Three Is Enough and All

← Library · Natural Philosophy

Three Is Enough and All

Natural Philosophy · Physics Book 1

From his file: THREE IS ENOUGH.doc.

Word doc

Read from in 1 class

THREE IS ENOUGH AND ALL

Often two is not enough, but three is enough. And many times, three is all there is.

The numbers two and three are the most important for the philosopher and the theologian. The philosopher and the theologian use reason and reason looks for order. And order presupposes distinction. And two is the number of formal distinction because formal distinction is by opposites and opposites are two.

However, often two is not enough, but three is enough. And many times, three is all there is. Both of these statements, three is enough and the stronger statement three is all, are not always true on the side of things. But three is the number of what has a beginning, middle and end and what has a beginning, middle and end is complete. And a sign is that three is the first number about which we say all. And not only do these statements have much truth on the side of things, but also on our side. For three reasons or three examples or three images is about all our reason and imagination can take together. One tends to lose what one has when the speaker goes beyond three.

Henry Shelley, Inns and Taverns of Old London, 1909, L.C. Page & Company, pp. 41-42:

No one can glance even casually over a list of tavern signs without observing how frequently the numeral "three" is used. Various explanations have been offered for the propensity of mankind to use that number, one deriving the habit from the fact that primitive man divided the universe into three regions, heaven, earth, and water. Pythagoras, it will be remembered, called three the perfect number; Jove is depicted with three-forked lightning; Neptune bears a trident; Pluto has his three-headed dog. Again, there are three Fates, three Furies, three Graces and three Muses.

It is natural, then, to find the numeral so often employed in the signs of inns and taverns. Thus we have the Three angels, the Three Crowns, The Three Compasses, the Three Cups, the Three Horseshoes, the Three Tuns, the Three Nuns, and many more.

In the City of London proper, the Three Cups was a favourite sign and the Three Tuns was hardly less popular. There were also several Three Nuns, the most famous of which was situated in Aldergate High Street, where its modern representative still stands. In the bygone years it was a noted coaching inn and enjoyed an enviable reputation for the rare quality of its punch.

Thomas Hardy, The Mayor of Casterbridge, Chapter V, Greenwood Ed., St. Martin's Press, N.Y., 1966, p. 38:

The younger guests were talking and eating with animation; their elders were searching for tidbits, and sniffing and grunting over their plates likes sows nuzzling for acorns. Three drinks seemed to be sacred to the company - port, sherry and rum; outside which old-established trinity few or no palates ranged.

Anthony Hicks, Notes for the Philips CD of Händel's Trio Sonatas, Opus 5:

The combination of two treble instruments or voices accompanied by a continuo bass was much favoured by composers of the Baroque period as the simplest and most economical ensemble which could display most aspects of musical craft. The three lines could move independently in ingenious counterpoint, or come together to define full harmonies. Alternately, either of the upper parts could be treated as a solo line, giving opportunity for imitative exchanges or competitive virtuosity between the players. In the field of instrumental music the idea of particular forms for complete works in trio texture - that is, trio sonatas - was established by the great Italian violinist and composer Arcangelo Corelli, who published four sets of 12 trio sonatas between 1683 and 1694. Corelli divided his sonatas into two types, the sonata da chiesa (or "church" sonata) and thesonata da camera (or "chamber" sonata) The sonata da chiesa generally consisted of four abstract movements in alternating slow and fast tempos, while the sonata da camera was a series of movements in named dance rhythms. In practice the distinction between the two was not absolutely rigid: many of Corelli's da camera sonatas start with an abstract Preludio in slow tempo, and some of the da chiesa sonatas include a movement in the style of a gigue.

From George Frideric Handel, by Paul Henry Lang, W.W. Norton & Company Inc., 1966, p. 647:

From Opus 5 onward, Handel combines the sonata with the suite, the gathered gravity and resonance of the one freshened with the lighter dances of the other. The exquisitely turned trios of Opus 5 stand, with Bach's trio sonatas, at the head of the Baroque chamber-music literature.

Mozart's Piano Concertos, by C. M. Girdlestone, Cassell & Company Ltd., 1958, pp. 21 & 24:

The period which precedes that of Mozart shows a great diversity in the concerto form. The three-movement plan is not yet predominant, neither is the tradition of the rondo finale, and the structure of each movement varies from composer to composer....With all their variety of form and content, Mozart's piano concertos keep throughout certain features which never change. They all have three movements: the first always begins with an orchestral prelude; the second is nearly always an andante; the third generally a rondo.

Mozart's Piano Concertos, by C.M. Girdlestone, Cassell & Company Ltd., 1958, pp.24 &27-28:

In the classical concerto, as in the symphony, the first allegro is the chief movement, the one which sets its mark upon the work, and on it one is tempted to found one's judgment of the concerto as a whole. It begins with a fairly long tutti, at the end of which the solo enters. This prelude, which serves as a first exposition and contains the movement's main subjects, finishes in the tonic. The solo's entry starts a new exposition, usually longer, which ends, as in a symphony, in the key of the dominant or the relative major. Apart from this double exposition, a concerto first movement follows sonata form; the development comes next, then the recapitulation...

The second exposition is in its structure much more like the exposition of a symphony than the first, but the effect it produces on the listener is quite different from that of a true exposition. It gives one more the impression of a development. Some of the chief ideas are already known; they have been heard in the tutti, and the second exposition seldom reproduces them without change. The true development itself is so short compared with the rest of the movement, especially in Mozart, that one hardly thinks of isolating it from what precedes. The result is that, for him who listens without worrying about forms or formulae, the real development begins with the solo entry, and instead of dividing a concerto first movment into four parts as do the textbooks, it would be more sensible to keep a threefold division as for the sonata and the symphony: tutti exposition, development (including the solo exposition and the development in the textbook sense), and recapitulation.

Mozart's Piano Concertos, by C.M. Girdlestone, Cassell & Company Ltd., 1958, p.44:

But for his andantes he has at his disposal several models, especially the variation which fits all movements, the rondo, another universal form, and the sonata whose ample and majestic outlines suit perfectly the meditative phrases of an andante or an adagio. This later is sometimes in two sections, the development being absent, sometimes in three....The piano concertos prefer the three section sonata; out of twenty-three, eight make use of it, all of them belonging to the later half. The two section sonata form is nearly as popular; five concertos at different periods use it. Two andantes in variation form belong to 1784 and two others of irregular plan, in 1784 and 1785, are modifications of the rondo, the other of the sonata. The three section sonata appears in the first concerto and vanishes in 1786 after the A major, K. 488; it covers therefore almost all Mozart's career as a concerto writer and it may be considered as the typical andante of his concertos.

Werner Heisenberg, Physics and Philosophy, Harper & Brothers, 1958, pp. 164-165:

The theory of relativity is connected with a universal constant in nature, the velocity of light...Quantum theory is connected with another universal constant of nature, Planck's quantum of action...There must exist a third universal constant in nature. This is obvious for purely dimensional reasons. The universal constants determine the scale of nature, the characteristic quantities that cannot be reduced to other quantities. One needs at least three fundamental units for a complete set of units. This is most easily seen from such conventions as the use of the c-g-s system (centimeter, gram, second system) by the physicists. A unit of length, one of time, and one of mass is sufficient to form a complete set; but one must have at least three units. One could replace them by units of length, velocity and mass; or by units of length, velocity and energy, etc. But at least three fundamental units are necessary. Now the velocity of light and Planck's constant of action provide only two of these units. There must be a third one, and only a theory which contains this third unit can possibly determine the masses and other properties of the elementary particles. Judging from our present knowledge of these particles the most appropriate way of introducing the third universal constant would be by the assumption of a universal length the value of which should be roughly 10-13 cm, that is, somewhat smaller than the radii of the light atomic nuclei.

Werner Heisenberg, Across the Frontiers, "Planck's Discovery and the Philosophical Problems of Atomic Theory", Harper & Row, Publishers, New York, 1974, pp. 13-14, 20:

Following recognition of the basic significance of the two universal constants of nature, Planck's quantum of action and the velocity of light, it was natural to ask how many such independent constants of nature there can actually be. The answer is that there must be at least three such universal constants, but that probably all other constants of nature can be traced back to these three by way of mathematical relations that are still in part unknown.

That three such independent natural units of measure must exist is something most simply made clear to the physicist or technician by considering how the customary physical or technical systems of measurement all contain three such units of measure: the centimeter for length, the second for time and the gram for mass.

If we wish to replace these three conventionally established units by natural ones, Planck's quantum of action and the velocity of light must be supplemented by yet another constant. The atomic structure of matter makes it natural to choose as our third unit a length of an atomic order of magnitude, for instance a length of the order of the diameter of simple atomic nuclei. But a precise formulation of this unit of length can be given only if we are able to express mathematically the natural laws in which it figures as an essential quantity...

quantum theory and relativity theory obviousy cannot be combined without difficulties. After what has emerged in recent years, we have every reason to suppose that success in combining the two theories can be achieved only if we also take into the field of consideration the third basic structure, which is bound up with the existence of a universal length of the order of 10-13 cm.

Ecclesiastes, Chapter 4, v. 12:

A threefold cord is not easily broken.

Scriptum Super Lib. I Sententiarum, Distinctio III, Questio I, Art. IV, Obj. 1 & Ad 1:

1. Videtur quod philosophi naturali cognitione ex creaturis in Trinitatem devenerunt. Dicit enim Aristoteles, in principio De Caelo et Mundo , text. 5 [Book I, Chapter 1] "Et per hunc quidem numerum," scilicet ternarium, "adhibuimus nosipsos magnificare Deum unum eminentem proprietatibus eorum quae creata sunt."...

Ad primum ergo dicendum, quod, secundum expositionem Commentatoris, Aristoteles non intendit Trinitatem personarum in Deo ponere; sed propter hoc quod in omnibus creaturis apparet perfectio in ternario, sicut in principio, medio et fine, ideo antiqui honorabant Deum in sacrificiis et orationibus triplicatis...

Scriptum Super Lib. I Sententiarum, Distinctio III, Q. II, Art. II, Utrum partes vestigii sint tres tantum vel duae, Solutio and 3 & Ad 3 :

...vestigium invenitur in creatura, inquantum imitatur divinam perfectionem. Perfectio autem creaturae non statim habetur in suis principiis, quae imperfecta sunt, ut patet in materia et forma, quorum neutrum habet per [se] esse perfectum; sed in conjunctione ipsius creaturae ad suum finem. Distantia autem natura non conjungit sine medio: et ideo in creaturis invenitur principium, medium et finis, secundum quae tria ponebat Pythagoras perfectionem cujuslibet creaturae. Et secundum rationem etiam horum trium repraesentatur in creaturis distinctio divinarum personarum, in quibus Filius est media persona, sed Spiritus sanctus est in quo terminatur processio personarum.

3. Item, vestigium dicitur in creatura secundum quod repraesentat Creatorem. Cum igitur in creaturis repraesentetur plurima attributa ipsius Dei, quae participantur a creaturis, sicut patet per Dionysium, De div. nom., cap. IX, col 910, t. 1, videtur quod sint plurimae partes.

Ad tertium dicendum, quod proprietates creaturarum, ex quibus ducimur in divina attributa, quamvis sint plura, habent tamen ordinem ad invicem principii, medii et finis, sub quorum rationibus in tres personas ducunt, qualitercumque diversificentur.

Scriptum Super Lib. IV Sententiarum, Distinctio XXI, Quaestio. I, Art. II, Ad primam quaestionem:

Et quia perfectio cujuslibet quantitatis ternario comprehenditur, propter principium, medium et finem; ideo triplex differentia ponitur.

Quia quaedam sunt gravissima in genere venialium et difficillime purgabilia, et haec per lignum significantur; quaedam minima, quae per stipulam, quaedam media, quae per fenum significantur.

What has a beginning, middle and end is most beautiful for it has all three of the greatest forms of the beautiful. For order is a before and after, and before and after define beginning, middle and end. And the beginning and end are limits. And the beginning is to the middle, as the middle is to the end.

Metaphysics, Book thirteen, 1078a 36 - 1078b 1-4

τοῦ δὲ καλοῦ μέγιστα εἴδη τάξις καὶ συμμετρία καὶ τὸ ὡρισμένον, 2 μάλιστα δεικνύουσιν αἱ μαθηματικαὶ ἐπιστῆμαι.

The greatest forms of the beautiful are order and symmetry and the limited which the mathematical sciences especially show.

Plato, Philebus, 64E:

μετριότης γὰρ καὶ συμμετρία κάλλος δήπου καὶ ἀρετὴ πανταχοῦ ξυμβαίνει γίγνεσθαι.

For moderation and symmetry everywhere are found to be beauty and virtue.