← Library · Natural Philosophy
Werner Heisenberg: Physics and Philosophy
Natural Philosophy · Physics Book 1
From his file: HEISENBERG-PHYSICS AND PHIL.doc.
Read from in 2 classes
WERNER HEISENBERG: PHYSICS AND PHILOSOPHY
CHAPTER I - AN OLD AND A NEW TRADITION
27A-28B The necessity of considering the ideas of modern physics 28B-29A Why perhaps the best way to enter into a consideration of the problems of modern physics is a historical description of the development of quantum theory 28C "it is in quantum theory that the most fundamental changes with respect to the concept of reality have taken place." 29A "the change in the concept of reality...in quantum theory...seems to be a real break in the structure of modern science."
CHAPTER II - THE HISTORY OF QUANTUM THEORY
30A-38A THE DISCOVERY OF THE QUANTUM OF ENERGY AND OF THE WAVE- PARTICLE DUALITY, THE RECOGNITION OF THEIR CONNECTION AND UNIVERALITY
30A-32A The work of Max Planck, the "father of modern physics" Planck's law of heat radiation seemed to indicate that the oscillator or radiating atom "could only contain discrete quanta of energy" It was so different from anything in classical physics (17th-19th) physics that it was hard to accept, but when Planck was convinced of it, he knew that he had made a discovery as fundamental as that of Newton (Dec. 1900)
32B-33A The work of Albert Einstein 32B-C Two applications of the quantum of energy made by Einstein (1905) 32B Photo-electric effect 32C Specific heat of solid bodies 33A The apparent contradiction between wave and particle pictures of light
33B-37A Rutherford, Bohr and the line of research opened by Bohr 33B-34A Rutherford's atom and the things not explained by it 34B-35A Bohr's use of the quantum hypothesis to explain the stability of the atom and its chemical properties and also partially, in simple cases, the spectrum of light radiated. 35B-37A The line of research opened up by Bohr: asking the right questions and contradiction
37B-38A Louis de Broglie comes to the idea that matter also has a wave aspect, the dual aspects again being connected by Planck's quantum of action.
38B-43D FORMULATION OF THE QUANTUM THEORY
38B What a theory would have to try to connect and explain: "some new feature of the behavior of matter was qualitatively expressed by the quantum conditions, which in turn were connected with the dualism between waves and particles"
38C-43D Formulation of the quantum theory 38C-40A Development of the mathematical formalism which did not explain the paradoxes of the wave-particle picture 40B-43D Development of a real understanding of quantum theory 40B-41A The first step towards a real understanding of quantum theory was the probability wave of Bohr, Kramers & Slater - "a quantitative version of the old concept of 'potentia' in Aristotelian philosophy." 41B-42A Tentative efforts 42B-43D The final solution 42B Difficulty of understanding & accepting the solution, nature seemed absurd. 42C-43B Two ways of approaching the final solution 42C-43B Heisenberg's way: limitation in the use of the concepts of classical physics, but mutual limitation determined rigorously (product of inaccuracies not less thant Planck's constant divided by mass of particles) 43B Bohr's concept of complementarity 43C-D Testing and acceptance of the Copenhagen interpretation in the autumn of 1927 at the Solvay Conference in Brussels.
CHAPTER 11: THE ROLE OF MODERN PHYSICS IN THE PRESENT DEVELOPMENT OF HUMAN THINKING (READ WITH READING1IN 1ST BK. OF NATURAL HEARING)
1. It is probably true quite generally that in the history of human thinking, the most fruitful developments take place at those points where two different lines of thought meet (p. 187)
2. The development of natural science in modern times was brought about by the combination of natural and technical science (p. 194)
3. This led to a picture of the material world to be described by means of those concepts which we nowadays call the concepts of classical or Newtonian physics. The world consisted of things in space and time, the things consisted of matter, and matter can produce and be acted upon by forces (p. 196) One was not so much interested in nature as it is; one rather asked what one could do with it (p. 197)
4. This frame was so narrow and rigid that it was difficult to find a place in it for many concepts of our language that had always belonged to its very substance, for instance, the concepts of mind, of the human soul or of life (p. 197) It was especially difficult to find in this framework room for those parts of reality that had been the object of the traditional religion. (p. 198)
5. The most important contribution of modern physics is the dissolution of the rigid frame of concepts of the nineteenth century which was too narrow for an understanding of the essential parts of reality. The help of physics itself was necessary for this because of the enormous success and prestige of these concepts. Only in this way could the force of custom begin to be overcome. (p. 198)
6. This dissolution took part in two distinct stages. The first was the discovery, through the theory of relativity, that even such fundamental concepts as space and time in Newtonian physics were subject to change although this did not affect the somewhat vague concepts of space and time in natural language. The second stage was the modification of the idea of matter which was the strongest part in the rigid frame of concepts of the nineteenth century. Again, the concepts so far as they belonged to the natural language remained untouched. (pp. 198-199)
7. These new results had first of all to be considered as a serious warning against the somewhat forced application of scientific concepts in domains where they did not belong. (p. 199)
8. Furthermore, one of the most important features of the development and the analysis of modern physics is the experience that the concepts of natural language, vaguely defined as they are, seem to be more stable in the expansion of knowledge than the precise terms of scientific language, derived as an idealization from only limited groups of phenomena This is in fact not surprising since the concepts of natural language are formed by the immediate connection with reality; they represent reality. (p. 200)
9. Keeping in mind the intrinsic stability of the concepts of natural language in the process of development, one sees that - after the experience of modern physics - our attitude toward concepts like mind or the human soul or life or God will be different from that of the nineteenth century, because these concepts belong to the natural language. (p. 200)
10. We know that any understanding must be based finally on the natural language because it is only there that we can be certain to touch reality; and hence we must be skeptical about any skepticism with regard to this natural language and its essential concepts. Therefore, we may use these concepts as they have been used at all times. In this way modern physics has perhaps opened the door to a wider outlook on the relation between the human mind and reality. (pp.201-202)
CHAPTER 9 - QUANTUM THEORY AND THE STRUCTURE OF MATTER (READ WITH READINGS 13-15 IN 1ST BK. OF NATURAL HEARING)
1. There are two main positions on the first or most basic matter in Greek philosophy: it is an actual substance, or it is a substance in potency. (pp. 147-148)
2. Mathematical experimental science up to the twentieth century conceived matter as that which has extension, or as that which produces forces or can be acted upon by forces. (pp. 148-149)
3. Natural science can investigate the problem of matter only by a study of the forms of matter. (p. 149)
4. Experiment has made it possible to pass from general experience to specific experience. (p. 149)
5. A first and most important step toward an understanding of matter was the introduction of the concept of the chemical element - a substance that could not be further dissolved or disintegrated by any of the means at the disposal of the chemist. (p.149-150)
6. The next step was the discovery of the conservation of mass in the chemical process - this discovery gave a quantitative meaning to the concept of matter. (p. 150)
7. The large number of elements was opposed to the principle of simplicity. (p. 150)
8. Hints at the connection of the elements in the fact that the atomic weights of different elements frequently seem to be integer multiples of a smallest unit near to the atomic weight of hydrogen and the similarity of chemical behavior of some elements. (p. 151)
9. The transmutation of elements in the radioactive process emitted a-particles which could be used as new tools for investigating the inner structure of the atom. This led to Rutherford's model of the atom involving the separation of theatom into two distinct parts, the atomic nucleus and the surrounding electronic shells. (p. 151)
10. The stability of the atom could not be explained by Newtonian mechanics but required quantum theory. (p. 152)
11. The forces between neighboring atoms are primarily electric forces, the attraction of opposite and the repulsion of equal charges. (p. 153)
12,. There are two opposites lines of research from the atom: (1) from the atom to the more complicated structures consisting of many atoms, from atomic physics to chemistry and biology, and (2) from the outer parts of the atom to the inner parts and from the nucleus to the elementary particles. The latter line will possibly lead to the unity of matter. (p. 155)
13. When the task is set to test the final unity of matter, we may expose matter to the strongest possible forces, to the most extreme conditions, in order to se whether any matter can ultimately be transmuted into any other matter. (pp. 155-156)
14. Bombardment of atomic nucleus by a-particles and artificially accelerated protons leads to reduction of many different chemical elements to three fundamental elementary particles: the proton, the neutron and the electron. But are these the final indestructible units of matter? (pp. 156-158)
15. Bombardment by particles of very high energy due to cosmic radiation or cyclotrons has led to the recognition of new elementary particles in addition to electron, proton, and neutron. At first sight, this might seem to lead away from the unity of matter. (pp. 158-159)
16. Actually, these last experiments have show the complete mutability of matter. All the elementary particles can, at sufficiently high energies, be transmuted into other particles, or they can simply be crated from kinetic energy and can be annihilated into energy, for instance in radiation. Therefore, we have here the final proof for the unity of matter. (p. 160)
17. All the elementary particles are made of the same substance which we may call energy or universal matter; they are just different forms in which matter can appear. The matter of Aristotle which is mere potency should be compared to our concept of energy which gets into actuality by means of the form when the elementary particle is created. (p. 160)
18. Modern physics is not satisfied with a qualitative description of the fundamental structure of matter; it tries to get a mathematical formulation of those natural laws that determine the forms of matter, the elementary particles and their forces. (p. 160)
19. One may hope that the combined effort of experiments in the high energy region and of mathematical analysis will some day lead to a complete understanding of the unity of matter. The term "complete understanding" would mean that the forms of matter in the sense of Aristotelian philosophy would appear as results, as solutions of a closed mathematical scheme representing the natural laws for matter. (p. 166)
REFERENCES TO ABILITY OR POTENCY
Chapter 1 - An Old and a New Tradition
1. There is a change in the concept of reality (being) in quantum theory (p28)
2. This change is a real break in the structure of modern science (p. 29)
Chapter 2 - The History of Quantum Theory
1. The radiating atom or oscillator could only contain discrete quanta of energy (p. 31)
2. The idea that energy could be emitted or absorbed only in discrete energy quanta was so new that it could not be fitted into the traditional framework of physics. (p. 32)
3. This idea proved useful in many other fields or was confirmed in them (pp. 32-34)
4. But this lead to contradictions which were useful in asking the right questions (pp. 33-35, 37)
5. The first attempt to resolve these contradictions, the probability wave of Bohr, Kramers and Slater introduced a quantitative version of the concept of potency in Aristotelian philosophy (pp.. 40-41)
Chapter 3 - The Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Theory
1. Bohr advocated the use of mutually exclusive pictures (wave and particle) to get at the strange kind of reality behind our atomic experiments. (p. 49)
2. The probability function contains statements about possibilities (potency in Aristotelian philosophy) and these statements are completely objective; they do not depend upon any observer. (p. 53)
3. A transition from the possible to the actual takes place during the act of observation in quantum theory. (p. 54)
4. Quantum physics cannot replace the concepts of classical or Newtonian physics because the latter are a refinement of the concepts of daily life and, hence, are an essential part of the language which forms the basis of all natural science. (p. 56)
Chapter 8 - Criticism and Counterproposals to the Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Theory
1. All opponents of the Copenhagen interpretation would prefer a world whose smallest parts exist in the same sense as stones or trees exist. (p. 129)
2. The rigorous validity of quantum mechanics compels us to depart from the reality concept of classical physics. (p. 141)
3. The ontology of the older materialism (the basic matter is an actual substance) rested upon the illusion that the kind of existence, the direct "actuality" of the world around us can be extrapolated into the atomic range. (p. 145)
Chapter 10 - Language and Reality in Modern Physics
1. The physicist must try to give some explanation in plain or ordinary language (pp. 167-168)
2. The language used by physicists when they speak about atomic events produces in their minds similar notions as the concept of potency. (pp. 180-181)
3. Some Physicists have tried to invent a language in which they could modify the principle of non-contradiction. (pp. 181, 185-186)
4. "Coexistent states" in modern physics should be understood as "coexistent potentialities". (p. 185)