← Library · Wisdom about Beginnings
Three Chief Things in Private Road of Each Reasoned Out Knowledge
Wisdom about Beginnings · Roads in Our Knowledge
From his file: THREE CHIEF THINGS-PRIVAT. ROAD.doc.
THREE CHIEF THINGS IN PRIVATE ROAD OF EACH REASONED OUT KNOWLEDGE
There are three chief things to be determined in the private road or private way of going forward of each reasoned out knowledge.
The first of these is the order of consideration. This is the order in which different things are considered in that reasoned out knowledge. In geometry, for example, the simple is considered before the composed and the equal before the unequal. But in natural philosophy, the general is considered before the particular and we go forward towards matter.
The second chief thing to be determined is the way of defining in that reasoned out knowledge. In natural philosophy, for example, we define with matter and motion. But in geometry, the definitions contain neither motion nor matter (not matter in the original sense, that is sensible matter, although we can speak of the extension of the geometer as an understandable or imaginable matter),
The third chief thing to be considered is the way of demonstrating. In geometry, for example, we demonstrate from the cause to the effect and only by the formal cause and our demonstrations have great rigor. But in natural philosophy, we more often demonstrate from effect to cause and we use all four kinds of cause and our demonstrations lack the certitude and precision of those in geometry.
To the determination of the way of defining can be added the general consideration of how the beginnings of that reasoned out knowledge are made known. For definition is one of the beginnings of reasoned out knowledge (and the one used sometimes to distinguish one reasoned out knowledge from another).
And to the consideration of the way things are defined and, in general, the way that the beginnings are made known, we may also attach a consideration of the limit to which the judgments of a reasoned out knowledge resolve. Although the consideration of judging might seem more appropriate to a determination of the way of demonstrating (since we judge by demonstration), nevertheless the term or limit of judgment is some beginning. For judgment is nothing other than the separation of the true from the false by some beginning in our knowledge. Hence, there is a connection between the way the beginnings of a reasoned out knowledge are made known and the way we judge in that reasoned out knowledge. In natural philosophy, for example, the beginnings are made known by sense experience and we judge by returning to the senses.
* * *
If we divide into two the private road or way, we should distinguish the way of considering and the order of consideration. The way of considering could then be divided into the way of defining and the way of demonstrating.
In explaning a book, this corresponds to the forma tractatus and the forma tractandi.