food, by which the body of man is sustained and likewise the spiritual life by the Eucharist. St. Thomas is saying that Baptism, Confirmation, and the Eucharist are to the spiritual life as birth, growth, and nourishment, or food, are to the life of the body. This, of course, is what our Lord suggests when, in John 3, He tells Nicodemus "Amen, amen I say to thee, unless a man be born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God," and what He says later in John 6: "For my flesh is food indeed and my blood drink indeed." 2. Why Christ Is Present In The Eucharist. Inasmuch as St. Thomas shows that the Eucharist is necessary as spiritual food, he then shows why Christ is present in the sacrament, according to His own substance, and not just by His own power. He states: It should be noted that the one generating is not joined to the one generated according to its substance, but only according to its power. But food is joined to the one nourished through its very substance. Whence in the sacrament of Baptism, by which Christ regenerates us for salvation, Christ is not there according to His very substance but only according to His power. [But in the Eucharist] Christ is now present, where first was the substance of bread and wine, by transubstantiation. St. Thomas elsewhere explains why Christ is contained in the Eucharist, but not in Baptism. He first considers a difference between bodily generation and bodily food: It should be considered that in a different way the one generating is joined to the one generated, and in another way nourishment or food is joined to the one nourished in bodily things. For the one generating is not by his very substance joined to the one generated but only according to likeness and power. But food is necessarily joined to the one nourished by its very substance. And then in the same chapter, he adapts this difference to Baptism and the Eucharist: Whence spiritual effects might correspond to bodily signs, the mystery of the Word made flesh is joined to us differently in Baptism, which is spiritual generation and in another way in the sacrament of the Eucharist which is spiritual food. And then he draws the conclusion: In Baptism is contained the Incarnated Word only according to its power, but in the sacrament of the Eucharist it is contained by its very substance. Elsewhere, he states: This is fitting first of all to the perfection of the new law. For the sacrifices of the old law contain that true sacrifice of the passion of Christ only in figure: "The law had the shadow of future goods." (Heb. 10:1). Therefore it is necessary that the new law, instituted by Christ, have something more. It contains the one suffering or undergoing, not only in signification and figure, but in truth. And therefore this sacrament that really contains Christ is perfection of all the other sacraments, in which the power of Christ is partaken. The second reason is that this belongs and is fitting in the love of Christ, from which He assumed a true body or nature for our salvation. The philosopher says, "And because it is most of all proper to friendship to live together with one's friends." Christ promised us His bodily presence as a reward: "Where the body is there the faithful shall be gathered." But also He did not want us to be destitute of His bodily presence in the pilgrimage. But through the truth of His body and blood, He joined himself to us in the sacrament. Whence He Himself says, "Who eats my flesh and drinks my blood remains in me and I in him." Whence this sacrament is most of all a sign of charity, and it is a raising up of our hope, from such a familiar joining of Him to us. 3. Why Christ Is Hidden In The Eucharist Under The Outward Form Of Another Thing. St. Thomas gives three reasons why Christ is in this sacrament hidden under the outward form of another thing. First, it would be horrible to the faithful, he says, if they were to receive the sacrament under the appearances of Christ's own body and blood, because people (he notes dryly) are not accustomed to eat such things. Second, he says, again appealing to common sense, the sacrament would "become mocked by the unfaithful" - charges of cannibalism and so forth would be leveled. But the third reason is especially interesting. He says that Christ is hidden so that "the merit of believing might increase." It is important, he notes, that "one believe the things that were not seen." In a way, the Miracle at Cana was a sign that prepared the way for the Eucharist. At the marriage feast, Christ turned water into wine, while in the Eucharist He turned wine into His blood. But in turning water into wine, Christ did not keep wine under the outward form of water. For one thing, the miracle would not have served the intention wished by His mother and needed at the feast. Also, there is nothing horrible about consuming wine under the outward form of wine and there is nothing that would allow others to deride Him for doing so. Indeed, this miracle impressed the wine steward and caused His disciples to believe in Him. But the miracle of the Eucharist, even more than the miracle at Cana, makes it possible for us to merit in believing. And so it is fitting. As we know from Paul's definition, because faith is of invisible things, just as He shows His divinity to us in an invisible way, so also in this sacrament He shows His flesh to us in an invisible way. 4. Why Christ Is Hidden Under Two Outward Forms In General. St. Thomas gives three reasons why the Eucharist is rendered under a twofold outward form. First, he says, on account of its perfection. "For since it is a spiritual refreshment, it ought to have spiritual food and spiritual drink because bodily refreshment is not perfected without food and drink." Second, he says, "on account of its signification." The Eucharist is a memorial of Our Lord's passion, where the blood of Christ was separated from His body. Accordingly, it is fitting that the Eucharist be represented as such, the blood apart from the body. Third, he says, on account of the saving effect of this sacrament, which saves both body and soul. That is why Psalm 52, the passion psalm, refers to both the salvation of the body and the soul, and is also why our Lord refers to the same in John 6:6, when he links the Eucharist with the raising up of our bodies on the Last Day. 5. Why Christ Is Hidden Under Two Outward Forms In Particular, Bread and Wine. St. Thomas gives three reasons for this. First, "because bread and wine are commonly used by man for nourishment, and therefore they are taken in this sacrament, just as water is for washing in Baptism, and oil for anointing in other sacraments." Eating bread and drinking wine makes a lot of sense to an Italian! "Second," he says "on account of the power of the sacrament. For bread strengthens the heart of man, but wine rejoices the heart of man." This signifies two effects of the Eucharist. The Eucharist gives us the strength to do the will of God and also joy in doing that will. Bread signifies this for bread is called the staff of life. But it is not enough to have the strength to do the will of God; we must also rejoice in doing His will. Now these two effects of the strengthening signified by bread and the rejoicing by the wine is found in Scripture, for example in the Psalms, where we read: "Thou bringest forth . . . wine to cheer the heart of man . . . and that bread may strengthen the heart of man." St. Thomas' final explanation of why Christ is hidden in bread and wine is that "bread, which comes to be from many grains, and wine from many grapes, signify the unity of the Church, which is put together from many of the faithful." He cites to St. Augustine, who notes that the sacrament of the Eucharist is especially the sacrament of unity and charity. Other Points. St. Thomas also elaborates on certain particulars about the Eucharist. For example, he comments on the blessing of the bread and wine, observing that it is a blessing of the fruit of the earth, a blessing which counters the curse laid upon Adam in his labor: "The earth will be cursed in your labor and will germinate spines and other things." He also sees a threefold signification of the breaking of the bread. First, the breaking signifies the mystery of Christ's passion, because it reflects the piercing He suffered on the cross: "They have pierced my hands and feet, they have numbered all my bones." (Psalm 17). Second, the breaking signifies that He is broken from one to many, just as in the Incarnation in which the Word of God became both God and man. Finally, St. Thomas says that the breaking of the bread "signifies the effect it has on diverse things." He quotes St. Paul, "There are divisions of graces though the same spirit." St. Thomas also sees a connection between the last words of Christ in Matthew - "behold I am with you all days, until the consummation of the world" - to Our Lord's Prayer, "Give us this day our daily bread." The name Emmanuel (or God is with us), we know, has special reference to the Incarnation, and thereby also to the Eucharist. The Incarnation and the Eucharist both raise our hope that we might see God face to face. They not only show His love for us, but also His willingness to be joined intimately to man. It is fitting, then, that the Incarnation be represented in this sacrament in some outward way, such as in the breaking of the bread.