← Library · Wisdom about Beginnings
Wonder Is the Beginning of Philosophy
Wisdom about Beginnings · Beginning of Philosophy in the Will
From his file: TEXTS ON WONDER_brief.doc.
Read from in 1 class
WONDER IS THE BEGINNING OF PHILOSOPHY
Democritus, DK 118:
I would rather discover one cause than be master of the kingdom of the Persians.
Plato, Theaetetus, 155C-D:
Theaetetus:
By the gods, Socrates, how greatly I wonder what these things are and sometimes when looking at them, I am really dizzy.
Socrates:
Theodorus seems to guess not badly about your nature, my friend. For this wonder is very much the undergoing of a philosopher. There is no other beginning of philosophy than this. And the one saying that Iris is the offspring of Thaumas did not make a bad genealogy. But do you begin to understand why these things are so?
Aristotle, Metaphysics, Proemium (Book One, Chapters1-3):
All men by nature desire to know. A sign is the love of the senses. For apart from their usefulness, they are loved for themselves; and especially among the others, that through the eyes. For we choose to see before all the others, not only that we might do something, but also when not aiming to do anything. The cause is that this one among the senses especially makes us know something and shows many differences.......
For men both now and at first began to philosophize through wonder - in the beginning, wondering about strange things close at hand; then going forward thus little by little, raising questions about the greater things, as about the changes of the moon and of the sun and stars, and about the origin of the universe.
But the man in doubt and wondering thinks himself to be ignorant. So the philomuthos is in some way a philosopher for the myth is put together from wonders. Hence, if men philosophized to escape ignorance, it is clear that they sought knowledge for the sake of understanding and not for any use. What happened witnesses this. When almost all necessary things and those for recreation and amusement existed, such knowledge began to be sought. So it is clear that we seek this knowledge through no other need....
WONDER OF THE SCIENTIST
Max Born, Natural Philosophy of Cause and Chance, Waynflete Lectures at Oxford, Dover Publications Inc., p. 128:
Science has undoubtedly two aspects: it can be regarded from the social standpoint as a practical collective endeavour for the improvement of human conditions, but it can also be regarded from the individualistic standpoint, as a pursuit of mental desires, the hunger for knowledge and understanding, a sister of art, philosophy and religion. Both aspects are justified, necessary and complementary. The collective enterprise of practical science consists in the end of individuals and cannot thrive without their devotion. But devotion does not suffice; nothing great can be achieved without the elementary curiosity of the philosopher.
Albert Einstein, “Autobiographical Notes”, in Albert Einstein: Philosopher-Scientist, Harper Torchbooks, Vol. I, pp. 3, 9, 11:
Even when I was a fairly precocious young man, the nothingness of the hopes and strivings which chases most men restlessly through life came to my consciousness with considerable vitality. Moreover, I soon discovered the cruelty of that chase, which in those years was much more carefully covered up by hypocrisy and glittering words than is the case today. By the mere existence of his stomach, everyone was condemned to participate in that chase. Moreover, it was possible to satisfy the stomach by such participation, but not man in so far as he is a thinking and feeling being...
For me it is not dubious that our thinking goes on for the most part without use of signs (words) and beyond that to a considerable degree unconsciously. For how, otherwise, should it happen that sometimes we ‘wonder’ quite spontaneously about some experience? This ‘wondering’ seems to occur when an experience comes into conflict with a world of concepts which is already sufficiently fixed in us. Whenever such a conflict is experienced hard and intensively, it reacts back upon our thought world in a decisive way. The development of this thought world is in a certain sense a continuous flight from "wonder".
A wonder of such a nature I experienced as a child of 4 or 5 years, when my father allowed me a compass. That this needle behaved in such a determined way did not at all fit into the nature of events, which could find a place in the unconscious world of concepts (effect connected with direct ‘touch’). I can still remember - or at least believe I can remember - that this experience made a deep and lasting impression upon me. Something deeply hidden had to be behind things. What man sees before him from infancy causes no reaction of this kind; he is not surprised over the falling of bodies, concerning wind and rain, nor concerning the moon or about the fact that the moon does not fall down, nor concerning the difference between living and non-living matter.
At the age of 12, I experienced a second wonder of a totally different nature: in a little book dealing with Euclidean plane geometry, which came into my hands at the beginning of a school year. Here were assertions, as for example the intersections of the three altitudes of a triangle in one point, which - though by no means evident - could nevertheless be proved with such certainty that any doubt appeared to be out of the question. This lucidity and certainty made an indescribable impression upon me...for anyone who experiences it for the first time, it is marvelous enough that man is capable at all to reach such a degree of certainty and purity in pure thinking as the Greeks showed us for the first time to be possible in geometry.
Albert Einstein, The World As I See It, 1931:
The most beautiful experience we can have is the mysterious. It is the fundamental emotion that stands at the cradle of true art and true science. Whoever does not know it and can no longer wonder, no longer marvel, is as good as dead, and his eyes are dimmed. It was the experience of mystery - even if mixed with fear - that engendered religion. A knowledge of the existence of something we cannot penetrate, our perceptions of the profoundest reason and the most radiant beauty, which only in their most primitive forms are accessible to our minds: it is this knowledge and this emotion which constitutes true religiosity. In this sense, and only in this sense, I am a deeply religious man...I am satisfied with the mystery of life’s eternity and with a knowledge, a sense, of the marvelous structure of existence - as well as the humble attempt to understand even a tiny portion of the Reason that manifests itself in nature.
Albert Einstein, Essays in......., p. 27:
Our admiration for this splendid man (Kepler) is accompanied by another feeling of admiration and reverence, the object of which is no man but the mysterious harmony of nature into which we are born.
Oskar Klein, “Glimpses of Niels Bohr as Scientist and Thinker” in Niels Bohr, His Life and Work As Seen By His Friends And Colleagues, ed. by S. Rozental, Wiley Interscience Publishers, N.Y., p. 74:
Bohr...developed a deep philosophical bent similar to that which seems to have characterized the early Greek natural philosophers.
Werner Heisenberg, “Planck’s Discovery and the Philosophical Problems of Atomic Physics” in the collection On Modern Physics, Collier Books, N.Y., p. 10:
there is today a struggle in the most diverse countries of the world and with the most powerful means at the disposal of modern technology to solve together problems posed two and a half millennia ago by the Greek philosophers.
Schrodinger, Nature and The Greeks, p. 56:
Curiosity is the stimulus. The first requirement of a scientist is to be curious. He must be capable of being astonished and eager to find out. Plato, Aristotle, and Epicurus emphasize the import of being astonished (thaumadzein).
A Conversation with Wiliam N. Lipscomb (Abbott and James Lawrence Professor of Chemistry at Harvard University where he has taught since 1959. He won the 1976 Nobel Prize in chemistry for his work on compounds known as boranes) in U.S. News & World Report, 1981. p. 85:
Because of the shortcomings of the educational process, people tend to think that scientists work by adding one fact to another. That is a misconception. A scientist proceeds in making discoveries in very much the same way that an artist goes about working. You have to master a large discipline, and your discoveries are not necessarily made by planning them. They arise intuitively. You suddenly perceive brand-new connections that you were unaware of before. Material somehow reorganizes itself in your mind, and that leads to the spawning of a new group of ideas.
One of the major problems in this process is not the lack of information but rather the abundance of contradictory material. You somehow have to see though the contradictions and fit the material together in a new way. Then, all of a sudden, things click. You begin to think, ‘Well, maybe there is something to it.’ The scientific method comes into play only after you make the intuitive jump. You use it to test your ideas - but not in the generation of the ideas.
Aesthetics in art and science are very much the same. The discoverers of the structure of proteins and of DNA - deoxyribonucleic acid - both used aesthetic criteria of beauty and simplicity in their work. Many scientists have commented on the aesthetics of what they do. The famous mathematician Hermann Weyl once said, "My work always tried to unite the true with the beautiful, but when I had to choose one or the other, I usually chose the beautiful."
One important aesthetic component of science is symmetry. It is a property that is obvious to someone who thinks about the construction of a symphony or the way a novel is put together; it is something less obvious in science. Yet all crystal structures are based on it. The law of conservation of energy is based on a symmetry principle, as are all of the conservation laws of physics. There are internal symmetries in particle physics. Human beings have nearly bilateral symmetry, and so does the pentagonal starfish. It is one of the common aethetic elements that pervades all of physical science, and it does so at a very deep and fundamental level.
WONDER OF THE PHILOMUTHOS
BOSWELL’S LIFE OF JOHNSON, Oxford University Press, 1961, Saturday, 30 July, 1763, pp. 323-324:
On Saturday, July 30, Dr. Johnson and I took a sculler at the Temple-stairs, and set out for Greenwich. I asked him if he really thought a knowledge of the Greek and Latin languages an essential requisite to a good education. JOHNSON: “Most certainly, Sir; it is wonderful what a difference learning makes upon most people even in the common intercourse of life, which does not appear to be much connected with it," "And yet, (said I) people go through the world very well, and carry on the business of life to good advantage, without learning." JOHNSON: "Why, Sir, that may be true in cases where learning cannot possibly be of any use; for instance, this boy rows us as well without learning, as if he could sing the song of Orpheus to the Argonauts, who were the first sailors." He then called to the boy, "What would you give, my lad, to know about the Argonauts?" "Sir, (said the boy) I would give what I have." Dr. Johnson then turning to me, "Sir, (said he) a desire of knowledge is the natural feeling of mankind; and every human being, whose mind is not debauched, will be willing to give all that he has to get knowledge."
WONDER OF THE HISTORIAN
George Macaulay Trevelyan, Illustrated English Social History, Volume One, Introduction to Complete Edition, pp. xii-xiii:
Disinterested intellectual curiosity is the life-blood of real civilization. Social history provides one of its best forms. At bottom, I think, the appeal of history is imaginative. Our imagination craves to behold our ancestors as they really were, going about their daily business and daily pleasure...there is nothing that more divides civilized from semi-savage man than to be conscious of our forefathers as they really were, and bit by bit to reconstruct the mosaic of the long-forgotten past. To weigh the stars, or to make ships sail in the air or below the sea, is not a more astonishing and ennobling performance on the part of the human race in these latter days, than to know the course of events that had been long forgotten, and the true nature of men and women who were here before us.
Arnold Toynbee, A Study of History, a new edition revised and abridged by the author and Jane Caplan, Oxford University Press, 1972, Foreword, pp. 10-11:
Mankind is surely going to destroy itself unless it succeeds in growing together into something like a single family. For this, we must become familiar with each other; and this means becoming familiar with each other's history, since Man does not live just in the immediate present. We live in a mental time-stream remembering the past and looking forward - with hope or fear - to an oncoming future. This present-day practical reason for studying history comprehensively is obvious and cogent.
But, even if we were not moved to study history by a concern for self-preservation, we should be moved by curiosity; for curiosity is one of the distinctive faculties of human nature. We should still feel curiosity about the Universe in which we find ourselves, even if we were completely prosperous and secure - and no human society, at any time or anywhere, has yet come within sight of attaining these two ideal goals.
I know this from my own experience. I have been prompted to study history by a life long curiosity. I was historical-minded from as early an age as I can remember. My mother was an historian, and her interest in history was infectious and stimulating. I was also brought up with a great-uncle who had been a sailor. He had been the captain of an East-Indiaman (a three-masted square-rigged sailing ship), and his stories of his voyages to India and China excited me. So, out of curiosity, I had been studying history from the start...
Arnold Toynbee, A Study of History, Chapter 54, "Historians in Action" a new edition revised and abridged by the author and Jane Caplan, Oxford University Press, 1972, pp. 489-490, 493, 494-495:
Curiosity is a distinctively human impulse...Without the impulse of curiosity, there cannot be intellectual action in any field....Since curiosity is the generator of intellectual action, an imperative and pertinacious curiosity is the intellectual worker's prime need. If his curiosity is strong enough, it can move mountains.
Curiosity that has borne fruit in the writing of history has sometimes been awakened by contemporary events, either public or personal to the historian or, in some cases, events of both kinds. The contemporary stimulus may be the fall of a great and famous city or the outbreak of a great and destructive war or the building of an empire whose architects have aspired to establish a literally worldwide world-state and have come within an ace of achieving their ambition. These dramatic experiences may inspire an historian to write the history of his own time and place; they may also lead him on to ground that lies far afield, in both dimensions, from his initial act of recording events within close range....
The impulse to write history may also be aroused by the experience of the outbreak of a great war.
Thucydides of Athens has written the history of the war betweeen the Peloponnesians and the Athenians. He began to write as soon as the war broke out, in the belief that this war would eclipse all its predecessors in importance.
Polybius is one of the historians whose curiosity has been stimulated by the rise, in his time, of a great empire.
What mind, however commonplace or indifferent, could feel no curiosity to learn the process by which almost the whole world fell under the undisputed ascendancy of Rome within a period of less than fifty-three years?
The still more rapid rise of the Achaemenian Persian Empire stimulated Herodotus, and the meteoric rise of the Mongol Empire stimulated two great Persian historians, 'Ala-ad-Din Juvayni (vivebat AD 1226-83) and Rashid-ad-Din al-Hamadani (vivebat c. AD 1247-1318) This fascinating spectacle led the historians whose curiosity had been excited by it to extend their field of observation still further to embrace as much of Mankind's habitat as lay within their horizon....
We have already noted the stimulation of Ibn Khaldun's and Volney's curiosity by their recognition of the Islamic World in their respective lifetimes and this region's former prosperity and grandeur. A similar experience inspired Gibbon to write The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire.
Sir Winston Churchill, The World Crisis, Part Three 1916-1918, Preface, Centenary Limited Edition, Vol. X, pp. 9, 11:
In dealing with a field so wide as that of the last three years of the World War, a highly selective process has been necessary. I have tried to find and follow the stepping-stones of Fate. I set myself at each stage to answer the questions "What happened, and Why?" I seek to guide the reader to those points where the course of events is being decided, whether it be on a battlefield, in a conningtower, in Council, in Parliament, in a lobby, a laboratory or a workshop...
In this present volume I try to present the reader at once with a comprehensive view of the mighty panorama and with a selection of its dominating features...I hope that the result will stimulate reflection upon the prodigious cataclysm which has shattered and re-shaped our life and the world we live in.
WONDER OF THE CHRISTIAN BELIEVER
THE GOSPEL ACCORDING TO ST. LUKE, CHAPTER TEN, VERSES 38-42:
Now it came to pass as they were on their journey, that he entered a certain village; and a woman named Martha welcomed him to her house. And she had a sister called Mary, who also seated herself at the Lord’s feet and listened to his word. But Martha was busy about much serving. And she came up and said. "Lord, is it no concern of thine that my sister has left me to serve alone? Tell her therefore to help me." But the Lord answered and said to her, "Martha, Martha, thou art anxious and troubled about many things; and yet only one thing is necessary. Mary has chosen the best part, and it will not be taken away from her."
THE GOSPEL ACCORDING TO ST. JOHN, CHAPTER SEVENTEEN, VERSES 1-3:
These things Jesus spoke; and raising his eyes to heaven, he said, "Father, the hour has come! Glorify thy Son, that thy Son may glorify thee, even as thou hast given him power over all flesh, in order that to all thou hast given him he may give everlasting life. Now this is everlasting life that they may know thee, the only true God, and him whom thou hast sent, Jesus Christ."
FIRST EPISTLE OF ST. JOHN, CHAPTER THREE, VERSE 2-3:
Beloved, now we are the children of God, and it has not yet appeared what we shall be. We know that, when he appears, we shall be like to him, for we shall see him just as he is.
CONSTITUTION ON THE SACRED LITURGY, N. 2, IN THE TEACHINGS OF THE SECOND VATICAN COUNCIL, THE NEWMAN PRESS, 1966, p.. 14:
It is of the essence of the Church that she be both human and divine, visible and yet invisibly equipped, eager to act and yet intent on contemplation, present in this world and yet not at home in it; and she is all these things in such wise that in her the human is directed and subordinated to the divine, the visible likewise to the invisible, action to contemplation, and this present world to that city yet to come which we seek.