What Logic Is About
Logic as a Whole · Subject of Logic
From his file: LOGIC IS ABOUT ACTS & TOOLS.doc.
WHAT LOGIC IS ABOUT
Logic has the greatest difficulty according to Thomas Aquinas ("habet maximam difficultatem"). This is one way in which it resembles wisdom. And like wisdom, it is difficult to know what it is about. There are indeed many correct answers to the question what is logic about, just as there are many correct answers to the question what wisdom is about. But in both cases it is necessary to see why there are many answers and how these answers are connected.
Perhaps one should begin to answer the question what is logic about thus: logic is about three acts of our looking reason: understanding what a thing is, understanding the true or the false, and reasoning. One could add that logic is about ordering these acts to a knowledge of things.
The second answer to our question is that logic is about the tools we use to order and perfect these acts. The chief tools are definition, statement and syllogism.
Each of these tools is a speech. Speech is vocal sound signifying by human agreement having parts that signify by themselves. (Every speech is composed of two or more names meaning by name a vocal sound signifying by human agreement not having parts that signify by themselves.) Definition is speech signifying what a thing is. A statement is speech signifying the true or the false. And syllogism is speech in which some statements laid down, another follows necessarily because of those laid down.
Definition is a tool for understanding what a thing is. Statement is a tool for understanding the true or the false. And syllogism is a tool for reasoning. These are not the only tools for these three acts, but they are the chief tools.
These two answers differ and are connected in this way. Ordering the above three acts of looking reason to a knowledge of things is what logic is about as its end or goal. But definition, statement and syllogism are more what it is about as its subject.
One could ask at this point how speech can be used to order our thinking about things. The answer is that it is possible only if the names composing those speeches signify things through thoughts. We use words signifying things through thoughts to order our thoughts about things and consequently our thinking about things.
Perhaps there is a third answer to the question what is logic about. Since there is the same knowledge of opposites, as Plato and Aristotle have taught us, and relatives are one kind of opposites, logic must also be about the signified. Logic then is about things in some way. It is about things as signified by words through thoughts. And therefore it is about things as known by reason in some way. And since things are known insofar as they are in the knower, logic is about things insofar as they are in reason.
Logic is about what happens to things insofar as they are known by reason or are in reason. As Boethius said, a thing is singular when sensed, but universal when understood. Hence, Albert the Great said that the universal is what is first considered in logic. It also happens to things to be named insofar as they are known by reason. Hence, things are named as we know them. Hence, one could also say that what should be first considered in logic is name said of many things. (This brings in both name and universal.) Hence, the first books traditionally studied in logic are the Isagoge and the Categories. Further, to be defined, or to be the subject or predicate in a statement, or to be a major or minor or middle term in a syllogism are among what happens further to things insofar as they are known by our reason or are in our reason. Thus we can also say that logic is about things as they known by reason or about what happens to things insofar as they are in reason.
Since the end is the reason for considering those things which are for the sake of the end, logic is more about the tools (the three speeches and the words or names that compose them) than about things as they are in our reason or what happens to them insofar as they are known by reason. Hence, when Aristotle gives a proemium to the Peri Hermeneias in which he shows what he is about to consider in that book, he speaks of a speech (the statement) and the names that compose it (noun and verb), not that he is going to consider things insofar as they are in our statements or things insofar as they can be the subject or predicate of a statement.
Since logic is not studied for its own sake but as the tool of the philosopher, it is also more in accord with logic to say that it is about the tools we use to order our thoughts and thinking about things rather than to say it about things in some way. It is not as clear that the latter is to be known, not for its own sake, but for the sake of ordering our thinking.
And since logic is the last part of philosophy to be desired and the first to be learned, it is easier for the student to start with the speeches (and the names which compose them) which are sensible. The senses come first in our knowledge.
Duane H. Berquist