The Order of Consideration of the Dispositions of Desire Necessary in the Philosopher

← Library · Wisdom about Beginnings

The Order of Consideration of the Dispositions of Desire Necessary in the Philosopher

Wisdom about Beginnings · Beginning of Philosophy in the Will

From his file: ORDER OF DISPOSITIONS OF DESIRE.doc.

Word doc

THE ORDER OF CONSIDERATION OF THE DISPOSITIONS OF DESIRE NECESSARY IN THE PHILOSOPHER

By desire in our title is meant chiefly the will, but also (to some extent) the emotions.

All knowledge of the dispositions of desire necessary in the philosopher should be anchored firmly in two beginning statements. (1) No one can become a philosopher without wonder and (2) No one can be a philosopher without the love of wisdom.

The philosopher is named from the love of wisdom. And Socrates (or Plato) in the Theaetetus clearly states that there is no other beginning of philosophy than wonder. And Aristotle also clearly witnesses in the beginning of the Metaphysics that men both now and in the beginning started to philosophize out of wonder.

We must understand these two beginning statements, their difference and their order or connection. Part of the latter involves seeing the truth of the statement that If wonder is the beginning of philosophy, then wisdom must be its end.

Wonder is the desire to know for its own sake the what and the why of things or the desire to know for its own sake especially the cause. But we must next consider that this desire is not enough to become a philosopher. This desire by itself is not an efficacious or sufficient beginning of philosophy without the reasonable hope of finding the truth and coming to know it. Without this hope, the desire will end in despair and the abandoning of philosophy. Nor is this hope of coming to know the truth about the what and why of things with the desire to know these enough. One must also have a reasonable fear of mistake. Otherwise, hope will be presumption and lead one into many mistakes.

Thus, to the consideration of the desire of the philosopher, one should add a consideration of his hope and fear. Sometimes the desire is called wonder and sometimes the fear is called wonder and sometimes all three are considered parts of the wonder sufficient for a philosopher.

Since man becomes wise and prudent by quieting down, a certain tranquillity of the emotions is also necessary for becoming a philosopher.

To be a philosopher, one must love wisdom for its own sake and one must love it more than anything else that one loves for its own sake. But such love needs to be accompanied by humility. Since God alone or most of all is wise, the philosopher should reverence God and the godlike and place himself under them. There is no wisdom without humility.

Thus, humility should be considered with and after the love of wisdom

If a man were sufficient by himself to pursue wisdom, the above dispositions of desire would perhaps be enough for the philosopher. But since one must learn from others and with others and be open to correction by others, there are also dispositions of will and emotion in addition to humility required in the philosopher. I say in addition to humility since it is very necessary in learning from those wiser than us and being open to correction by others. Foremost among these other dispositions necessary for being taught by others or for investigating with others or for being corrected by others are friendship and mildness. These may be considered in regard to the first three conversations distinguished in the book On Sophistical Refutations. In the conversation between the teacher and the student, there is more a friendship between unequals but in the second conversation there is more a friendship among equals. Without friendship, the third kind of conversation (the examination discussion) is apt to degenerate into the fourth, bad conversation the sophistical one. Mildness is also chiefly necessary when being examined, Anger can also turn this conversation into a sophistical one.

Thus in learning from others and with others and being open to correction by others, the philosopher's will and emotions must be disposed well by humility, friendship and mildness.

Appendix

Scriptum Super Lib. IV Sententiarum, Distinctio XVII, Quaestio II, Art. III, Ad primam quaestionem:

omnis operatio augetur per propriam delectationem, ut dicitur in X Eth. (1175a 30): sicut qui delectatur in addiscendo aliquam scientiam, melius addiscit.