← Library · Wisdom about Beginnings
Tragedy and Geometry
Wisdom about Beginnings · Beginnings Misc
From his file: TRAGEDY AND GEOMETRY.doc.
TRAGEDY AND GEOMETRY
It is remarkable that the Greeks should have produced or invented both tragedy and geometry. It is remarkable, not only because the honor of having invented just one would have been great, but also because of the distance between them. Geometry and its sister science, the science of numbers, excel all other sciences in certitude while tragedy is the most striking representation of "life's uncertain voyage". It is not schizophrenic to be interested both in what is very certain, the theorems of geometry and arithmetic, and what is very uncertain, "life's uncertain voyage", because our interest in the latter is not because of its incertitude, but because of our natural desire to be happy and avoid misery. Solon said, "Call no man happy till he be dead" because of the incertitude of life and Sophocles echoes this at the end of Oedipus Rex. But geometry arises from our natural desire to know.
What tragedy and geometry have in common
1. They both have a special connection with the imagination which is closer to reason than the senses.
2.The beautiful is found in both to a pre-eminent degree
3. They both have a fundamental role in arousing wonder in man
4. In both. we find necessity or simplicity without purpose or apparent purpose (?)
Tragedy has an affinity with some of the fragments of Heraclitus and both are at the threshold leading into Hegel and Nietzche (and perhaps Marx, Kant??)
Pythagoras is perhaps the most famous name in the beginning of geometry and the science of numbers; and the Pythagorean influence is very much found in the mathematical sciences of nature.
At first sight, the physical sciences and existentialism would seem to be very far apart and those inclined to the one would seem to have an antipathy to the other.
Tragedy and geometry have in common a close connection with the imagination. Among the imitative arts, the tragic art and, in general, the poetic arts have a close connection with the imagination in their appeal. Among the sciences, geometry and, in general, the mathematical sciences are closest to the imagination. Given the role of imagination in our thinking (we always think in images or not without images), both tragedy and geometry can be basic for the orientation of our mind.
Tragedy teaches us more how to wonder and geometry how to think. Geometry gives us an experience of a matter that is very certain and tragedy impresses upon us the incertitude of human life and action. Geometry gives us more hope and tragedy more fear and humility Following either too much or without the other leaves the mind unbalanced.
But even both of them together could tie us too much to the imagination rather than to the sense of touch and the common sense.
Both tragedy and geometry are necessary before beginning philosophy. The soul of man must be balanced by both. One without the other leaves the soul unbalanced: witness Descartes and Spinoza on the one hand and Nietzsche on the other. Compare Aristotle's interest in both as witnessed in his Posterior Analytics and About the Poetic Art. What should one say about those who want to banish the tragic poets from the city?
The senses that most of all make us know are the senses of sight, touch and for learning from others, the sense of hearing. The mathematical sciences most of all emphasize the sense of sight and the imagination which sight is most like among the senses. But tragedy arouses pity which is tied to the sense of touch. Moreover, tragedy appeals to the ear with its rhythm etc and bring out the importance of counsel - life ends tragically for those who do not listen to the advice of other (for example, Lear to Kent, Romeo to Friar Lawrence, Oedipus to Jocasta, Creon to and so on)
Opposites along side of each other stand out more. But tragedy leads us to think of human happiness and misery by presenting the fall from one to the other in a short space. Unlike a Sherlock Holmes story, it thus leads us into the universal matter and concern of the practical philosopher. The pity and fear it arouses also prepare us to approach practical philosophy.
Aristotle's examples in the Rhetoric are often borrowed from the poets. We use Antony's speech and Iago's persuasion of Othello to illustrate the three means of persuasion. Dialectic is like rhetoric in many ways but in other ways like demonstrations exemplified in geometry.
“There are more things in heaven and earth than are dreamt of in your philosophy”. Thomas talks about the importance of belief in some things above reason as being useful to repress the presumption of some.