← Library · Wisdom about Beginnings
The Private Road of Reasoned Out Knowledge
Wisdom about Beginnings · Roads in Our Knowledge
From his file: PRIVATE ROADS.doc.
THE PRIVATE ROAD OF REASONED OUT KNOWLEDGE
The private road of reasoned out knowledge should first be divided as a composed whole and then as a universal whole.
As a composed whole, it can be divided into the order of determination and the order of demonstration (if we understand by the latter, both how the private beginnings are made known and how one goes forward from, and returns to, the private beginnings)
Under how the private beginnings are made known, we can consider both the way of defining and how we know that it is so.
Under how one goes forward from, and returns to, the private beginnings, we can consider whether one demonstrates from cause to effect or from effect to cause, from what causes and how from each of them, and the limit of judging.
THE PRIVATE ROADS OF REASONED OUT KNOWLEDGE
The private road of a reasoned out knowledge should fit its matter, just as a shoe should fit one's foot. The matter is the measure. Hence, the way of going forward is called the modus congruus.
Modus autem est, ut dicit Augustinus, super Gen. ad litteram [L. IV, C. 3, n. 7, ML 34, 299] quem mensura praefigit. Unde importat quandam determinationem secundum aliquam mensuram.
[Deut, XXV, 2] Pro mensura peccati erit et plagarum modus.
The punishment should fit the crime. We measure how much someone should be punished by their crime.
The modus procedendi or way of going forward should be measured by the matter (II Meta., 3) and the end (VI Meta) and by how reason is to that matter (II Meta. 1)
PRIVATE ROADS
1.Diversity according to end
Matter
2. Diversity in order of determination. Text on ordo determinandi, Metaphysics, Book 7, Lectio 2
3. How private beginnings are made known
4. Way of demonstrating (esp in looking reasoned out knowledge)
Propter quid and quia Which causes ut in pluribus fewer principles terms of judgment diversity in way of defining
5. manuductio (?)
6. Certitude to be expected : this follows from all of the above.
PRIVATE ROADS
The ordo determinandi in mathematical philosophy is the simple before the composed and the equal before the unequal.
The geometer and the student of numbers also define the general before the particular insofar as they also follow to some extent the natural road. But they follow the natural road the least
The definition of even number is before the definition of odd number.
In Boetii de Trinitate, Lectio II, Q. 1, Art. 2, Ad 2:
...intellectus communiter abstrahit a materia signata et conditionibus eius, non autem a materia communi in scientia naturali, quamvis etiam in scientia naturali non consideratur materia nisi in ordine ad formam; unde etiam forma per prius est de consideratione naturalis quam materia.
In the first book of Natural Hearing, we consider that there are contraries in change before that there is a matter underlying the two contraries. And we begin the study of life with the three books About the Soul.