← Library · Wisdom about Beginnings
What Are the Main Exhortations of Philosophy
Wisdom about Beginnings · Beginnings Misc
From his file: WHAT ARE THE CHIEF EXHORTATIONS.doc.
WHAT ARE THE MAIN EXHORTATIONS OF PHILOSOPHY
The name of Aristotle’s lost work, the Protreptikos, suggests the importance of the exhortation in beginning and going forward in philosophy. And since brevity is the soul of wisdom, we should not be surprised to find short exhortations having an enormous influence and power in philosophy.
There are perhaps four main exhortations in the practical life which have similar ones in the philosophical life. But since the necessity and universality of these exhortations are seen first and more easily in the practical order which is more proportioned to us than the theoretical life, we can be led by likeness from their application in the practical life to their analogous application in the philosophical life.
The first and fundamental exhortation of the Greek philosophers is the most famous one at the oracle of Delphi: Know thyself.
Two truths underlie this famous exhortation. The first is that the good of man requires that he know himself. The second is that most men do not know themselves or know themselves enough.
The first statement can be proven thus. The good of man requires that he be true to himself. But a man cannot be true to himself if he does not know himself. Hence the good of man requires that he know himself.
The second statement can be made known by examining the two parts of knowing yourself, the general and the particular part. As regards knowing himself in general, a man does not know himself unless he knows what a man is. But man has both a body and a soul, and it is not easy to know either — a sign of this difficulty is the disagreement men have had about the nature of the body and especially about the nature of the soul.
Coriolanus, Act II, Sc. 1, Menenius:
O that you could turn your eyes toward the napes of your necks, and make but an interior survey of your good selves.
[Yale Note: "the original fable of Aesop … was that Jupiter had furnished every man with wallets, one hanging down on his breast and containing his neighbour's faults, which are always before his eyes, and the other hanging down his back and out of sight, and filled with his own faults.]
This is closely connected with the famous exhortation of Polonius to his son: “This above all: to thine own self be true”. One cannot be true to oneself if one does not know oneself. One thinks of doing here before making but even the maker must know his own capacity and not attempt a work above his powers (like Samuel Johnson and tragedy).
The third of these exhortations was joined to the first at Delphi: Nothing too much. This can be balanced by Nothing too little. This is of universal application in all practice of the moral virtues and of government and in all making.
The fourth exhortation is look before and after which comes from Hamlet’s exhortation to use reason. In the practical order, this is often stated more particularly as “look ahead”, “look before you leap”, “watch out where you’re going”, “keep your wits about you” etc.. Homer attaches disaster in the practical order to the inability out look before and after or as he says “before and behind yourself”.
We can now see what is proportional to these four exhortations in the philosophical life. (Aristotle and Thomas often manifest where possible the proceeding of the speculative reason by that of the practical reason which is more known to us
Know thyself in the life of knowledge has two main applications. One must know what one knows and what one does not know as in the Socratic examination. And one must know where one falls in Hesiod’s division (those who can discover something great by themselves, those who can learn this from another, and those who can do neither) which applies to both the practical and the theoretical.
Reason is true to itself when it pursues knowledge for its own sake and ultimately wisdom itself.
Look before and after again has two applications. The philosopher must look for the before and after in our knowledge of things and for the before and after in things themselves.
Nothing too much and nothing too little apply first to truth itself, the object of the speculative life, for truth is modest. Then to the modesty of nature as in the principle of simplicity. Then to wisdom which is also modest being a knowledge of truth and seeming to be first a knowledge of nature (God is of course simpler than nature). But turning now to logic and the private roads of the sciences, one can define and prove too much or too little, and these in two ways. Some try to define and prove everything while others do not define and prove the things they should. Again some try to define or prove in a more rigorous way than is possible or in a less rigorous way than is possible. Some extend or imitate the road of a science too much into matters where it does not fit. Again (a third way) some put too much or too little into a definition or the premisses of an argument.
THE CONNECTION OF THE ABOVE THREE EXHORTATIONS WITH REASON
It is reason itself that urges these three. Hence, when we listen to these three exhortations, we are listening to reason itself.
A man is true to himself when he (1) listens to reason and (2) follows what he hears or lives in harmony with what he hears.
Reason more than anything else is man.
Only reason knows how much is too much. Reason sets the boundaries, considering oneself and the circumstances