The Philosopher and the Believer

← Library · Wisdom about Beginnings

The Philosopher and the Believer

Wisdom about Beginnings · Beginning of Philosophy in the Will

From his file: THE PHILOSOPHER & THE BELIEVER.doc.

Word doc

THE PHILOSOPHER AND THE BELIEVER

The question about the philosopher and the believer is usually asked about the one who believes God. Can one be both a philosopher and a believer or are they incompatible? But the question can also be asked in regard to human belief. We shall consider the usual question and then the second one.

Many thinkers from Bertrand Russell to Leo Strauss think that one cannot believe God and be a philosopher. The reason seems to be that the philosopher wonders and the believer assents. For example. the philosopher, like Socrates in the Phaedo, wonders whether the human soul is immortal while the believer already assents to the statement that the human soul is immortal. Or the philosopher wonders whether there is a first cause and, if there is, whether that first cause is matter or God or something else. But the believer has already assented to the statement that God is the beginning of all other things. Or the philosopher wonders whether human life or man has a purpose and, if so , what is that purpose, But the believer already assents to the purpose of life as revealed to him by God. If, then, the philosopher wonders about these things (and others like them) and the believer does not; and wonder is the beginning of philosophy; then one cannot be both a philosopher and a believer.

Sometimes it is also said that the believer cannot investigate a philosophical question with an open mind and weigh correctly the reasons for or against a statement since he has already assented to one side of the question. But a philosopher, like a member of a jury, should hear with an open mind the pros and cons of a position before making up his mind. Hence, the believer cannot be a philosopher.

We can begin to investigate the question by asking what is a philosopher. The objections seem to assume that the philosopher is by definition a man who wonders and a man with an open mind.

The man who wonders thinks himself to be ignorant. Likewise, the man with an open mind, who neither affirms nor denies, is ignorant. If the philosopher is by definition one who wonders, or one who has an open mind, then the philosopher is by definition one who does not know.

Since believing is not knowing, it would seem that no one knows anything unless there is someone else beside the philosopher and the believer who knows. But the philosopher, being a lover of wisdom, would seem to be the man most apt to know, or come to know, if anyone can do so. Hence, if even the philosopher, who most of all loves knowledge, cannot know, then no one else can know. Then if we define the philosopher as a man who does not know (and this is necessary if we define him by wonder or an open mind), it would seem that no one knows anything. But such a position is self-destroying.

The philosopher is defined as a lover of wisdom. This, at last, is indicated by his name. But we must understand also how one must love wisdom in order to be called a lover of wisdom.

First, one must love wisdom for its own sake and not for the sake of something else. If a man loves a woman for her money, he should be called a lover of money rather than a lover of that woman. Likewise, if a man loves wisdom for the sake of honor or money, he should be called a lover of honor or money, not of wisdom.

Second, to be called a philosopher, one should love wisdom more than anything else that one loves for its own sake. If one loves music and wisdom for their own sake, but music more than wisdom, one should be called more a lover of music than a lover of wisdom.

Third, since the thing one loves for its own sake and more than anything else would seem to be the end of one's life, before one can be called a philosopher in the full sense of the word, one must love wisdom as the end of one's life.

If knowledge was not possible for man, wisdom could not be his end. And one could not think of something as one's end if it were impossible. One might wish it, but it could not be the end towards which one directs all one's doings. No one acts for the sake of something they consider impossible.

Hence, the philosopher or lover of wisdom cannot be defined by wonder or an open mind because then, as such, he could not know; and, as we saw above, if knowledge were impossible, he could not be a lover of wisdom as his end. One can love wisdom before and after one knows, but wonder is before one knows. Wonder is the beginning of philosophy, not its end.

But if the believer does not wonder, how can he begin to be a philosopher?

If there are some things the non-believer might wonder about that the believer would not, there are many much more wonderful things that the believer wonders about which the non-believer would not. The believer, for example, wonders why God became man; but the non-believer does not wonder about such things.

But someone might reply that wonder why God became man is not the wonder which is the beginning of philosophy (It is rather, perhaps, a beginning of theology).

But most of the things that come under the philosopher's wonder are not things about which the Church has pronounced.

But if one returns to Plato and Aristotle who said that wonder is the beginning of philosophy, it is clear that this wonder is chiefly a wonder what and why, a wonder about the cause. The believer is more apt to wonder what is the soul and what is God than the non-believer because he is more sure that he has a soul or that there is a God.

If the philosopher should have an open mind about everything, he should never reach a conclusion (which is a closing of the mind - "the case is closed") or recognize anything as known through itself. The philosopher should have an open mind before he is sure which side of a contradiction is true.

Further, it is not an open mind which enables one to weigh arguments. As Socrates pointed out in the Phaedo, we need an art about arguments to help us judge whether an argument is good or bad, and if good, whether necessary or probable. This art, called logic, can be possessed by a believer as well as a non-believer. Boethius and Albert the great and Thomas Aquinas were great logicians.

The only difference in regard to arguments here is that the believer will not be deceived by an argument that concludes the opposite of what he believes. He will know there is a defect in the argument and will look for that defect while the non-believer will be deceived before he sees a defect in the argument.

If the believer knows logic, he knows that a bad argument can have a true conclusion. Hence, he need not accept an argument as good because it concludes to something he believes.